Remove this Banner Ad

Game Day AFL Round 3 - Matchday Discussion St Kilda@Collingwood(MCG - 4:35PM)

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Round three is upon us, and it still almost impossible to make an accurate gauge of where the season is heading. The season has handed us some unpredictable results, and no one really knows where each team is at. What we do know is that we’re in for what should be a beauty today.

These two sides last met in round nine of 2019. In a match that is infamous for the Stephenson betting scandal, the Magpies ran out 41 point winners. Despite starting slow, the Magpies came home like a train, kicking six goals to one in the last quarter. Grundy was simply outstanding for the Magpies, while Billings was best on for the Saints.

Collingwood

In what was perhaps the worst close game of all time, the Magpies managed to escape with a draw against the Tigers. The two sides combined for the lowest scored this century, with both sides being able to muster only five goals each. Both teams also went goaless for two quarters each. While Collingwood showed that their defense was as strong as ever, it also showed that their forward line was still lacking. The lack of prominent key tall forward really stopped the Magpies from scoring, and the small forwards didn’t offer much either. The game showed that Collingwood really hasn’t worked on their scoring firepower in the offseason, which could lead to their undoing at the business end of the season.

Jeremy Howe was absolutely elite for the Magpies, leading the backline, while Taylor Adams and Pendlebury were strong contributors.

Where the Magpies can win the game

In the first quarter, the Magpies looked unstoppable, and it started from the backline. The Magpies were able to generate scoring opportunities from the centerline and half back. However, their fitness seemed to wane in the second half, meaning that running game wasn’t effective, and the backline resorted to long kicks. If the Magpies are to win, they will have to opt to run the ball off half back, instead of trying to kick it long to tall targets who have proven ineffective in being able to mark the ball

Player to watch

Jaidyn Stephenson is the man to watch for Collingwood. The former rising star has struggled over the past 12 months, serving a lengthy suspension for betting on AFL games, and generally struggling to have an impact on the game with opposition teams putting a larger focus on him. To add to his woes, Stephenson suffered from glandular fever in the summer, restricting his offseason. Despite being left out for the first two games, Stephenson has been given the opportunity, and will need to show what he is capable of if he is to remain in the side for the long term.

St Kilda

Last week the Saints were a completely different team that we’ve grown to know and love over the past few seasons. Despite historically being a horribly inaccurate team, the Saints kicked a scintillating 14.4 against a woeful Western Bulldogs side. The Saints moved with smooth precision across the field, and put in a strong defensive effort. Jack Billings was simply outstanding kicking three goals and racking up 24 disposals, while Zak Jones was solid in just his second game in a Saints jersey.

The Saints will be without Geary, but will welcome back former Magpie Johnathan Marsh into the team.

Where the Saints can win the game

First and foremost, the Saints need to continue that accurate scoring that they brought to the table last week. The Saints have blown games far too often by being inaccurate in front of goals. They’ve shown at times they can be a very capable football side, but their inaccuracy has prevented them from winning a number of games. To add to this, the Saints need to keep finding targets inside 50. Currently, the Saints are able to hit a target inside 50 on 30% of their entries, the best in the AFL. The Saints are coming up against one of the best defenses in the league, and hitting these targets will be paramount to them winning.

Player to watch

Jade Gresham is the man to watch for the Saints. The young gun made a move into the midfield last season, and it paid dividends immediately. Gresham has a reputation for getting his hands on the footy, generating contested possessions, and has a habit of popping up in the big moments.

Head to Head odds

Collingwood: $1.45
Saints: $2.75

Changes

Saints


IN

Johnathan Marsh

OUT

Jarryn Geary (Injured)

Collingwood

IN

Jaidyn Stephenson
Rupert Wills

OUT

Jack Madgen (Omitted)
Josh Thomas (Omitted)

TV

Live on Fox Footy, Commercial Free

Radio

Triple M
3AW
ABC
SEN


IPTV

AFL Live Pass
Foxtel Now
WatchAFL
Kayo Sports

Congratulations Brayden Maynard – 100 games

Drafted back in 2014, Maynard has grown to become a critical staple in the quality Collingwood defense. He shown that not only can he shutdown dangerous forwards, but also create scoring chances out of the backline.

Tip

Another tough game to tip. This season has proven wildly unpredictable. The Saints have also proven to be more than capable, and have the talent to give the Magpies a shake. However, Collingwood’s tough defense will be enough to get the Magpies over the line.



Magpies by 20.
 
Most draws are ultimately unsatisfying – like a Tassie kid pashing his hot cousin and getting caught by his uncle.

The refs robbed us last week when they awarded Higgins a converted try.

After the 77 draw, Tommy flogged our boys on the track like a deranged drill sergeant.

But some draws, in hindsight, are joyous – precursors to glory.

The Hand of God was at work when the ball shunned Tip Rat Stevie.

The following week was beautiful. So beautiful. Mostly because our lads hoisted the cup, but also because St Kilda lost.

St Kilda has been a rubbish club for 50 years. Thugs like Jim O’Dea and my former Frankston neighbours epitomise its debasement.

The club’s highlights are the Moorabbin Disco and Plugger (respect that he played at 160 kegs).

No more highlights for Sainters this week.

Collingwood by 64 points
 
I'm hopeful more than confident, but I am also a pessimistic supporter generally as well.

Worried what the run and gun footy from the Saints could do, so hopefully we can limit their supply

I'm still tipping us, but in a pretty tight one
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Big game
I just have a feeling we’ll go back to our 2018 blitzing best and blow them away.
Saints played a good game last week but are all hype, we are composed and a much stronger line up.
I was a big critic of Daicos but I’m all in now, expect a classy 25 & 2 goal game.
Pies by 55
 
How am I already nervous? This is an absolute must win game.

I can't wait to watch Stephenson play for the first time this year. I'm hoping to see Noble play with more composure today and show us what he can do at AFL level. I want to see what Darcy Cameron offers in terms of forward craft today.

A good showing from Ty Brown and a Collingwood win would make it a good day!

My prediction. Pies to win by 20 points and De Goey to kick 4
 
Got No Idea what to Expect as we had some weird Results so Far.

Hopefully we can play more then 1 Good Qtr and IF we can win 2-3 Good Qtrs so we can Win this Evening


Weather will be fine.


Though it was going to Rain All Day?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Got No Idea what to Expect as we had some weird Results so Far.

Hopefully we can play more then 1 Good Qtr and IF we can win 2-3 Good Qtrs so we can Win this Evening



Though it was going to Rain All Day?
It's actually a pretty nice day,TD!
 
Stephenson back is massive for us. More pace.
De goey will play against the Saints for only the 3rd time in his career. 2018 - kicked 6.0, 2016 - 17 touches & 2 goals. Expect a big one from him today.
Moore didn’t play the Saints last year, I expect him to shutdown King.
Howe will dominate.
Adams didn’t play last time, that’s added grunt to our midfield.
Our young boys - Daicos and the brown brothers will be a problem.
 
Stephenson back is massive for us. More pace.
De goey will play against the Saints for only the 3rd time in his career. 2018 - kicked 6.0, 2016 - 17 touches & 2 goals. Expect a big one from him today.
Moore didn’t play the Saints last year, I expect him to shutdown King.
Howe will dominate.
Adams didn’t play last time, that’s added grunt to our midfield.
Our young boys - Daicos and the brown brothers will be a problem.
Also didn’t have Jamie Elliott! We must win big today.
 
It's possibly only minor but gee it annoys me that our game isn't on 4k on Foxtel. Do they only have one set of 4k cameras or something? The North vs. Sydney game atm is in 4k.

Otherwise it's mainly just NRL games and replays.

I can't believe they advertise "live footy in 4k" and only show about 2 games a week.

This truly gives new meaning to the phrase 'first world problems'.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

With Connor McKenna getting Covid 19 might mean the game might not even happen yet
McLachlan's press conference is on the ABC. All other games going ahead; the other 2 Sunday games have had their start times altered to fill the TV slot.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top