News NWM stays at Saints (Will Faulkner wrong about being crows bound)

[Doctor Feel]

Mate you're the go to man for player's funerals.

Speaking of, Bergman is friday.

 

[stfan]

So the billionaire dinner, sorry (bribes).worked..hey NAS be a consultant to my company for 200k a year and I'll given your Uncle 10 million to be production manager 1 day a year.

The Dinner was actually held a lot earlier in the season despite the hack who tried to pretend it was recent.

 

[davesnothere]

Outside your very obvious untouchables, I don't particularly want any other port player more than another. Farrell suggestion was purely based on age and he walks into our best 22 I'd have thought.
Berry and or Whitlock may be the better long term prospect, but us losing Nas sends us backwards a mile as it is. Speculative picks and unproven young players don't help us immediately.
IF I was running stkilda I want an immediate best 22 from 2026 onwards + future prospects.
We will get well under his value- i think i have posted here before where that he is worth pick 1 + (based on known vs unknown quantity and his age) but that isnt happening and we all know that.

You guys are coming for Whitlock.

He’s having his 1st run on Sunday. If you watch the game to have a look at him I’ll apologise in advance for Ken and what we’ve become.

It’s not a deal anyone on this board likes and we feel we can get a deal done without giving him up.

C4 mentioned him a couple of weeks ago giving the impression Saints have asked.

Farrell could happen as well with 2 1st round picks but Whitlock would be only one 1st.

 

[Wargreymon90]

You guys are coming for Whitlock.

He’s having his 1st run on Sunday. If you watch the game to have a look at him I’ll apologise in advance for Ken and what we’ve become.

It’s not a deal anyone on this board likes and we feel we can get a deal done without giving him up.

C4 mentioned him a couple of weeks ago giving the impression Saints have asked.

Farrell could happen as well with 2 1st round picks but Whitlock would be only one 1st.

Whitlock and one 1st would be absolute robbery.

 

[davesnothere]

Whitlock and one 1st would be absolute robbery.

If we have to give something

 

[Wargreymon90]

If we have to give something

lol we are not on the same page

 

[davesnothere]

lol we are not on the same page

He’s out of contract.

 

[PAFC66]

Oh well that's settled then

 

[240volt]

Giving up our best two picks for the next two years plus our best young prospect we have on our list is crazy.
I wouldn’t do that trade, the same people that say we should are the ones that will be complaining in years that St Kilda have gone past us.
Whitlock stays, find another player.

 

[Wargreymon90]

Giving up our best two picks for the next two years plus our best young prospect we have on our list is crazy.
I wouldn’t do that trade, the same people that say we should are the ones that will be competing in years that St Kilda have gone past us.
Whitlock stays, find another player.

You do realise it’s for one of the best players in the competition. Who is also a “young prospect”.

 

[QPower]

I think NWM worth roughly the same as JHF was worth at the time we did that trade.

Folks suggesting he is worth what Chris Judd was worth when he moved to Carlton need to remember Judd was already highly decorated and an all time great at that point in time.

 

[powermacs]

Giving up our best two picks for the next two years plus our best young prospect we have on our list is crazy.
I wouldn’t do that trade, the same people that say we should are the ones that will be competing in years that St Kilda have gone past us.
Whitlock stays, find another player.

The club just needs to be smart enough to make sure we can bring in all of our NGA’s and FS we will be getting. I’m sure that’s part of the planning.

 

[davesnothere]

I think NWM worth roughly the same as JHF was worth at the time we did that trade.

Folks suggesting he is worth what Chris Judd was worth when he moved to Carlton need to remember Judd was already highly decorated and an all time great at that point in time.

No. JHF was under contract.

 

[Zakk Wylde]

Port ITK V Saints ITK

 

[240volt]

The club just needs to be smart enough to make sure we can bring in all of our NGA’s and FS we will be getting. I’m sure that’s part of the planning.

That’s fair enough but 200cm players with potential don’t grow on trees.
We need not to go overboard on what we give up.

 

[Toppa]

You guys are coming for Whitlock.

He’s having his 1st run on Sunday. If you watch the game to have a look at him I’ll apologise in advance for Ken and what we’ve become.

It’s not a deal anyone on this board likes and we feel we can get a deal done without giving him up.

C4 mentioned him a couple of weeks ago giving the impression Saints have asked.

Farrell could happen as well with 2 1st round picks but Whitlock would be only one 1st.

It would appear to me that our interest might be because we are uncertain in kings knee long term. But that's just a guess.
I will certainly watch with interest but note bit rough on the kid debuting against thr cats in Geelong.

 

[ahneadearut]

This Tony dude is either going to be an absolute hero on the Saints board , or win the Turkey of the year award.

 

[JUSTWORK]

Yea I’d not be giving up Whitlock lightly, our next 2 firsts is reasonable, especially if we get academy access to Cochrane who would almost certainly be bid on before our first pick anyway.

Maybe try upgrade our first pick this year into a first rounder instead of two future firsts.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Tbh if Tony actually works for the club, ofc he's going to be optimistic Nas is staying especially after seeing him on Ross's shoulders.

 

[jackag24]

This Tony dude is either going to be an absolute hero on the Saints board , or win the Turkey of the year award.

And lets be honest, even if he does stay, it has nothing to do with Tony

 

[Rash]

Tony has a 50/50 chance, he guesses i reckon.

 

[ctpower]

So St Kilda are training today after which they will be making an announcement that NWM has agreed to stay.

Does anyone know what time they train. I assume it’s in the morning.

 

[Rash]

So St Kilda are training today after which they will be making an announcement that NWM has agreed to stay.

Does anyone know what time they train. I assume it’s in the morning.

Apparently training started an hour ago, saints board in shambles because apparently they're itk said he will re-sign at training this morning

 

[Ford Fairlane]

For those of us 'mature' enough to remember, is this going to be like the tidal wave that was going to wash Adelaide away?

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Apparently training started an hour ago, saints board in shambles because apparently they're itk said he will re-sign at training this morning

Are they selling tickets?

On a side note, when Russell Ebert won his third Magarey Medal, Bob McLean charged an admission fee to supporters to watch him train.