The official "X v Y" thread

[munk3ymark]

Last piece of the puzzle -


Houlihan, Otten, (Anthony, Robinson) <-- Bench

VS

Frawley/Henderson/Geary (not sure who), Rich (Otten, Anthony) <--Bench


Cheers.

The latter (probs Geary or Henderson of the first three, although Frawley is more likely to play most games) might get you a better average between the two starters, but Houilhan does have the potential for much higher scores than any of the other individual players, so if you take the former you can chop and change the other lads depending on how well they're travelling.

 

[Parasite]

Taylor Walker vs Wade Thompson?

 

[Judd_Magic]

just on the radio, "cox and goddard will certainly not play" FOX FM​

Serious???????????????

Now I am wondering if I should ditch Goddard?? Hmmm!

 

[The Voice of Sport]

Serious???????????????

Now I am wondering if I should ditch Goodard?? Hmmm!

Mate check the other posts. He has posted 3 different sources for this on differerent threads, as well as saying Rich has done his hammy.

Some people don't have a life. Can the mods do something re this pest?

 

[Fitty]

Hodge - Judd - Chad Cornes

or

Hodge - Scotland - Sam Fisher

 

[hazzaman101]

Kerr v Gibbs v Kane Cornes

 

[hawker21]

C Newman (2nd Back) and W Thompson (9th Forward) vs

P Burgoyne (4th Back) and J Ziebell (7th Forward)

 

[goodie23]

Pondering over J. Riewoldt (Rich) vs. J. Kennedy (WCE)

 

[Biggie]

Pondering over J. Riewoldt (Rich) vs. J. Kennedy (WCE)

Yuk.

Kennedy isnt worth it. Cant stay on the park long enough.

Jack will struggle in the new rolling zone type game plan.

 

[Hazey1977]

Hasleby or Tuck? Hasleby surely in Freo's best 22, is Tuck in Hawks best 22?

 

[Biggie]

Haselby for mine.

Everyone thinks Tuck.

Paul will be keen as mustard to get back into and has a great kick.

Tuck is good contested ball player.

Tuck for $ I guess but I rate Haselby.

 

[munk3ymark]

Hasleby or Tuck? Hasleby surely in Freo's best 22, is Tuck in Hawks best 22?

Give him a couple of games and he will be

 

[weagles_fan]

Should I pick N Krakouer or Houlihan?

 

[Hazey1977]

Should I pick N Krakouer or Houlihan?

For no particular reason than personal preference I would go for Krakouer. Houlihan could be an option in your backline?

 

[Teak_Pies]

Higgins vs N Krakouer

 

[Biggie]

Higgins vs N Krakouer

Higgins.

 

[Windas_Magic]

Higgins vs N Krakouer

Higgins.

White V Jacobs?

T.Tuck V Masten?

Hill V Henderson?

 

[weagles_fan]

For no particular reason than personal preference I would go for Krakouer. Houlihan could be an option in your backline?

Can't afford putting him in the backline and then getting Krakouer in the forwards so have to just put one of them in the forwards.

 

[Teak_Pies]

Jacobs and masten

Enright vs newman

 

[Daniels]

Higgins.

White V Jacobs?

T.Tuck V Masten?

Hill V Henderson?

Maybe a lil late but...

Jacobs

Tuck

Henderson

 

[SJ]

Rank in order:
- Rich
- Otten
- Anthony
- Robinson
- Beams

 

[Parasite]

Rank in order:
- Rich
- Otten
- Anthony
- Robinson
- Beams

Anthony
Beams
Otten
Rich
Robinson

Alphabetical?

 

[Teak_Pies]

Didak vs Fevola vs Roughhead vs S Johnson

 

[Roos4eva]

Foley vs Griffen? (Griffen about 30k cheaper)

 

[Teak_Pies]

Foley

Griffen is to inconsistent