List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[left at home]

so on the menu right now is mega mega deal horse racing and steak knives.
so that covers the last 15 pages. what's next.

 

[Crazy Tails]

Too good to be true. Gives us a realistic chance of getting Weideman if it happens.

We would probably have to hold this off till
the death too and get AT & Aish done first otherwise the vultures might want a piece of this pick too.

 

[MagpieJoel]

I wouldn't be complaining, but Brisbane are crazy if they do that... Bell is SHIT.

They want a mature, big bodied mid. Bell is their man.

 

[BPikkers]

I wouldn't be complaining, but Brisbane are crazy if they do that... Bell is SHIT.

I know however they are resigned to losing Aish and they have a more mature body wanting to play for them which they can't let slip. A replacement which they need to happen to try an win a few more games

 

[jhndos]

Whats the difference between a normal deal and a mega deal?

Large chips and $3

 

[JollyBallsUp]

IF there is any truth in this Witts for pick 11 yes please; where do we sign. Do not rate.

Maybe sling them a mid to late pick for big Minno who could be the mature back up for Grundy if required.

If Witts gets traded for pick 11, we should give both our 1st rounders in this years draft for Treloar and keep our future pick up our sleave.

 

[PhiloBeddoe]

I know however they are resigned to losing Aish and they have a more mature body wanting to play for them which they can't let slip. A replacement which they need to happen to try an win a few more games

If anything, Bell is inconsistent. I reckon he goes alright and will get better. Brisbane will have done well to get him.

 

[thetruth000001]

PAUL SEEDSMAN TRADED FOR ADELAIDE 2016 SECOND ROUND PICK

 

[FireKrakouer]

This thread will be bang on 1200 pages when Treloar is announced, calling it early. Mods what prize do I get when I'm proven correct?

 

[JollyBallsUp]

I think that Brisbane get ripped off and Blues make like bandits on that deal.

Aish to Pies
Bell & 26 to Brisbane
32 to Blues

32 for Bell is about right especially given the quality of this draft.

 

[PhiloBeddoe]

PAUL SEEDSMAN TRADED FOR ADELAIDE 2016 SECOND ROUND PICK

Says it's done and then says it's likely. So sort of done.

 

[ronnysnodgrass]

Hey guys, sorry for the intrusion, wanted to do a sanity check on a trade idea on the saints board.

As you probably know we are having some good old fun times trying to get the Carlisle deal done.

It's reported at this stage we offered 5+61 for Carlisle, 23 & 25 (melksham pick)

It will need work to get done, either a player or better pick at our end or a change at their end, but for this case let's assume we get 23&25 in the deal.

The thought process is that the saints would offer Collingwood picks 23,24,25 and next years second for 7 & freeman.

The logic is that that group of picks may be more exciting to GWS on a point basis than 7 & and your first / second next year.

Saving you guys having to give up that pick.

Does this kind of thing have any basis in achievability at the pies end?

 

[The Magnificent Seven]

This thread will be bang on 1200 pages when Treloar is announced, calling it early. Mods what prize do I get when I'm proven correct?

You get 2 free future picks for the 2016 Trade Thread

 

[left at home]

This thread will be bang on 1200 pages when Treloar is announced, calling it early. Mods what prize do I get when I'm proven correct?

nah it will be over 1200 pages. sat morning with only 60 to go, shit that in

 

[MagpieJoel]

Says it's done and then says it's likely. So sort of done.

PAUL SEEDSMAN TRADED FOR ADELAIDE 2016 SECOND ROUND PICK

Sounds like it's just the paper work.

 

[SnakePlisskin]

Says it's done and then says it's likely. So sort of done.

Ahh the media , lead you in with a bullshit headline then tell the truth in small print!

 

[thetruth000001]

Says it's done and then says it's likely. So sort of done.

I think it's done and dusted

 

[1892]

PAUL SEEDSMAN TRADED FOR ADELAIDE 2016 SECOND ROUND PICK

That pick has gone to GWS, so the typo has us getting nothing in return.

 

[The Magnificent Seven]

Re Finlayson, for the uninformed and slightly clueless (me), is this a case of GWS trying to force this guy on us to seal the deal? Or do we want him as part of the package, and GWS are resisting? If the latter, then is he one of Hine's famous 'specials'?

His highlights look pretty good. Solid hands, reliable penetrating kick and good below his knees. Why hasn't he cracked a senior gig yet?

 

[Pendles!]

Hey guys, sorry for the intrusion, wanted to do a sanity check on a trade idea on the saints board.

As you probably know we are having some good old fun times trying to get the Carlisle deal done.

It's reported at this stage we offered 5+61 for Carlisle, 23 & 25 (melksham pick)

It will need work to get done, either a player or better pick at our end or a change at their end, but for this case let's assume we get 23&25 in the deal.

The thought process is that the saints would offer Collingwood picks 23,24,25 and next years second for 7 & freeman.

The logic is that that group of picks may be more exciting to GWS on a point basis than 7 & and your first / second next year.

Saving you guys having to give up that pick.

Does this kind of thing have any basis in achievability at the pies end?

Can't happen, 7 will go to GWS. If you want another first you're better off offering up a deal for GWS' pick 8.

 

[dmoore30]

Can trades be made today and tomorrow?

 

[FireKrakouer]

nah it will be over 1200 pages. sat morning with only 60 to go, shit that in

My logic was that posting would slow down to 20 pages per day on the weekend with no news. I could well be wrong though

 

[domin8tors]

I love Witts. This might be crazy talk, but we should consider trading him. He has value, and will fetch a well needed first round pick. He"ll mainly play in the VFL this year.
I don't see how Grundy,Cloke,White, Howe, Moore, Reid, Brown, Frost and WITTS can play in the same team. That looks way too tall for my liking.
I would hate for him to leave, but there's no point if we can grab Weideman.
We would need to chase Giles or Andrew Phillips, someone who doesn't mind being the second ruck.
Only possible way it could work is if Howe is on the wing. Witts and White fighting over second rick position.

I don't want to trade Witts, but it's what is best for the team. We could probably grab Dogs first pick for him.

I think that the other thing of note here is that we just signed our 2nd American Project player as a ruckman. So I wonder if the pies are just banking on the fact that one of these Project Rucks can make it.

 

[Roverjg]

Whats

Can trades be made today and tomorrow?

Yes. However paperwork will not be signed off by the AFL until Monday

 

[Ketchup]

Hey guys, sorry for the intrusion, wanted to do a sanity check on a trade idea on the saints board.

As you probably know we are having some good old fun times trying to get the Carlisle deal done.

It's reported at this stage we offered 5+61 for Carlisle, 23 & 25 (melksham pick)

It will need work to get done, either a player or better pick at our end or a change at their end, but for this case let's assume we get 23&25 in the deal.

The thought process is that the saints would offer Collingwood picks 23,24,25 and next years second for 7 & freeman.

The logic is that that group of picks may be more exciting to GWS on a point basis than 7 & and your first / second next year.

Saving you guys having to give up that pick.

Does this kind of thing have any basis in achievability at the pies end?

Would never happen. Pick 7 is the pick Gws will take to the draft that isn't their academy player. Not a chance in hell they would give up that pick for 23,24,25.