- Jul 6, 2017
- 36,291
- 54,878
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Delisted Callum Ah Chee - Joins Adelaide via the PSD
- Thread starter go_the_dockers
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Go back and read the post. I only said you have also had the opportunity from 1991 for players who could have produced F/S but haven't. The Lion have been fortunate enough too. As have the Pies & doggies.
Talk about creating your own narrative.
Blake Coleman was a fail and delisted. Kiddy Coleman went as an overager pick 35, Sam marshall pick 25. check your facts. Anabelle this year is the 1st midfielder who looks to go early. Wow!
you must be new to footy
I keeping wondering what age some of these posters are.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
how does responding to someone who says Brisbane has only ever had a single first round pick, that being Hipwood, with 2 first rounders that happened within the last couple years, mean i'm new to footy? lol what...
Blake Coleman, was still a first round pick whether he was good or not. Sam Marshall was still regarded as being in the first round as other academy picks came before him pushed it back, its still the first round.
2024 AFL draft - Wikipedia
might not like the facts, but just because a player is a "fail" doesnt mean anything, a player can be a fail without going through academy. The draft is a risk whether you have an academy or not
By that logic, we never got a first rounder in 2019, wheres our refund for Fischer?
for a start this is the thread about ah Chee and the trade that never happened
ah right, now we want to bring it back after getting found out on multiple lies you lions supporters have been spewing for the past 2 days lmao.
your list management thread is in meltdown, just basically crying about every other club and their supporters
you've been on bigfooty 2 weeks I dont think you even know what meltdown is, secondly you really think any of us give a stuff oh no we missed out on future pick 40(around about) a total of 270 points
Back 2 back we really dont care, the whole saga could of been over with a pick slide and f2
that would be around 500 points which is equal to pick 28 a good deal for everyone
- May 18, 2015
- 2,600
- 2,176
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Thought there was something about trading in pick 29 but Brisbane refused..
no, we wanted a pick slide 16-23 and the pick slide is worth 270 points and pick 40 is worth 238 = 508 points
pick 28 = 505 points
If you dont think ah Chee is worth pick 28 I really dont have anything else to say and everyone wonders why we didnt take the rubbish deal
Using DVI to justify what picks are worth is so Brisbane and GCS supporters lol. Would you trade picks in the 30s, 40s and 50s for pick 2 which Will Ashcroft was selected??????
youve been on here for nearly 20 years and have only 1800 posts, talk about casual
thats literally how list managers determine value
secondly will Ashcroft has nothing to do with the trade
thirdly we used our first round pick for Ashcroft
must be nice being able to use this logic, other clubs don't get the luxury
I didnt feel the need to post for 15 years and im starting to remember whyyouve been on here for nearly 20 years and have only 1800 posts, talk about casual
some other people feel this way too, except don't make acccounts....
If you think Sam Marshall and Blake Coleman were taken in the genuine first rd, then no doubt you'd support a Crows 2nd rd pick was significantly unders in a trade for Ah Chee. As by that logic the crows 2nd rd pick is going to be in the early 40s...
FYI those two players were taken at pick 24 and pick 25...
Last edited:
you aren't very bright
We were giving Adelaide the option instead of going and finding a pick suitable(somewhere in the 20's do a pick slide and f2 that equates to that pick
how hard is it to understand your f2 probably around half of ah Chee value somewhere in the twenties is about right which you never offered
If you honestly believe ah Chee is worth (around pick 40) I dont know what to tell you
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
leighmo
Senior List
- Feb 19, 2025
- 215
- 407
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Grasping at straws to deny this is the exact thing you argued is a mythI didn't see Adelaide threatening to walk Ah Chee to the PSD; they made multiple offers to him over the week before deadline day
Also--- is it even a guarantee that Ah Chee makes it to the Crows?
Based on your summary there, the crows did offer well unders for Ah Chee... they had the assets to get an early 20s pick for him... they just sat on their hands instead.
Ah Chee now has to be dragged through the mud of the PSD all because your club wanted a cheapie. Players will have taken note of Adelaide's trade approach - it would put me off considering them if I had to be traded that's for sure.
No they don't, it's only those with a massive leg up think and why Dom "the prick" is so arrogant with the worth of a 2nd rounder. Name a list manger who would trade pick 30s, 40s and 50s for pick 2 and they will be sacked on the spot.
Nah Adelaide committed a fat contract to Ah Chee and didn't want to get him via a fair trade.
Brisbane traded Starce without issue - if we were not fair traders, Starce wouldn't have been traded either. Adelaide on the other hand, they have form in this area.
we didnt get Ashcroft for that we used our first round pick you are just to dense to understand also thats 3 years ago and not relevant
ask the bulldogs what happened to our first round pick that year
