List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread (Cont’d)

[12kilos]

Mitch Cleary was bang on the money last night when he said the value for Hill right now is at its lowest point. A first round pick for Hill ain't happening.

Disagree, Hill is on a 4 year deal which gives Collingwood the upper hand.
Sure he had personal issues, but no comparison to JUH!
Hills problems seem also to have been ironed out.
Cleary is talking shit imho!
Worse case we keep him kills it in the next 2 years!
Then you might have Tasmania breathing down his neck
Pies hold the cards with Hill, its overs or he stays!
Both outcomes i would be content.
Would probably be happier if he stays
Arguably when Hill is firing there is no more dangerous small forward then him

 

[sr36]

In 2025. They don’t win it in 2024 without Daniher and are spending big to bring Allen across for 2026. I think they value them and just made it work this year through the sheer brilliance of their small mid/fwd brigade across the final 3 weeks. That’s where I’d be focusing $ moving forward.

I agree. They're adding a high priced ruck too. It's the same with every role. Having good players in any role helps, but if you're good enough elsewhere you can still win it with role players in any role. Harris aside, their tall set up is really bad, but their mids, runners and hybrid forwards are League best.

 

[soreplums]

I would prefer just to have it once every quarter and thats it. Nothing better than hearing the first bound in an eerie dead quiet in the first final.

Throw it up around the ground. Bounce after each goal is what I’d like.

But starting the game with a bounce would be nice for tradition sake.

 

[Vicky Park]

The only time I like seeing a ruckman is when one of the freaks is trying to fit themselves in to an economy seat.

And not on the aisle.

 

[TradeDraft]

They need to get a Stadium 1st Built

 

[manicpie]

Will we look to add a tagger for next year?. I hope not but if we do go down that path, Cincotta is available for free

 

[JOELY]

Trade radio listeners, how are we coping with that Didi ad so far? Think it might be the end of me by the end of the trade period.

 

[gouki88]

The only time I like seeing a ruckman is when one of the freaks is trying to fit themselves in to an economy seat.

You’re a bastard for triggering me like this

 

[lyfsux]

Throw it up around the ground. Bounce after each goal is what I’d like.

They do that now

 

[ksardog]

Will we look to add a tagger for next year?. I hope not but if we do go down that path, Cincotta is available for free

why dont we just develop Q or have Perryman do it instead of getting some other sides scrubber to take the role
Parker slots in at half back next year, we also have Ryan and Jiath hopefully knocking the door down for senior selection. think Q could be great in there, also help with the lack of speed in there

 

[soreplums]

They do that now

Keep it

 

[lyfsux]

Keep it

nope its goneski

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

They need to get a Stadium 1st Built

The Devils were always going to be coming into the league before a Mac Point stadium was going to be completed, why should the AFL wait to develop list rules?

 

[soreplums]

nope its goneski

I know. But I like it

 

[Jen2310]

 

[Matt_352]

Why would he go to that basket case

 

[bunter]

no way he's doing that

 

[Harry O]

I asked the question of Sydney Sweeney too

 

[Bianconeri]

Will we look to add a tagger for next year?. I hope not but if we do go down that path, Cincotta is available for free

We can just use Perryman

 

[anshell]

Jeez,these media types are really desperate to prise Jamie out of Collingwood,aren’t they?

 

[PonsfordMagpie]

Who's Mitch Cleary's source? Sam Edmund?

 

[JLC]

Waiting for the, I had a lot to think of but I love the club, I love my team mates so it was an easy decision in the end and I’ve always wanted to stay a one team player post/announcement.

But thanks to the Suns for the free holiday.

 

[No SPIN]

Is it too soon to suggest Elijah Hollands?

A very very sad waste of talent - one can only hope he gets his life sorted.

 

[JLC]

Jeez,these media types are really desperate to prise Jamie out of Collingwood,aren’t they?

100% and they want no one going to us.

 

[BillyElliott]

Fk off Carlton. And you too Graham Wright.