News Scharenberg Update

[Apex36]

Bit harsh for mine.

He was good on the much bigger Ambrose on Saturday and has taken some legitimate steps forward this year.

He's behind Martin, but far from the clogger that many had him pegged for going into 2014. Second best small defender in the VFL line up behind Williams ATM, IMO

Never said he hadn't improved. Just not enough to warrant an upgrade, especially since we seem to have bucketloads of defenders all of a sudden.

 

[Scodog10]

Never said he hadn't improved. Just not enough to warrant an upgrade, especially since we seem to have bucketloads of defenders all of a sudden.

Yep and I never stated that you hadn't said he'd improved either

My assessment of you being harsh was with the bolded not that you don't rate Yagmoor or anything. He's done enough to be upgraded just not ahead of Martin.

If we were running a depth chart on small defenders currently he would be ahead of Ramsay, Clarke, Armstrong and Sinclair (because of injury) which leaves him behind only Williams, Toovey and Langdon (I haven't included Fasolo because I have no idea where he's at).

 

[Hardas]

It's off topic, but this is what I expect from the AFL Carlton on Friday night. Groveling at the feet of their Magpie overlords

Off topic, you say?

Surely, it's always at the back of our minds, whatever the actual topic.

 

[MyManLynch]

Silly me, I clicked on the 'Scharenberg Update' thread expecting to read an update on Scharenberg.

 

[Temploar]

Silly me, I clicked on the 'Scharenberg Update' thread expecting to read an update on Scharenberg.

Scharen-who?

 

[Number 10]

Excellent.

I'll be sure to bookmark June 7th against Casey for his return/debut.

So are you going? Playing next week in the vfl

 

[MagpieBat]

So are you going? Playing next week in the vfl

Am aiming to. Currently scouring the wardrobe for heavy warm clothing. Casey Fields is a windy hole.

 

[TradeDraft]

So are you going? Playing next week in the vfl

I be there, My Dad will be coming too

 

[vjknight]

Am aiming to. Currently scouring the wardrobe for heavy warm clothing. Casey Fields is a windy hole.

my arse.................oh wait.

 

[Lefthanded]

So are you going? Playing next week in the vfl

Great to hear, just wondering about your source (I couldn't see anything from a quick look on the website)

 

[joefootylover]

he is listed at 3 - 4 weeks on the injury list. So he won't be playing v Casey.

 

[TradeDraft]

he is listed at 3 - 4 weeks on the injury list. So he won't be playing v Casey.

Highly Doubtful

 

[Number 10]

Great to hear, just wondering about your source (I couldn't see anything from a quick look on the website)

My initial source was someone who works for Collingwood.

My source about the return this week was regurgitated from another thread. It was wrong...