eth-dog
Tier 1 WW Player
Good player. Very good set shot.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 14
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
EUFA EURO 2024 - Group Stage ⚽ EPL 24/25 starts Aug 17
Once you guys climb into the top 8 next year or the year after (whenever it is in the near future), then we will have a better gauge on his capabilities against all opposition/what his ceiling could be, but yeah, those floggings interstate where nearly your whole team were uncompetitive wouldn't have helpedI think it's a bit of a common misconception already about him to be fair.
He's been reasonable against better opponents in the games he has playe this season, the only games he's been largely ineffective in is against WCE and Adelaide where we lost by a combined total of 191 points. He wasn't the only one, trust me. He was still decent against the Eagles FWIW as well considering.
Can't be as bad as James Sellar or Chris Dawes...Spuds always kick bags against us, Membrey is certainly one.
5 goals is generally considered a bag, is it not?
...who kicked lots of goals, including 9 in a TAC Cup prelim and then 4 in the grannie, both while playing with an ankle injury. Was captain of that side, too.Pretty sure anyone who followed the u18's knew who he was.
He was the kid with the terrible palm tree tattoo
It's about time we got one back on the Swans for stealing Lockett and Hall.
How's Tommy Walsh going Sydney fans?
(It's a joke)....who kicked lots of goals, including 9 in a TAC Cup prelim and then 4 in the grannie, both while playing with an ankle injury. Was captain of that side, too.
Pretty sure if you pick an 11 game sample for the mentioned players you'll find a 3 goal a game average too.22 years old and averaging just shy of 3 goals a game, above the likes of Jenkins, Betts, Gunston, Hogan, Riewoldt, Walker etc etc
At just 22yo, or with less than 25 games to their name?Pretty sure if you pick an 11 game sample for the mentioned players you'll find a 3 goal a game average too.
Maybe? Wouldn't have a clue.At just 22yo, or with less than 25 games to their name?
It's not a selected sample of his best 11 games though, that's all the games he's played this year, so that logic doesn't really work.Pretty sure if you pick an 11 game sample for the mentioned players you'll find a 3 goal a game average too.
Maybe not Hogan.
Walker kicked 63 goals in 2012 at an average of 3.3 when he was 21-22.At just 22yo, or with less than 25 games to their name?
You don't think Jack, Buddy, Tex etc have ever had an 11 game stretch where they've averaged 3 goals?It's not a selected sample of his best 11 games though, that's all the games he's played this year, so that logic doesn't really work.
Probably but it's not a comparable to select a players 11 best games vs a players entire season for obvious reasons.You don't think Jack, Buddy, Tex etc have ever had an 11 game stretch where they've averaged 3 goals?
It's not an entire season, it's 11 games.Probably but it's not a comparable to select a players 11 best games vs a players entire season for obvious reasons.
So can't compare Membrey to them using that then?Probably but it's not a comparable to select a players 11 best games vs a players entire season for obvious reasons.
So can't compare Membrey to them using that then?
Since it's his best 11 games?
Which is his entire season. We haven't picked out his best 11 games to present a maximum goal average so why would you do the same with another player to compare? I would have thought this is pretty obvious stuff.It's not an entire season, it's 11 games.
As I said earlier I have no idea when you start adding qualifiers like that.Try comparing their 10th - 20th odd first senior games of football
Before this season, Membrey has played approx one dozen games of football