Opinion 2025 Player X v Y v Z

[Borgan]

Baz v humpa v maric? In which order

 

[kyri]

Is Bice a must have at the expense of other backline rookies, like Prior or Reid? Feel like Bice only one average game away from coming back to the pack. If he goes large again and one of the others are average, may look at a swap. Thoughts?

in most scenarios, no one is that much of a must have, especially at 113k. were given the blessing of another game, and still get them for less than FOS, tsatas and lash.

 

[Scythe]

Baz v humpa v maric? In which order

I'm getting all three, but probably Baz > Maric > Humphrey

 

[Northernsoul74]

Bice vs Moraes

Impacted by returning players
Bice - Mills & Cunners
Moraes - Butters & ???

I’m hoping one gets dropped this week to make the decision easier.

 

[Bob Butter]

Smith and Moraes
Vs
Humphrey and Maric

 

[Jiska]

Hump v Maric

Maric

Role is SC gold and the ball will live there for WC

 

[Jiska]

Is Bice a must have at the expense of other backline rookies, like Prior or Reid?

No. If you have Paton, no brainer, but wouldn’t be trading Prior, Trainor or Reid based on spike games.

 

[Jiska]

Baz v humpa v maric? In which order

Maric, Humpa, Baz

 

[Jiska]

Smith and Moraes
Vs
Humphrey and Maric

Humpa and Maric

 

[1989]

Which one to keep out of Sam Powell-Pepper and Tom Lynch?

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Which one to keep out of Sam Powell-Pepper and Tom Lynch?

I'm keeping Tom Lynch out of the two.

 

[King Max]

Humpa and Maric

I was thinking Smith and Humphries in this week.
But now you have me thinking, Humphries and Maric plus another $134k in the bank.

 

[kyri]

Which one to keep out of Sam Powell-Pepper and Tom Lynch?

-13 BE against a BE of 6. id rather keep spp for this round as he will go up in price, and potentially have a spike game to keep the cash gen going.

lynch would need a huge game to keep his cash gen going.

 

[JuddgementDay]

-13 BE against a BE of 6. id rather keep spp for this round as he will go up in price, and potentially have a spike game to keep the cash gen going.

lynch would need a huge game to keep his cash gen going.

I'm having this choice and I've stuck with Lynch.
He's not fully fit atm, but he's a better player than SPP easily - teh spikes will come for Lynch

 

[SloppyJoe]

Bice v Moraes?

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Bice v Moraes?

Moraes

 

[Cats_29]

Maric v Moraes & $$

 

[JuddgementDay]

Bice v Moraes?

Bice

 

[Jiska]

Which one to keep out of Sam Powell-Pepper and Tom Lynch?

SPP. Easily IMO.

Lynch KPF and likely injured this week.

Bice v Moraes?

Bice.

Mid rookies are dime a dozen. Trainor and Reid can’t be trusted on field.

Maric v Moraes & $$

Maric.

He’ll earn the same while pumping out 80+ each week and has DPP.

 

[King Max]

With Hewett out, maybe better to get dead rookies out of my team.

First option.
Out SPP & Knevitt… keep Hewett.
In Smith & Humphries. Bank $13k

Second option.
Out Hewett and Knevitt.
In Humphries and Maric. Bank $137k

 

[Deliverance]

Keep
FOS - thumbs up
Knevitt - thumbs down

 

[St Steady]

Keep
FOS - thumbs up
Knevitt - thumbs down

 

[SloppyJoe]

I thought Knevitt was just being managed, so I traded Campo instead...

Can't change that but I can reverse my other rookie trade out, which was Hewett.

But who should I keep? Kneviit or Hewett?

Given Hewett's injury history I'm leaning towards keeping Knevitt.

 

[YellowAndBlack83]

Torn between
Out - SDK, Flynn, Lalor In - Soligo, Hump/Maric, Bice

or

Out - Lalor, Flynn, Paton In - Hump, Maric, Moraes

 

[EA100]

Petracca/JHF > Baz, Campo > Moraes, Hewett > Maric

or

Short > Bice, Campo > Baz, Hewett > Maric