What is our best 22 this year?

[themidlandmaster]

today we saw another young player debut in mooney who looked really good. to me, Elliot and Sinclair have done enough to be considered best 22 from now on.

What does everyone think our best 22 is now? Are any of didak, krakouer or macaffer best 22?


Shaw. Brown/Tarrant Toovey
OBRien Reid. Johnson
Jolly. Swan. Pendles
Thomas Sidebotom Wellingham
Beams Cloke Elliot
Sinclair Dawes Fasolo

Blair Maxwell Goldsack Didak

 

[Jelly Bean]

today we saw another young player debut in mooney who looked really good. to me, Elliot and Sinclair have done enough to be considered best 22 from now on.

What does everyone think our best 22 is now? Are any of didak, krakouer or macaffer best 22?


Shaw. Brown/Tarrant Toovey
OBRien Reid. Johnson
Jolly. Swan. Pendles
Thomas Sidebotom Wellingham
Beams Cloke Elliot
Sinclair Dawes Fasolo

Blair Maxwell Goldsack Didak

The way you have written it is confusing. It looks like you have Sidebottom at CHF, Jolly on a wing, and Sinkers in the ruck....

 

[Jelly Bean]

The way you have written it is confusing. It looks like you have Sidebottom at CHF, Jolly on a wing, and Sinkers in the ruck....

B: O'Brien, Brown, Toovey
HB: Maxwell, Reid, Shaw
C: Thomas, Beams, Sidebottom
HF: Fasolo, Cloke, Didak
F: Tarrant, Dawes, Sinclair
Fol: Jolly, Pendles, Swan
IC: Blair, Wellingham, Clarke, Goldsack.

 

[themidlandmaster]

The way you have written it is confusing. It looks like you have Sidebottom at CHF, Jolly on a wing, and Sinkers in the ruck....

Yeah, I never understand why rucks are written down the bottom instead of the middle

 

[Knightmare]

Mine changes with every week.

Right now I'd go with:
B: Alan Toovey Nathan Brown Chris Tarrant
HB: Harry O'Brien Ben Reid Nick Maxwell
CEN: Heath Shaw Scott Pendlebury Steele Sidebottom
HF: Alan Didak Travis Cloke Dane Swan
F: Jamie Elliott Chris Dawes Tyson Goldsack
FOLL: Darren Jolly Dayne Beams Dale Thomas
BENCH: Sharrod Wellingham Jarryd Blair Marty Clarke
SUB: Ben Sinclair
Unlucky and still without a doubt in the mix: Alex Fasolo Caolan Mooney Jackson Paine Marley Williams

 

[Jelly Bean]

Mine changes with every week.

Right now I'd go with:
B: Alan Toovey Nathan Brown Chris Tarrant
HB: Harry O'Brien Ben Reid Nick Maxwell
CEN: Heath Shaw Scott Pendlebury Steele Sidebottom
HF: Alan Didak Travis Cloke Dane Swan
F: Jamie Elliott Chris Dawes Tyson Goldsack
FOLL: Darren Jolly Dayne Beams Dale Thomas
BENCH: Sharrod Wellingham Jarryd Blair Marty Clarke
SUB: Ben Sinclair
Unlucky and still without a doubt in the mix: Alex Fasolo Caolan Mooney Jackson Paine Marley Williams

Mooney unlucky not to be in our best 22? You must have been pretty impressed with the 23 minutes and 3 possessions he played today Knightmare...

 

[themidlandmaster]

Mine changes with every week.

Right now I'd go with:
B: Alan Toovey Nathan Brown Chris Tarrant
HB: Harry O'Brien Ben Reid Nick Maxwell
CEN: Heath Shaw Scott Pendlebury Steele Sidebottom
HF: Alan Didak Travis Cloke Dane Swan
F: Jamie Elliott Chris Dawes Tyson Goldsack
FOLL: Darren Jolly Dayne Beams Dale Thomas
BENCH: Sharrod Wellingham Jarryd Blair Marty Clarke
SUB: Ben Sinclair
Unlucky and still without a doubt in the mix: Alex Fasolo Caolan Mooney Jackson Paine Marley Williams

You dont think all three defenders and maxwell is too tall?

 

[SwanBet]

it really depends on who we play, west coast at full strength we need the 3 tall defenders in, whereas against an Adelaide we would be to tall down back. anyway;

B: C.Tarrant, N.Brown, N.Maxwell
HB: H.O'brien, B.Reid, H.Shaw
C: D.Thomas, D.Beams, S.Sidebottom
HF: S.Wellingham, T.Cloke, A.Didak
F: B.Sinclair, C.Dawes, T.Goldsack
R: D.Jolly, D.Swan, S.Pendlebury
I: J.Blair, A.Toovey, B.Johnson
Sub: A.Fasolo

emg: S.Buckley, J.Elliott(comes in if johnson isn't ready), J.Paine, M.Clarke, M.Williams, C.Wood.

The small forwards could really go anyway, in a big final i see one of Fasolo, Sinclair and Elliott starting. One as the sub, and one missing out. If elliott continues this form he will be first in the pecking order, but atm Sinclair and Fasolo probably have for credits in the bank.

 

[Knightmare]

Mooney unlucky not to be in our best 22? You must have been pretty impressed with the 23 minutes and 3 possessions he played today Knightmare...

I've liked his improvement and his tackling was very impressive today. I don't have him inside the best 22 and you can't off the back of one game, but I expect his improvement to continue and he is one I wouldn't be shocked to see make the most of his senior opportunity if and when he receives a full match. Not one I've counted out yet and has the talent and athleticism to surprise.

 

[Knightmare]

You dont think all three defenders and maxwell is too tall?

Should be ok. Tarrant can play small depending on opposition and with many clubs going the two key forwards and two rucks - one resting forward it's probably necessary.