Trades: Round 9

[foley4brownlow]

quick question which would be better-

getting chapman and wellingham or- brad johnson and cotchin

 

[samwise]

Or Hill to Chapman.

mm but i was thinking more of waiting on hill and tradin him to valenti and wait till he gets to hill's price as both are much more certain to have spots in their teams than pfieffer.
also if pfeiffer doesnt play would you still say that?

hill to bj/chapman
or
pfeiffer to johncock/pburg/jking/bock/sfisher
or
hill to valenti
or
wait a week and trade pfeiffer to chornes
??

 

[Cat for Life]

mm but i was thinking more of waiting on hill and tradin him to valenti and wait till he gets to hill's price as both are much more certain to have spots in their teams than pfieffer.
also if pfeiffer doesnt play would you still say that?

hill to bj/chapman
or
pfeiffer to johncock/pburg/jking/bock/sfisher
or
hill to valenti
or
wait a week and trade pfeiffer to chornes
??

You need to get Hill out ASAP, he's dropping value fast. Normally Hill to Valenti would be ok, but you already have Stokes and Sellar doing nothing on your bench so I would rather upgrade than down grade.

Pfeiffer for Cornes is a good trade but if Pfeiffer is getting games can wait a 2-3 more weeks. Courtney Dempsey is out LT so I would be looking to get rid of him.

This is what I suggest:
This week - Hill to BJ/Chappy; Dempsey to Wellingham/Cotchin (can wait another week with this).

Down the track: Pfeiffer to Cornes.

Haven't done the maths, so not sure if getting Chapman and Cotchin would leave you enough cash for Cornes.

 

[samwise]

This is what I suggest:
This week - Hill to BJ/Chappy; Dempsey to Wellingham/Cotchin (can wait another week with this).

Down the track: Pfeiffer to Cornes.

Haven't done the maths, so not sure if getting Chapman and Cotchin would leave you enough cash for Cornes.

definately wouldnt as chapman loses me money and cotchin does nothing.

i could do hill to chapman and then browne to valenti where i would have about 145-160 depending on browne's increase.

then at best i would have 330k with pfeiffer, needing 431k for chad. i dont think pfeiffer and chad will make up that difference and i definately aint counting on it.

so do you think anything is better than hill to valenti and pfeiffer to sfisher/johncock/bock?

 

[kenny712]

Is it worth upgrading Palmer to Bartel next week? Having a hard time deciding on whether to keep or trade Palmer. My centres are currently: [Palmer], Hayes, Kornes, Murphy, Stevens, Cross (Masten)(Browne). In order to upgrade to Bartel, I would need to downgrade Masten for Cotchin. Thoughts?

 

[Butane]

Is it worth upgrading Palmer to Bartel next week? Having a hard time deciding on whether to keep or trade Palmer.

Wouldn't worry about that for a few weeks. Palmer is still going up and there's no sign of stopping just yet. Look else where for trades at the moment. It will become clearer over the next few weeks if Palmer can hold down the 6th midfielder position.

 

[Hirdy_5]

Not yet. Will start climbing in price again with Guerra and Crawford out. Give him a few more weeks then trade him.

Yeah spot on, And hopefully with Cornes to return this week against Sydney and with a High b/e, an Ellis to Cornes trade looks good in a few weeks..

 

[Cat for Life]

definately wouldnt as chapman loses me money and cotchin does nothing.

i could do hill to chapman and then browne to valenti where i would have about 145-160 depending on browne's increase.

then at best i would have 330k with pfeiffer, needing 431k for chad. i dont think pfeiffer and chad will make up that difference and i definately aint counting on it.

so do you think anything is better than hill to valenti and pfeiffer to sfisher/johncock/bock?

There's a risk that Valenti will get demoted, and then you're stuck with 3 non playing rookies, even in the best case scenario that he plays the whole year you will need to upgrade him later on anyway. Pfeiffer to those 3 is finde, but you'll need to get Chad in at some point.

 

[notshown]

hey guys i need help with the following trade

since guerra is out for a month ( i really thought he was a keeper and will average top few off the baks )

i was thinking to either birchell or milburn. since they both are the most consistent of any that are presented to me

i would get milburn by the fact that he costs less but after trading out guerra i will have no hawks players which is disappointing since hawks are flying in afl and dreamteam. in cats i have steve johnson and harry taylor (starting becuz of waters) and soon to have bartel. i kno they dont effect milburns score but im still not sure.

if you were in my situation wot would u do?

 

[Hirdy_5]

I agree Salopek is a waste but there's just something about seeing your team with the big boys in it that is somewhat comforting.

I still dont think he can sustain his early form.

On the other hand, Lade is about as useful as a penis flavoured lollipop

And somebody watches the movie " Dodgeball " far too much...

 

[samwise]

There's a risk that Valenti will get demoted, and then you're stuck with 3 non playing rookies, even in the best case scenario that he plays the whole year you will need to upgrade him later on anyway. Pfeiffer to those 3 is finde, but you'll need to get Chad in at some point.

surely there is no way valenti will get dropped. really struggle to see it. i know i will have to upgrade him but i will have made money and end up having a better team for it as he will get as good a scores as hill is.

so anyone disagree with
hill to valenti(starting)
pfeiffer to johncock/fisher/bock
+$50k to $90k

other options are
ugrade hill and leave pfeiffer
or leave pfieffer and hope he and chornes can make up 30k next week to trade then
or trade stokes or browne to valenti this week or next to allow me to get brad johnson for hill and johncock/fisher/bock for pfeiffer

 

[Hirdy_5]

hey guys i need help with the following trade

since guerra is out for a month ( i really thought he was a keeper and will average top few off the baks )

i was thinking to either birchell or milburn. since they both are the most consistent of any that are presented to me

i would get milburn by the fact that he costs less but after trading out guerra i will have no hawks players which is disappointing since hawks are flying in afl and dreamteam. in cats i have steve johnson and harry taylor (starting becuz of waters) and soon to have bartel. i kno they dont effect milburns score but im still not sure.

if you were in my situation wot would u do?

I currently have the both of them in my backline, and as you sayed they are bother very consistant, apart from the shocker Milburn pulled out a few weeks back, Now with Guerra out does this effect Birchalls role in the team in anyway ? More attacking/ Running ? Or More defensive ? Or just stay the same ? But to answer your question on who i would pick if i was in your shoes i would go with Birchall but i don't think it would make a differance either way...

 

[paramore]

If Cornes plays and if pfeiffer/sdthompson plays, then im not tradin this week.

 

[Hirdy_5]

surely there is no way valenti will get dropped. really struggle to see it. i know i will have to upgrade him but i will have made money and end up having a better team for it as he will get as good a scores as hill is.

so anyone disagree with
hill to valenti(starting)
pfeiffer to johncock/fisher/bock
+$50k to $90k

other options are
ugrade hill and leave pfeiffer
or leave pfieffer and hope he and chornes can make up 30k next week to trade then
or trade stokes or browne to valenti this week or next to allow me to get brad johnson for hill and johncock/fisher/bock for pfeiffer

When Grimes comes back either one of him or Woonermirri has to go back onto the Rookie list, and with the form that Woonermirri has been in latley i would say that he would be staying...

 

[Butane]

If CCornes plays i'll do:

Rioli --> Chapman
Houli --> L.Hayes

Time to start beefing up my team. Will also be in the bottom half of the Eliminator game this week so i need to surprise the 'better' opponent this week.

 

[Geeves Train]

Only trade i'll be doing this week is Barlow > Milburn, Fisher, Goddard, Birchall..

Leaning towards Sammy Fisher at the moment, can anyone convince me otherwise???

 

[samwise]

When Grimes comes back either one of him or Woonermirri has to go back onto the Rookie list, and with the form that Woonermirri has been in latley i would say that he would be staying...

grimes is on the long term injury list??

 

[KouDogg]

And somebody watches the movie " Dodgeball " far too much...

Actually he doesn't watch it enough because he got the quote wrong.

Its c**k flavoured lollipop, not P***s flavoured lollipop .

 

[apple]

Only trade i'll be doing this week is Barlow > Milburn, Fisher, Goddard, Birchall..

Leaning towards Sammy Fisher at the moment, can anyone convince me otherwise???

Would go with Birchall for consistancy. Should post up some bigger scores in the near future, and rarely ever gets a low score.

 

[force65]

Rioli---->ROK

then next week
Bird---->Cotchin and Gamble---->Valenti

then then week after

Jack----->Corey or another gun midfielder

This will leave me with my team looking like this:

Shaw Burgoyne Johncock Milburn Goddard Cornes Waters Int: Ibbotson Proud

Corey Cross Murphy Johnstone Stevens Palmer Int: Cotchin Wonaemirri

Simmonds Mcintosh Int: Kreuzer Meeson

Pavlich Brown Riewoldt O'Keefe Didak Mooney Porplyzia
Int: Tippett Valenti

At this stage I will have 9 trades left

The bolded players are the people I might need to upgrade if need be

Thoughts would be much appreciated

 

[freckles]

Backline woes = losing first place in my league

Scored atrociously this week due to backline injuries - can't afford another shocker so need advice on who to trade. Thinking Kennelly and Symes at the moment (this week), then will still need a decent but cheap back-up player later (thinking Myers/Ibbotson).

DEF: Shaw, Goddard, Gram, Cornes, Symes, Kennelly, Wona, Proud, Selwood

Happy with my mids/forwardd....Have 13 trades and $55K in the bank - so if I trade Kennelly and Symes I could get two guns.

1) Which player would you trade?
2) Which players (2) would you pick: Burgoyne, Milbun, Johncock, Guerra, Birchall, someone else??

Cheers!

 

[Deez Baby]

Rioli---->ROK

then next week
Bird---->Cotchin and Gamble---->Valenti

then then week after

Jack----->Corey or another gun midfielder

This will leave me with my team looking like this:

Shaw Burgoyne Johncock Milburn Goddard Cornes Waters Int: Ibbotson Proud

Corey Cross Murphy Johnstone Stevens Palmer Int: Cotchin Wonaemirri

Simmonds Mcintosh Int: Kreuzer Meeson

Pavlich Brown Riewoldt O'Keefe Didak Mooney Porplyzia
Int: Tippett Valenti

At this stage I will have 9 trades left

The bolded players are the people I might need to upgrade if need be

Thoughts would be much appreciated

In my opinion

I would get rid of mooney very quickly

even before you get rid of rioli

 

[Ferg720]

In my opinion

I would get rid of mooney very quickly

even before you get rid of rioli

Who would you upgrade to chapman out of mooney or monfries? what is a bigger priority? (i have 110, 000 in the bank so not enough to upgrade rioli)

 

[force65]

In my opinion

I would get rid of mooney very quickly

even before you get rid of rioli

IMO mooney can increase in price more than rioli.
mooneys start of the season has not been great but the reason for his low scores have been for his inaccurate kicking ....while rioli i think will struggle to stay at his price because teams are beginning to notice him and hes gonna be played more tightly....he is no ball magnet

that is my reasoning behind me trading rioli b4 mooney

 

[TDub23]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ok so heres my dilemma, I want to do

This week Out: Houli In: Wellingham

Next week out: Masten In: Swan

Week After Out: Gamble (7th forward) In: BJ/SJ

Going by xalia these trades should all be right to do but my 7th and 8th mids will be wellingham and Browne and i will have 7 trades left for injuries, what should i do?