The Official "What is this player worth?" Thread.

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Jack is easily better than McCartin and Wright, same goes for Aish, Kelly, Bontempelli and Boyd.

you dont get it, they are untried at A.F.L level for starters and they are not better when the club with say number one pick has crumbing forwards or mids in big supplies..so in saying that i would take Wright or Macartin over billings, Aish, Kelly as a dogs member but maybe not over Boyd or Bonti.

 

[eth-dog]

Majak Daw
Cam O'Shea
Darcy Gardiner
James Frawley
Michael Hibberd

Hibberd signed a 3 year deal earlier in the year. Won't go.

HF: Breust, Roughead, Lewis
FF: Puopolo, Carlisle, Gunston

That would be unstoppable.

Billings, in this draft, would fetch Pick 1.

Would rather

HB Hodge, Carlisle, Gibson
FB Stratton, Lake, Suckling

Doesn't matter, Carlisle won't leave.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Hibberd signed a 3 year deal earlier in the year. Won't go.



Doesn't matter, Carlisle won't leave.

If you followed Hawthorn you would be saying he will leave and go hawkers get him...

 

[eth-dog]

If you followed Hawthorn you would be saying he will leave and go hawkers get him...

Well considering his manager quashed the rumours within hours of them coming out...

 

[cotter101]

Hibberd signed a 3 year deal earlier in the year. Won't go.



Doesn't matter, Carlisle won't leave.

Hibberd would never leave Essendon unless he was forced too. Know him personally. Loves the club.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Well considering his manager quashed the rumours within hours of them coming out...

Oh you and i and everybody else knows managers don't speak the truth, he might not go but to say he is staying because his manager said so is like saying i believe Lawyers always tell the truth.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Well considering his manager quashed the rumours within hours of them coming out...

And also please read the topic of the thread, its called WHATS IS THIS PLAYER WORTH, not are they leaving.

 

[eth-dog]

Hibberd would never leave Essendon unless he was forced too. Know him personally. Loves the club.

Great to hear. Love him down at bomberland.

Oh you and i and everybody else knows managers don't speak the truth, he might not go but to say he is staying because his manager said so is like saying i believe Lawyers always tell the truth.

So despite all the evidence pointing to him staying, he's leaving.

And also please read the topic of the thread, its called WHATS IS THIS PLAYER WORTH, not are they leaving.

Why mention players that aren't going to leave?

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Great to hear. Love him down at bomberland.

So despite all the evidence pointing to him staying, he's leaving.

Why mention players that aren't going to leave?

Oh good lord good night

 

[eth-dog]

Oh good lord good night

Forgot that it's a school day tomorrow, you must need to get to bed soon

 

[Oddhawk]

Read the topic line bud....

What is Hibbard worth? Wouldn't think better than pick 30

 

[eth-dog]

Read the topic line bud....

What is Hibbard worth? Wouldn't think better than pick 30

Okay, what's Roughead worth? Hodge? Mitchell?

Hibberd? 1st round pick easily

 

[Oddhawk]

Hodge I'd say 30 odd, Mitchell slightly more.

Roughy is well out of your league top 3 pick

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Forgot that it's a school day tomorrow, you must need to get to bed soon

your a moron.... serious stuff there.

 

[Oddhawk]

Okay, what's Roughead worth? Hodge? Mitchell?

Hibberd? 1st round pick easily

You bomber boys do alright at over valuing your players. Would give Hibbard no higher value than Suckling... So 20-25 tops!!

 

[cotter101]

You bomber boys do alright at over valuing your players. Would give Hibbard no higher value than Suckling... So 20-25 tops!!

Hibberd is easily worth a first round pick.

 

[Oddhawk]

And Lisle was worth pick 30

Only a **** recruiting team would pay that!!

 

[eth-dog]

your a moron.... serious stuff there.

Learn proper spelling and grammar before making statements like that.

You bomber boys do alright at over valuing your players. Would give Hibbard no higher value than Suckling... So 20-25 tops!!

Hibberd (it's an "e", not an "a") is easily worth a 1st round pick. Good defender, excellent reading of the play and an excellent kick. He's equal to Andrew Mackie.

 

[Oddhawk]

Easily suggests we're talking inside the top 12....

Wow....
Just wow...

 

[eth-dog]

Easily suggests we're talking inside the top 12....

Wow....
Just wow...

Averaged 24.05 disposals (more than Birchall), 6.25 marks (more than Birchall) and 4.3 R50's (more than Birchall) over the past 2 years. Birchall is widely regarded as one of the best HBF's in the AFL. Hibberd is definitely worth a 1st round pick

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Learn proper spelling and grammar before making statements like that.

Hibberd (it's an "e", not an "a") is easily worth a 1st round pick. Good defender, excellent reading of the play and an excellent kick. He's equal to Andrew Mackie.

Learn proper spelling and grammar before making statements like that.

Hibberd (it's an "e", not an "a") is easily worth a 1st round pick. Good defender, excellent reading of the play and an excellent kick. He's equal to Andrew Mackie.

You were commenting on a thread you didn't know what the topic was about and you are chastising me about grammar, you have no idea do you?

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Hibberd would never leave Essendon unless he was forced too. Know him personally. Loves the club.

Oh boy, some mothers do have them

 

[eth-dog]

You were commenting on a thread you didn't know what the topic was about and you are chastising me about grammar, you have no idea do you?

No, I wasn't unaware what the topic was, I was simply pointing out the pointlessness of asking about players that won't leave the club. The equivalent of asking how much Ryan Griffen would cost.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

No, I wasn't unaware what the topic was, I was simply pointing out the pointlessness of asking about players that won't leave the club. The equivalent of asking how much Ryan Griffen would cost.

If it was a pointless thread then why would you enter it? i have already put down a few Bulldog players, its called harmless banter. Its not called put down names of players to rile people up thread

 

[eth-dog]

If it was a pointless thread then why would you enter it? i have already put down a few Bulldog players, its called harmless banter. Its not called put down names of players to rile people up thread

It's not a pointless thread. Players like Jarryd Lyons from Adelaide or Jack Watts are worthy of discussion, not payers like Ryan Griffen or Jake Carlisle. Comprender?