Rank Richmond's Players from 1 to 30

[tigs2010]

List starts to fall away after the first 20 - yours, around the 10 mark.

Drops away at 1 after Relton

 

[Ralll]

1: Riewoldt
2: Rance
3: Deledio
4: Martin
5: Cotchin
6: Edwards
7: Maric
8: Miles
9: B. Ellis
10: Vickery
11: Houli
12: Yarran
13: Grimes
14: Vlastuin
15: Grigg
16: Conca
17: Chaplin
18: Batchelor
19: Astbury
20: McIntosh
21: Lennon
22: C. Ellis
23: Griffiths
24: Lloyd
25: Lambert
26: McBean
27: Menadue
28: Morris
29: Hunt
30: McKenzie

 

[DrMike]

List starts to fall away after the first 20 - yours, around the 10 mark.

This board has a "No Opposition Dickheads" policy.

Don't be a dickhead.

And I'm honestly surprised that wasn't picked up in swear filter, go figure.

 

[SplintWhisky]

Ok....Sam Lonergan?

Tom hislop and tambling have to make the list

 

[Nostradumbass]

I'd have Miles ahead of Ellis.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

1. Vlastuin
2. Grimes
3. Deledio
4. Martin
5. Ellis
6. Grigg
7. Lennon
8. Riewoldt
9. Cotchin
10. Edwards
11. Batchelor
12. Astbury
13. Yarran
14. Houli
15. Moore
16. Hampson
17. Rioli
18. Rance
19. Who cares
20. Maric
21. Townsend
22. Who cares
23. Lambert
24. Griffiths
25. Chaplin
26. Miles
27. Lloyd
28. Hunt
29. Vickery
30. Conca

 

[DrMike]

Thread discussion is fine but keep it about Richmond. If nothing much comes from it I'll just merge it with the "Best 22" thread.

N.O.D. policy has been enforced and he's not welcome back to his own thread.

 

[Rubber Hips]

Someone include the goo

 

[Tiger Toffee]

Thread discussion is fine but keep it about Richmond. If nothing much comes from it I'll just merge it with the "Best 22" thread.

N.O.D. policy has been enforced and he's not welcome back to his own thread.

On the rampage, is that heatwave taking a toll on you folk over in the west.

 

[DrMike]

On the rampage, is that heatwave taking a toll on you folk over in the west.

It's just a dry heat, no big deal.

 

[Tetley Tigers]

I've done mine with importance to the team in mind plus the usual criteria

1. Rance
2. Deledio
3. Riewoldt
4. Martin
5. Cotchin
6. Edwards
7. Miles
8. Maric
9. Houli
10. Vickery
11. Vlastuin
12. Grigg
13. Chaplin
14. Grimes
15. Yarran
16. Ellis B
17. Rioli
18. Conca
19. Hunt
20. Ellis C
21. Griffiths
22. Batchelor
23. McIntosh
24. Astbury
25. Lambert
26. McBean
27. Lloyd
28. Hampson
29. Lennon
30. Menedue


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[CHIMP MAGNET]

gus graham > nic nat

 

[CoggaRules]

Someone include the goo

and we we cant forget the Kont too.

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

1. rance
2. cotch
3. jack
4. dusty
5. martin
6. lids
7. Edwards
8. miles
9. b ellis
10. houli
11. yaz (could go higher or lower depending on how long it takes to get the carltank out of him)
12.vickery
13.grimes
14. grigg
15. maric (was higher but body is shot still one of our most important)
16.vlas
17.grimes
18. McIntosh
19.lennon
20. lambert
21. griff
22.batch
23.c.ellis
24.astbury
25. conca
26.hunt
27. Menadue
28. mcbean
29. Lloyd
30.moore

 

[Severe]

I'd talk about about Relton but a couple of my ReltRob posts got deleted for some reason, so I will do this.
1. Rance
2. Deledio
3. Riewoldt
4. Martin
5. Cotchin
6. Edwards
7. Miles
8. Maric
9. Houli
10. Vickery
11. Vlastuin
12. Grigg
13. Chaplin
14. Grimes
15. Yarran
16. Ellis B
17. Rioli
18. Conca
19. Hunt
20. Ellis C
21. Griffiths
22. Batchelor
23. McIntosh
24. Astbury
25. Lambert
26. McBean
27. Lloyd
28. Hampson
29. Lennon
30. Menedue

Even though I rate The Relt higher.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Townsend will be the highest ranked 2015 recruit by this seasons end .

 

[Wallaby]

1. rance
2. cotch
3. jack
4. dusty
5. martin
6. lids
7. Edwards
8. miles
9. b ellis
10. houli
11. yaz (could go higher or lower depending on how long it takes to get the carltank out of him)
12.vickery
13.grimes
14. grigg
15. maric (was higher but body is shot still one of our most important)
16.vlas
17.grimes
18. McIntosh
19.lennon
20. lambert
21. griff
22.batch
23.c.ellis
24.astbury
25. conca
26.hunt
27. Menadue
28. mcbean
29. Lloyd
30.moore

I was about to say our Top 7 is pretty clear, and then I noticed you had Miles at No 8. It took a while for me to spot that you'd listed Martin twice (I mean, I know he's good, but......)

 

[TheDyerLegacy]

1. Rance
2. Martin
3. Deledio
4. Riewoldt
5. Cotchin
6. Miles
7. Vlastuin
8. B. Ellis
9. Edwards
10. Houli
11. Vickery
12. Maric
13. Yarran
14. Grimes
15. Grigg
16. McIntosh
17. Townsend
18. Conca
19. Lennon
20. Chaplin
21. Batchelor
22. Astbury
23. Hampson
24. Lambert
25. Lloyd
26. Hunt
27. A.Moore
28. Griffiths
29. C.Ellis
30. Marcon

 

[TigerImposter]

1. Rance
2. Maric (crucial bc no real replacement)
3. Jack
4.Miles (Rate his value higher than lids and Cotch bc he's a man of all seasons)
5.Martin
6. Lids
7. Cotchin
8 .Grimes (Only worthwhile helper for Rance)
9. Flossy(Seriously needed to step up in the midfield for hardness.Too slow and nonreactive for defense)
10.Vickery(needs to step up to chop out for Maric so makes him valuable)
11.Griffiths (to replace Chaplin)
12.Edwards
13.McIntosh(moves as our hard rebounding backman in Flossy spot)
14.Houli
15. B Ellis
16.Lennon (Looked good last year and is ready body wise to take his game to another level.Tough as nails)
17 C.Ellis (A natural and will automatically improve us
18. Townsend(To come off the bench and chop out for Miles Cotchin or Flossy)
19.Mcbean(needs to start putting pressure on TV or Grifiths if they bludge around.The time has come)
20.Elton (to replace Chaplin)
21.Yarran(could go higher or lower depending on if he can recapture his old form)
22.Lambert
23.Rioli (must play v inferior teams to fast track his development-crucial as we need a small fwd)
24.Lloyd (needs to grab the small fwd spot if Rioli needs resting)
25. Conca(enough said)
26. McKenzie(Powerhouse unit who could be a big improver.Hopefully he put pressure on our tall fwds come midseason
27. Menadue
28.Grigg (needs to phased out as he's a no show pony when the whips are cracking)
29 Chaplin(needs to phased out as he's an expensive liability)
30 Short (love the way this kid rolls along .Could surprise a few on here)

 

[tigs2010]

List starts to fall away after the first 20 - yours, around the 10 mark.

LOL.

 

[Charlie Pannam]

1. Rance

29 Chaplin(needs to phased out as he's an expensive liability)
30 Short (love the way this kid rolls along .Could surprise a few on here)

You might have Chaplin a bit high TI

 

[Charlie Pannam]

1 Reiwoldt (our only A grade forward)
2 Rance
3 Martin
4 Deledio
5 Cotchin
6 Edwards
7 Miles
8 Ellis
9 Vickery
10 Houli
11 McIntosh
12 Maric
13 Yarran
14 Vlastuin
15 Conca
16 Grimes
17 C Ellis
18 Lennon
19 Grigg
20 Griffiths
21 Townsend
22 Menadue
23 McBean
24 Hampson
25 McKenzie
26 Lloyd
27 Rioli
28 Moore
29 Hunt
30 Lambert

 

[TigerImposter]

You might have Chaplin a bit high TI

Replace with Chol.

 

[Phoenix_9]

Chaplin seems to be the enigma on your board. Some think he's top 15, others want him out of the team and as depth.

Does anyone realistically expect Dimma not to play him in 2016?

I think realistically he will be in fhe team for 2016. Maybe phased out next year. He's still playing well enough and apparently now he's versatile. Probably as good as Griffiths as a forward, and as good as Astbury as a defender. Therefore probably plays in front of one of them due to being able to swing to both ends of the ground.

 

[Da_Pin]

We've had plenty of rank players

less so now though.