Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. Contracts. Trades. Draft. Other Assorted Crap. 2020 Edition

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
He would get instant games at many clubs i'd have thought?

It's only because we have an embarrassment of AFL quality tall forwards (JK, Darling, Oscar, Waterman) that he isn't getting a look.

He's plenty good enough.
I could see him starting in the Swans forward line immediately and getting a long run there.
 
Just have Brander and Allen at CHF/FF, Darling third tall and Waterman HFF/wing. Kennedy will probably miss a number of games next year so just rotate he, Brander and Allen and they can both learn off him as he's moving into a coaching role after the season anyway. Would be perfect for him to develop them both next season.

Darling's always played better as either the main man or 3rd tall, is a bit quiet as second fiddle sometimes.
 
No sh*t.

I think you'll find the majority of the board has been saying this for a long time, this isn't new.

Kennedy deciding to sign on again for another year has stamped Branders papers as tradeable for mine. I'm deadset against him languishing in the WAFL for a 4th season, like he has for his first three. It really isn't going to do anything for his development, there's a time when state league competition isn't enough.

However i would play him ahead of Ainsworth in any goddamn position on the ground.

Will any of our players being playing WAFL next year?
 
I don't think any clubs would be guaranteeing Brander games in 2021.

For the next 12 months, at least, he would be in the same situation whether he left or stayed.

That is seriously BS.

He wouldn't get a game with North, Essendon, the Swans or Crows?

It all depends the state of their list and if they need tall's.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I assume you think its no chance. So why do you think its no chance thus the lol's and shock? Because West Coast could not satisfy Freo or Freo would not do it? Maybe you think Fyfe would not consider it?

Fyfe doesn't like the Eagles.

Freo also.

He's their captain and dual Brownlow medalist.

They could almost make finals if Fyfe has a good 2021.

Nothing has ever pointed towards Fyfe leaving for the Eagles.

And lastly, his personality does not fit the Eagles style. Much more suited to Freo.
 
Fyfe doesn't like the Eagles.

Freo also.

He's their captain and dual Brownlow medalist.

They could almost make finals if Fyfe has a good 2021.

Nothing has ever pointed towards Fyfe leaving for the Eagles.

And lastly, his personality does not fit the Eagles style. Much more suited to Freo.

What do you mean on the personality?
 
That is seriously BS.

He wouldn't get a game with North, Essendon, the Swans or Crows?

It all depends the state of their list and if they need tall's.

He'd get the odd game, for sure, but I don't think any club would guarantee him a spot in their 22. He'll be 22 with 11 games of experience. He's never kicked a goal at AFL level and he has no exposed 2020 WAFL form. It would take a brave club.
 
He'd get the odd game, for sure, but I don't think any club would guarantee him a spot in their 22. He'll be 22 with 11 games of experience. He's never kicked a goal at AFL level and he has no exposed 2020 WAFL form. It would take a brave club.

Has Brander actually not kicked a goal yet ?
wowee and some of you blokes are carrying on like he is the goat.
we would be lucky to get a straight swap for Clark, starting to feel like we would need to add a sweetener
 

Remove this Banner Ad

He'd get the odd game, for sure, but I don't think any club would guarantee him a spot in their 22. He'll be 22 with 11 games of experience. He's never kicked a goal at AFL level and he has no exposed 2020 WAFL form. It would take a brave club.

Is any player guaranteed a game?

Look at Coniligio.

A rebuilding club would put time and games into developing Brander in his best position.

That is all that any unproven kid should expect.
 
Is any player guaranteed a game?

Look at Coniligio.

A rebuilding club would put time and games into developing Brander in his best position.

That is all that any unproven kid should expect.

Yes. Hundreds of players

1 example from that complete and utter nutjob Leon Cameron doesnt change that
 
Yep, Brander at a team like North, Adelaide, GWS (with the players they are losing) or Sydney is going to get games. The potential is there for him to turn into a very good player.

The potential is there for him to be a good player with us also - but games will be harder to come by (especially in his best position/s).

This is why the AFL should look at a loan system like in soccer, especially with no opportunities to develop in the WAFL/VFL/SANFL.
Brander would be a perfect candidate for a loan to a younger team while KPF/KPD spots are tight at WCE.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Yes. Hundreds of players

1 example from that complete and utter nutjob Leon Cameron doesnt change that

No player is guaranteed a game.

You need to do the work and earn it.

It's the word guaranteed which is the key here people..
 
Yeah slow deliberate movement from the back line when they intercepted. Could have contributed to Cameron wanting out. Stating the obvious but Forwards thrive on quick clean movement, which we lacked for long stretches of games this year. And when we did get it in we didn't have the forwards tackling hard enough to keep it in our half.
Not sure which way the recruiter's head here. More half back line / wing speed players that can break the line or chase harder tackling pressure forwards to lock it in. Hard to find either type at the moment
If this was a problem for him, he wouldn't be going to Geelong - very similar in their slow deliberate movement out of defence. GWS obviously overpaid Coniglio on his new contract and offered Cameron unders.
 
This is why the AFL should look at a loan system like in soccer, especially with no opportunities to develop in the WAFL/VFL/SANFL.
Brander would be a perfect candidate for a loan to a younger team while KPF/KPD spots are tight at WCE.

I'm sure a younger team would be happy to develop Brander in the AFL system so WCE can reap the benefits.

Only way this system would work is if we could loan Brander to a lower league, like a WAFL club...
 
I'm sure a younger team would be happy to develop Brander in the AFL system so WCE can reap the benefits.

Only way this system would work is if we could loan Brander to a lower league, like a WAFL club...

Obviously my idea was half-baked - maybe we pay them for the privilege via cash or draft picks?

Or, you know, we flex on the minnow clubs?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top