Traded Adam Treloar [traded w/ #28 to Collingwood for #7, #65, 2016 first rounder]

[Tiger71]

No, and I'll write it slowly for you, I'm saying we paid, after you asked, player A (Greenwood) less money and a lesser pick than player B (Cotchin) and player C (Selwood). Seeing as he did a better job when he played on them than they did, it seems like a good value deal for us.

Not implying anything just stating the facts.

Are you saying Greenwood is a better player then Cotchin ?

 

[Old Spice]

What you said sounded as if tiges and geelong are iver paying cotchin and selwood...which they are not.
Collingwood on the other hand paid overs for a guy who had one good season....greenwood!

There's always someone who arrives late to the conversation and gets it all wrong.

Anyway, we're paying the right amount for Greenwood as a lock-down player who shaves higher paid players on field. Okay.

 

[Mr Magic]

Nah. The club that Treloar nominates will get him. For a quality player like Treloar a deal will get done. The history of trading players shows that players being offered equal or better deals money wise elsewhere and that team having better trading assets but they didn't get a look in because the player opted to go his team of choice. The player holds more power than any club.

Not sure why you're so beat up about this. Just relax until he makes a decision.

Surely Treloar will not nominate until competing bids are finalised would he? I trust Treloar is not that foolish!

 

[ryza87]

Know itss naht. Did i mis spel sometin wong$

 

[Old Spice]

Ok wise one. Please link where he has chosen the pies. If you can do that sir, I would appreciate it as I cant find where his management, GWS or Treloar himself has nominated you.

Meet me in the future, we'll have a beer and discuss where it all went wrong.

 

[ryza87]

There's always someone who arrives late to the conversation and gets it all wrong.

Anyway, we're paying the right amount for Greenwood as a lock-down player who shaves higher paid players on field. Okay.

No i read what you wrote and its how it sounded. Maybe go re-read it champ

 

[jimmy35]

Are you saying Greenwood is a better player then Cotchin ?

I'm saying he played better than him 2 weeks ago. He's paid less as well. Win/win.
Wouldn't have thought it was too difficult to work out., particularly by the 2nd or 3rd time.

 

[Mr Magic]

Kreuzer, Murphy, Gibbs, Cripps, Treloar makes a solid midfield.

If only a team was 5 players like basketball

 

[Bay Pie]

Surely Treloar will not nominate until competing bids are finalised would he? I trust Treloar is not that foolish!

Nah. He'd have chosen a team already. The bidding process would have been on for longer then many us would know and would have been sorted by now. There's been plenty of time for making better offers etc. He's just waiting for his season to finish to announce.

 

[Mr Magic]

I'm saying he played better than him 2 weeks ago. He's paid less as well. Win/win.
Wouldn't have thought it was too difficult to work out., particularly by the 2nd or 3rd time.

Have not seen Greenwood play a good match.

 

[Mr Magic]

Nah. He'd have chosen a team already. The bidding process would have been on for longer then many us would know and would have been sorted by now. There's been plenty of time for making better offers etc. He's just waiting for his season to finish to announce.

BS, as a human he could not be that ignorant.

Who knows what he may cost himself if he jumps early without proper consideration about all his interests

 

[Old Spice]

 

[Colonial]

Nah. He'd have chosen a team already. The bidding process would have been on for longer then many us would know and would have been sorted by now. There's been plenty of time for making better offers etc. He's just waiting for his season to finish to announce.

He could still change his mind. Its against the rules to have a binding contract already.

 

[Tiger71]

Meet me in the future, we'll have a beer and discuss where it all went wrong.

Will do brother, and its ok to cry on my shoulder. I will be there for you.

 

[jimmy35]

Have not seen Greenwood play a good match.

Ignorance is no excuse so they say.

 

[Wayne Arnold]

He's chosen the Pies. However, if the Tigers make a prelim this may change his mind.

 

[Bay Pie]

BS, as a human he could not be that ignorant.

Who knows what he may cost himself if he jumps early without proper consideration about all his interests

LOL. You haven't made many life changing career moves have you ? They aren't made in a week or 2.

 

[Tiger71]

I'm saying he played better than him 2 weeks ago. He's paid less as well. Win/win.
Wouldn't have thought it was too difficult to work out., particularly by the 2nd or 3rd time.

You are right, he played better then Cotchin who had someone pass away while carrying a bad back, the good news though we still won the game by 91 points

 

[jimmy35]

He's chosen the Pies. However, if the Tigers win a final for a change this may change his mind.

efa and all that

 

[Mr Magic]

Ignorance is no excuse so they say.

Keep telling yourself Collingwood have talented players if it makes you feel any better. We have not been stupid enough to trade with you guys for years for good reason. We know most of your guys are crap!!

The only decent guy you offloaded was H Shaw and he is getting on anyway.

 

[Tiger71]

Nah. He'd have chosen a team already. The bidding process would have been on for longer then many us would know and would have been sorted by now. There's been plenty of time for making better offers etc. He's just waiting for his season to finish to announce.

The bidding process would have reset once clubs could trade future picks, that was not to long ago but hey, its all fun times

 

[jimmy35]

You are right, he played better then Cotchin who had someone pass away while carrying a bad back, the good news though we still won the game by 91 points

Shit must have been a hell of a sore back. Condolences.

You did win but, as pointed out for 925th time, Greenwood beat him.

 

[Mr Magic]

The bidding process would have reset once clubs could trade future picks, that was not to long ago but hey, its all fun times

Seriously anyone thinking anything is set now is dead set mad.

First there is FA. So we see what happens with Kruzeur and Danger.

Then starts the trading. First cab off the rank Treloar so anything could happen

 

[Old Spice]

No i read what you wrote and its how it sounded. Maybe go re-read it champ

Go back to post #1993 and start from there. Champ.

 

[Tiger71]

Shit must have been a hell of a sore back. Condolences.

You did win but, as pointed out for 925th time, Greenwood beat him.

going to make a interesting game in our return bout next year. I wonder who do you think Greenwood the 500k plus tagger will tag, treloar or Cotchin ?