Autopsy Round 1 = Collingwood 79-93 Adelaide

[spenze]

I hope this is not out of place but any win against the Pies is a very good win.

We rate your team that well

 

[JLC]

Swap Moore for McStay? Although that makes me a little nervous...

I think a fully fit Moore would give you a better contest.

We probably at present have the worst or second worst trio in the AFL.

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

14 points off a win with the umps awarding many 50 metre penalties to get them across the line. But despite this we didn't deserve to win. We were smashed out of the middle in the third quarter and were missing someone like Moore to stop their talls from marking. We had Quaynor on a bloke 20cm taller then him at times. It was just a poor match up.

 

[anshell]

We are a decent hard working side that never gives up.But our forward line lacks class and speed,and our centre square set up is diabolical.Oh,and we usually play against teams that have four extra players playing for them,all of who are dressed in yellow.So that doesn’t help either.

 

[No SPIN]

With all due respect…
Pies look the worst they have under McRae since 2024, when they missed finals

LOL - defending the bed wetters and chicken littles is hardly a heroic act.

 

[eyeroller]

 

[CaptainHowdy87]

DC getting beaten by McAndrew was not on my bingo card. He struggles with taller ruckman.

We should've held onto Big Mase for another year

 

[peter9789]

I might add to my earlier post, He’s not the only one but Ed Allan is absolutely awful. 2 very poor games and he needs to go back to VFL. I’m not sure he’s AFL standard.

Buller, early days but I’m not hopeful.

Hope we get a look at west and Anderson soon

 

[Moore of the Same]

We should've held onto Big Mase for another year

Nah, play Steene.

 

[CaptainHowdy87]

Mcstay is a list clogger

He's seriously terrible. One of the dumbest players I've ever seen.

 

[MoreMoore]

Howe and Moore will not fix your forward line champ.

It fixes the way we move the ball
More speed on the ball opens up the forward line
You should be well aware of this at Carlscum with your rubbish backline.

 

[CheckerTrade666]

Walking into this thread:

 

[crackerss08]

Soooo bbboooorrrriiiinnnggggg
Outside daicos and pendles most players are crap… this side will turn everyone against McRae… his moves were baffling..
Where are our new fresh shoots???
There is no good youth coming through.. McRae pushing our players to play into their 30s is worrying…

 

[Matrix10]

Fly .. get back to the run and gun carefree game style ... balances out with your lifestyle. Last $20 on the cards. All keys in the jar. See who it matches up with
Keep swinging

 

[JOELY]

What has changed with the way we're using Houston and why couldnt we have sorted this out last year?

 

[surfer1]

Hard to be critical of Steele and Pendles tonight

 

[MoreMoore]

Swap Moore for McStay? Although that makes me a little nervous...

Moore as forward/ruck could work with the new ruck rules
McStay and Frampton as the shit truck defenders and Howe intercepting

 

[Run n Spread]

Disappointing night.
Actually thought they played well 2nd half of 1q but delivery into the 50 was shocking.
Than the 3rd q they just spread the ground and killed on leg speed.
While the foward line has its woes midfield looked one pace. They also always had a spare behind the ball run into the contest and provide a link.
Did well to fight it out and looked a show early in the last. One game don't think it's time to call it yet

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

Soooo bbboooorrrriiiinnnggggg
Outside daicos and pendles most players are crap… this side will turn everyone against McRae… his moves were baffling..
Where are our new fresh shoots???
There is no good youth coming through.. McRae pushing our players to play into their 30s is worrying…

Parker was good. Steele kicked 2 goals.

 

[Moore of the Same]

Moore as forward/ruck could work with the new ruck rules
McStay and Frampton as the shit truck defenders and Howe intercepting

McStay and Frampton taking possession coming out if D50 is the stuff of nightmares.

 

[nahnah]

Club needs to get serious about its key position stocks in the off season. Such a disadvantage. How is our only capable back up key defender a guy still recovering from ACL surgery.
All 3 key forwards are laugh out loud bad. Might as well pump games into West like RIchmond do with their key forwards from the same draft.

 

[OEP MKII]

Thought we went in with the correct game plan given our backline deficiencies, but unfortunately the team just couldn't hold up for the whole game. It would've been a massive win if the team got over the line, but Adelaide were deserving winners.
On to next week.

 

[JoinDate]

Despite the loss, it's good knowing Ollie's mum tucked him into bed tonight and gave him a big kiss on the head. No doubt he's all snuggled up, cuddling his teddy.

 

[MoreMoore]

B. IQ. McStay. Maynard
HB. Houston. Frampton. Howe
C. Steele. Pendles. Lipinski
HF. Shultz. Moore. Mcreery
F. Elliot. Degoey. West

R. Cameron. Naicos. Jaicos

Int. Sidey. Perryman. Crisp Allan HH

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

Mcstay is a list clogger

We don’t win 23 without him. His goals in the qualifying and prelim were crucial.

That being said, seems to have 0 confidence.

Either get him behind the ball or drop him.