Charlie Dixon

[port_adelaide_1870]

I'm predicting...

Moore + Pick 10 + Pick 29
for
Dixon + Pick 22

I am predicting

Pick 10
for
Dixon

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

Port: Come on GC just accept Pick 10 for Dixon, we need our second pick to get Jimmy Toumpas. What do ya say?
GC: Nahhhh
Port: Com'on
GC: Nahhh
Port: Com'onnn
GC: Nahhhhhh
Port: Oh Com'onnnnnn
GC: Ahhhh
Port: YES! Now that Gold Coast are in, Toumpas will fall like a domino.

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

I'm predicting...

Moore + Pick 10 + Pick 29
for
Dixon + Pick 22

make it

Moore + Pick 10 + Pick 29
for
Dixon + Pick 22 + pick 37

an you've got yourself a deal

then

Young + pick 37
for
Toumpass + pick 43

So we end up with picks 22, 47 and 65 (gray upgrade)

 

[Phhht]

make it

Moore + Pick 10 + Pick 29
for
Dixon + Pick 22 + pick 37

an you've got yourself a deal

then

Young + pick 37
for
Toumpass + pick 43

So we end up with picks 22, 47 and 65 (gray upgrade)

Are you saying Moore + 29 = pick 22 + pick 37?

or
Dixon = pick 10 + pick 29

and Moore = pick 22 + pick 37?


I cant see GC agreeing to any of that. And with Ablett, O'Meara, Swallow, Prestia plus others, do GC really need Moore?

I'm not sure its the way they would be thinking

 

[stokholme]

View attachment 181667

Port: Come on GC just accept Pick 10 for Dixon, we need our second pick to get Jimmy Toumpas. What do ya say?
GC: Nahhhh
Port: Com'on
GC: Nahhh
Port: Com'onnn
GC: Nahhhhhh
Port: Oh Com'onnnnnn
GC: Ahhhh
Port: YES! Now that Gold Coast are in, Toumpas will fall like a domino.

Port negotiating with GCS

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

was saying

Moore + 29 = pick 22

pick 37 being suplus to their needs was the goodwill add on

FIFY see above

but that being said, i agree, they prob dont need more.

 

[Wargreymon90]

Chris Davies on getting the Dixon deal done

 

[PowerKidd]

Definitely this. Jay goes one way Charlie the other while Paddy's in the goal square.

I can see the opposition defenders being so confused by this hahaha then just add Wingard, Monfries and Neade crumbing

 

[Hong-Kong Phooey]

I can see the opposition defenders being so confused by this hahaha then just add Wingard, Monfries and Neade crumbing

Since when has monfries crumbed?

 

[Dylan8]

View attachment 181667

Port: Come on GC just accept Pick 10 for Dixon, we need our second pick to get Jimmy Toumpas. What do ya say?
GC: Nahhhh
Port: Com'on
GC: Nahhh
Port: Com'onnn
GC: Nahhhhhh
Port: Oh Com'onnnnnn
GC: Ahhhh
Port: YES! Now that Gold Coast are in, Toumpas will fall like a domino.

Hey! That's my maymay
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10205311197082767

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

Hey! That's my maymay
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10205311197082767

IM SO SORRY I DIDN"T KNOW PLS FORGIVE

 

[Dylan8]

IM SO SORRY I DIDN"T KNOW PLS FORGIVE

That's not très bien, dark wizard.

 

[Port83]

Since when has monfries crumbed?

He doesn't, he's privides defensive pressure, score involvements and goals out the back! Great role player for us imo.

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

That's not très bien, dark wizard.

holy shit haha. How good is their podcast? WORLDS COLLIDE

 

[HombschyPAFCgun]

I am predicting

Pick 10
for
Dixon

This is the ideal situation. Another option was suggested on Trade Radio, after the Carlisle destination was revealed.

Saints Lose: Pick 5
Saints Gain: Aaron Young and Pick 10

Port Gain: Pick 5
Port Lose: Aaron Young and Pick 10

Forwarded;

Gold Coast Gain: Pick 5
Lose: Charlie Dixon

Port Gain: Charlie Dixon
Port Lose: Pick 5

Overall, Port Lose Young, pick 10 then pick 5 for Charlie Dixon

Is sounds alright, however, I think a second rounder should be thrown to us somewhere. Maybe the pick GC recieve from Geelong for Zac Smith or St.Kilda's second????

 

[Dylan8]

holy shit haha. How good is their podcast? WORLDS COLLIDE

I live for it. Robbie really sucks though.

 

[Spadge]

This is the ideal situation. Another option was suggested on Trade Radio, after the Carlisle destination was revealed.

Saints Lose: Pick 5
Saints Gain: Aaron Young and Pick 10

Port Gain: Pick 5
Port Lose: Aaron Young and Pick 10

Forwarded;

Gold Coast Gain: Pick 5
Lose: Charlie Dixon

Port Gain: Charlie Dixon
Port Lose: Pick 5

Overall, Port Lose Young, pick 10 then pick 5 for Charlie Dixon

Is sounds alright, however, I think a second rounder should be thrown to us somewhere. Maybe the pick GC recieve from Geelong for Zac Smith or St.Kilda's second????

so.. Dixon costs us pick 10 and Young?
yeah nah

 

[Powertron]

This is the ideal situation. Another option was suggested on Trade Radio, after the Carlisle destination was revealed.

Saints Lose: Pick 5
Saints Gain: Aaron Young and Pick 10

Port Gain: Pick 5
Port Lose: Aaron Young and Pick 10

Forwarded;

Gold Coast Gain: Pick 5
Lose: Charlie Dixon

Port Gain: Charlie Dixon
Port Lose: Pick 5

Overall, Port Lose Young, pick 10 then pick 5 for Charlie Dixon

Is sounds alright, however, I think a second rounder should be thrown to us somewhere. Maybe the pick GC recieve from Geelong for Zac Smith or St.Kilda's second????

As much as it works for us, saints aren't trading down in the draft to get Aaron Young.

 

[Malibu#27]

This is the ideal situation. Another option was suggested on Trade Radio, after the Carlisle destination was revealed.

Saints Lose: Pick 5
Saints Gain: Aaron Young and Pick 10

Port Gain: Pick 5
Port Lose: Aaron Young and Pick 10

Forwarded;

Gold Coast Gain: Pick 5
Lose: Charlie Dixon

Port Gain: Charlie Dixon
Port Lose: Pick 5

Overall, Port Lose Young, pick 10 then pick 5 for Charlie Dixon

Is sounds alright, however, I think a second rounder should be thrown to us somewhere. Maybe the pick GC recieve from Geelong for Zac Smith or St.Kilda's second????

Dixon for five ??? Seems a bit much. Gold Coast need to give something back.

 

[Malibu#27]

As much as it works for us, saints aren't trading down in the draft to get Aaron Young.

I'm assuming a part of the deal is missing where saints give 10 to Essendon for Carslile. So it's five for Carlisle and Young.

 

[Willsy10]

This is the ideal situation. Another option was suggested on Trade Radio, after the Carlisle destination was revealed.

Saints Lose: Pick 5
Saints Gain: Aaron Young and Pick 10

Port Gain: Pick 5
Port Lose: Aaron Young and Pick 10

Forwarded;

Gold Coast Gain: Pick 5
Lose: Charlie Dixon

Port Gain: Charlie Dixon
Port Lose: Pick 5

Overall, Port Lose Young, pick 10 then pick 5 for Charlie Dixon

Is sounds alright, however, I think a second rounder should be thrown to us somewhere. Maybe the pick GC recieve from Geelong for Zac Smith or St.Kilda's second????

This scenario is too heavily skewed in Gold Coast favour, and Port and Saints get screwed, which is the counter-opposite of how it should play out. Gold Coast need to accept that they will get slightly short changed for Dixon, that's what normally happens when a player leaves.

 

[PJ Power]

so.. Dixon costs us pick 10 and Young?
yeah nah

So much this.
Pick 10 is adequate for a 60-game player, with questions over his ankles and off-field behaviour

 

[malcheski]

This is the ideal situation. Another option was suggested on Trade Radio, after the Carlisle destination was revealed.

Saints Lose: Pick 5
Saints Gain: Aaron Young and Pick 10

Port Gain: Pick 5
Port Lose: Aaron Young and Pick 10

Forwarded;

Gold Coast Gain: Pick 5
Lose: Charlie Dixon

Port Gain: Charlie Dixon
Port Lose: Pick 5

Overall, Port Lose Young, pick 10 then pick 5 for Charlie Dixon

Is sounds alright, however, I think a second rounder should be thrown to us somewhere. Maybe the pick GC recieve from Geelong for Zac Smith or St.Kilda's second????

If this were even remotely possible then we would be silly not to keep 5 and then trade Next years first rounder and Moore to GC.

Then we use pick 5 to get either Parish or Hopper to add to our midfield straight away.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

 

[Harro59]

So much this.
Pick 10 is adequate for a 60-game player, with questions over his ankles and off-field behaviour

Thought he had some shoulder issues as well.

 

[HombschyPAFCgun]

I'm assuming a part of the deal is missing where saints give 10 to Essendon for Carslile. So it's five for Carlisle and Young.

Something like that, recalling the various scenarios thrown up on Trade Radio can be difficult. Some just come out of left field.

I find 10 is enough for Dixon, however, I hope we don't go overs with a first and second round pick.

If it comes down to it, and we need to throw in an extra pick. Please make it next years second round pick (which I pray starts as a base number 36 before Compensation.)