Rumour Jake Carlisle to Carlton

Remove this Banner Ad

Royal Doulton said:
Agree it would strengthen... but additional strengthening required if a 1st year is expected to hold down CHB... and your two back pockets cant hit a pass...
Most pts against.. so definitely worth going hard at Carlisle.. but some speed and foot skill from backline is critical in my view to improving on current.. JC alone will not make a difference..
Click to expand...

Sam Rowe is a solid citizen but gets caught out from time to time but good cheap back up to have both end of the ground..

Buckley played that HBF role as line breaker which Yarran usually does. Hoping he plays across half forward.

Hoping to add Bailey Rice in the mix across half back.

One thing is for sure the Carlton team next season will be really young.
 
Royal Doulton said:
100% agree.. and trust me I know how it feels..
Hopefully the off field changes matches the same passion and drive that occured for us..
This finals series I was staggered at the amount of ex Blues who starred on the big stage... Jacobs. . Kennedy. .Betts.. Waite..
That has been blues recent demise.. poor leadership and decision-making
Click to expand...

Kennedy was traded for Judd, so I think we can state that as a win win for both clubs.
Jacobs wanted to go back to SA.
Waite didn't want to go through a rebuild and took a 2 year deal from North over a 1 year deal from us
Betts was a mistake. We should have tried harder to keep him.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

HBF said:
Kennedy was traded for Judd, so I think we can state that as a win win for both clubs.
Jacobs wanted to go back to SA.
Waite didn't want to go through a rebuild and took a 2 year deal from North over a 1 year deal from us
Betts was a mistake. We should have tried harder to keep him.
Click to expand...
Judd & Armfield for Josh Kennedy & Chris Masten...
The Win Win will certainly favour the eagles in the end... but I dont discount Judd is a champ.. and well worth any slight edge in who won the deal..
Jacobs wanted to go home because too much value was placed internally on Kruezer & Warnock...
Hopefully Blues go hard at rebuild this time for your sake.. shopping Krueze around shows good intent.. if it landed compo pick at 2.. goldmine!
Its hard enough to find match winners.. but to lose so many frm your squad must be frustrating...
 
Royal Doulton said:
Judd & Armfield for Josh Kennedy & Chris Masten...
The Win Win will certainly favour the eagles in the end... but I dont discount Judd is a champ.. and well worth any slight edge in who won the deal..
Jacobs wanted to go home because too much value was placed internally on Kruezer & Warnock...
Hopefully Blues go hard at rebuild this time for your sake.. shopping Krueze around shows good intent.. if it landed compo pick at 2.. goldmine!
Its hard enough to find match winners.. but to lose so many frm your squad must be frustrating...
Click to expand...

Judd did so much for the footy club, both on and off the field.
I think with a new pres, Trigg and SOS at the club the penny has finally dropped that we have to go through a full rebuild.
First time in a long time I feel like the club is heading in the right direction with no more idiotic deals like Thomas and Jones.
 
HBF said:
Judd did so much for the footy club, both on and off the field.
I think with a new pres, Trigg and SOS at the club the penny has finally dropped that we have to go through a full rebuild.
First time in a long time I feel like the club is heading in the right direction with no more idiotic deals like Thomas and Jones.
Click to expand...

Next minute, Carlton make a late play and come over the top of Melbourne to snag Melksham...

Royal Doulton said:
Bulldogs back in race...
Click to expand...

Because Talia is looking at leaving yeah?
 
I would only want Carlisle in the PSD if at all. Not keen on getting any players with bans hanging over their heads, considering we still wont know the Essendon players fate until after the trade period.
 
Blue1980 said:
I would only want Carlisle in the PSD if at all. Not keen on getting any players with bans hanging over their heads, considering we still wont know the Essendon players fate until after the trade period.
Click to expand...
Good call.. not ideal timing forthe Blues to take a punt on them being cleared of suspension...
I was thinking same for Bullies given Crameri is on board too.. but I feel our club needs to roll dice a little more..
 
Unearthing Hamling from Geelong reserves last pre season has given me more confidence that mature talent can be found to address holes.. but given Carlisle age and initial form as key back.. could be a good opp to lock down our bookends..
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Surely Footscray's SC space is getting awfully close to the max ?

Seems like its out of Carlton and St Kilda for Buckets
 
DaVillaBlues said:
Surely Footscray's SC space is getting awfully close to the max ?
Click to expand...
No, we're chipping in for Griffen this year to meet the minimum 95% cap.
We can pay 105% next year under AFL rules - we're heavily front loading contracts as it is (rumoured that over 25% of Boyd's 7 year deal will be paid in 2016 alone).
 
pinot said:
Sam Rowe is a solid citizen but gets caught out from time to time but good cheap back up to have both end of the ground..

Buckley played that HBF role as line breaker which Yarran usually does. Hoping he plays across half forward.

Hoping to add Bailey Rice in the mix across half back.

One thing is for sure the Carlton team next season will be really young.
Click to expand...
But does it have to be so young that we're uncompetitive? I understand we need a rebuild, but along with the kids, I can't see a problem with looking at blokes like Carlisle, maybe Talia now, Walker from the cats. A rebuild won't work if the kids don't get some support and learn to win. Otherwise there's a risk they will develop a losing culture/mentality.
 
TheCoach16 said:
But does it have to be so young that we're uncompetitive? I understand we need a rebuild, but along with the kids, I can't see a problem with looking at blokes like Carlisle, maybe Talia now, Walker from the cats. A rebuild won't work if the kids don't get some support and learn to win. Otherwise there's a risk they will develop a losing culture/mentality.
Click to expand...
Would you trade Gibbs to Port for pick 9?
 
sonnywalters said:
Would you trade Gibbs to Port for pick 9?
Click to expand...
I reckon Carlton would... me personally, if it were my call, no way in the world. I know there's plenty of player movement these days, but some blokes are part of the fibre of a club, for me Gibbs is that sort of player for Carlton.
Great question by the way.
 
Remember when Aaron Hamill had a choice between staying at Carlton or coming to us? Yeah think big Jake is gonna make the same choice ;)

No pick 4 this time though, and no Sam Cranage either :p
 
NathanMX said:
Remember when Aaron Hamill had a choice between staying at Carlton or coming to us? Yeah think big Jake is gonna make the same choice ;)

No pick 4 this time though, and no Sam Cranage either :p
Click to expand...
Not really the same thing. Once Hamill had decided to leave Carlton, he knew where he wanted to go. He was only faced with one decision, "stay or go"... Carlisle on the other hand is faced with two decisions 1. Stay or go? And 2. Where do I go now? He may very well choose the Saints, I would, but the two circumstances are quite different.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Kings of Lygon
Scandal Elijah Hollands (GC-Carlton): Posession of Illicit Substance
Replies
16
Views
3K
bradfisher14
bradfisher14
M
Rumour Simon Goodwin resigning today?
2 3 4 5
Replies
101
Views
13K
stinga82
S
T
Rumour AFL to buy / take control of regional AFL venue.
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
163
Views
9K
Bluez Rule
Bluez Rule
Slats
Scandal The AFL is aware of footage which shows Tom Hawkins looking at a phone during the rain break
2 3
Replies
51
Views
3K
SuperMal
SuperMal
LordLucifer
Ex-AFL agent Nixon too broke to pay assault case lawyer
2 3
Replies
74
Views
14K
FuManchu
FuManchu
Dazb86
Rumour Dodoro to Port Adelaide?
2
Replies
25
Views
4K
Outtatym
O
GC2015
Rumour Treloar considering a move to the Suns (again)
2
Replies
28
Views
8K
KERRPOW
KERRPOW

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top