Remove this Banner Ad

Collingwood and Richmond - who has the greater supporter base

Who has the greater supporter base?

  • Total voters
    302

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Tiger2709 said:
So like us your the biggest club around your flag years no surprises there.
Oh you forgot 2017 we again were no.1. And now of course.

As for members your struggling to get any where near us, even after finishing runners up, your best is 20000 behind our best and right now your 20000 behind us.
Click to expand...

You weren’t #1 in home and away.

https://afltables.com/afl/crowds/summary.html

Try again.
 
Last edited:
ToddaRools said:
Do you regularly open your mouth and spew crap, or is it just reserved for your online keyboard warrior antics? Anzac Day is nothing but pies and bombers supporters, regardless of ladder position it’s always a memorable day, arguably up there with the grand final in terms of atmosphere and crowd numbers. Now run away back to the safety of your no opposition circle jerk forum you annoying minnow and talk about 2017 being b2b with 1981 and your umpiring conspiracies
Click to expand...
Lol are you kidding Anzac day has more neutrals than any day other than the GF its a day Sheedy copied because Richmond and Collingwood in 1977 attracted 92000, it is still the 3rd biggest crowd on the day.

don't be fooled into thinking this is purely about the Bombers and Magpies - it's so much more than that.
http://www.espn.com.au/afl/story/_/id/23291018/afl-collingwood-essendon-makes-anzac-day-mcg-special

Lesson over its time for bed youngster, the adults are talking.
 
Last edited:
Tiger2709 said:
No one is denying you have been the biggest club at times, just not when Richmond are up and about, we were bigger for most of the 60's and 70's as were Carlton and right now we are the biggest side, you were 5th last year but have probably moved up to 3rd biggest club after WCE and Richmond.
Click to expand...

Lol again 9.2 million ahead of Richmond. Biggest club on social media and will be the biggest drawing club in the afl this year.

Collingwood, West Coast, Adelaide and Essendon are the big 4!

Richmond were only drawing more in the 60’s and 70’s because they played at the mcg while Collingwood were playing at Victoria Park. You all were boasting about Richmond being more popular then Collingwood on Instagram but Collingwood has quickly overtaken them
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Tiger2709 said:
Lol are you kidding Anzac day has more neutrals than any day other than the GF its a day atarted by Richmond and Collingwood in 1977 and that is still the 3rd biggest crowd on the day.

Lesson over its time for bed youngster, the adults are talking.
Click to expand...

Lol Collingwood are involved in the top 6 biggest home and away crowds of all time. Richmond only 1! Collingwood are also involved in 16 of the top 20 biggest crowds of all time.

If Richmond were so big why don’t they hold the biggest home and away attendance record set in 2010 by the pies?
 
gopies1981 said:
Lol Collingwood are involved in the top 6 biggest home and away crowds of all time. Richmond only 1! Collingwood are also involved in 16 of the top 20 biggest crowds of all time.

If Richmond were so big why don’t they hold the biggest home and away attendance record set in 2010 by the pies?
Click to expand...

It’s like talking to brick walls.
 
Ilksy said:
How about you go the best averages table in the link I gave you numbnuts. Excluding 2019.
Click to expand...

I’ll post 2019 attendance figures as of next week and watch Collingwood attendance’s increase over Richmond. Collingwood will easily draw more then Richmond last year. Richmond play gws will get 15,000 compared to Collingwood v West Coast and the mcc is expecting 58,000 to the game. Has Richmond ever drawn over 50,000 in Melbourne v west Coast? No
 
Tiger2709 said:
Are there any grown up Collingwood supporters on Bigfooty I can speak with?
View attachment 646565

Now I can see you're all getting a little tired and grumpy, so nighty night kids, lesson over.
Click to expand...

:$

Why do you want to keep talking about 2017 specifically? Collingwood has had seasons where more people attended, and it’s not even close. 2010 creams 2017.

1D336CF8-54EE-4592-B5A0-A4775A5F4349.png
26E34281-3567-4FBF-B50E-643693084F13.png
8ECD6470-9284-4D16-A84F-3F34756B46B2.png
7B7958D3-38AE-4905-9599-2CBD96FEC9C8.png
71C8DF18-12BA-4CDB-A9C1-9DA357105143.png
94ECF4D3-5EF9-421E-9415-A90FD2637361.png
D5E9E434-C0D5-45CD-B1A2-7A5EE7AAD0A0.png
C68A41A4-6CC3-4B8E-AE5B-64CCD29BD9C1.png

I’m not even sure why you guys are arguing this point?
 
Last edited:
Ilksy said:
:$

Why do you want to keep talking about 2017 specifically? Collingwood has had seasons where more people attended, and it’s not even close. 2010 creams 2017.

View attachment 646595
View attachment 646596
View attachment 646597
View attachment 646598
View attachment 646592
View attachment 646591
View attachment 646593
View attachment 646594

I’m not even sure why you guys are arguing this point?
Click to expand...

Game, set, match.

Look at when Collingwood won a premiership we average 21,600 more then Richmond in 2010 during the home and away season

In Richmond’s premiership year they averaged 900 more people during the home and away season. Says it all
Really
 
Last edited:
Collingwood are the biggest club in the comp, anyone who suggests otherwise is naive.
Tigers have cemented themselves as the 2nd atm, but a successful Bomber period could change that.
I think some have forgotten the size of the bombers base.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Ilksy said:
:$

Why do you want to keep talking about 2017 specifically? Collingwood has had seasons where more people attended, and it’s not even close. 2010 creams 2017.

View attachment 646595
View attachment 646596
View attachment 646597
View attachment 646598
View attachment 646592
View attachment 646591
View attachment 646593
View attachment 646594

I’m not even sure why you guys are arguing this point?
Click to expand...
This is a discussion on who is bigger right now, Ive said Collingwood were bigger and have generally been bigger in the past but right now we are.
Look at 2013 no flag for 33 years like Collingwoods drought except we had no success at all, yet still number 2, not many if any clubs could stay that big with oir lack of success, we were the sleeping giant we're now awake.

Oh unless you believe Roy Morgan in which case Sydney are the biggest by a mile
 
Tiger2709 said:
This is a discussion on who is bigger now, Ive said Collingwood were bigger in the past but right now we are.
Look at 2013 no flag for 33 years like Collingwoods drought except we had no success at all, yet still number 2, we were the sleeping giant were now awake.
Click to expand...

We’ll draw more this season. Bookmark it.
 
Wortho said:
Collingwood are the biggest club in the comp, anyone who suggests otherwise is naive.
Tigers have cemented themselves as the 2nd atm, but a successful Bomber period could change that.
I think some have forgotten the size of the bombers base.
Click to expand...

Essendon are the 2nd biggest Victorian club in the competition. Richmond currently 3rd. A successful Carlton will overtake Richmond.
 
I reckon the order is currently Richmond > West Coast > Adelaide > Sydney > Essendon > Carlton/Collingwood depending on form > Hawthorn > Freo > Port/Saints > Melbourne > Geelong > North/Dogs > Brisbane > GWS/GC
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

gopies1981 said:
Essendon are the 2nd biggest Victorian club in the competition. Richmond currently 3rd. A successful Carlton will overtake Richmond.
Click to expand...
Essendon are no where near our size, they were never that big except under Sheedy when they were winning flags, there are no indicators that would put them ahead of Richmond Collingwood or Hawthorn, oh except Roy Morgan:$

There is a reason only one club was ever known as the sleeping giant, that reason is now obvious.
 
Craze said:
I reckon the order is currently Richmond > West Coast > Adelaide > Sydney > Essendon > Carlton/Collingwood depending on form > Hawthorn > Freo > Port/Saints > Melbourne > Geelong > North/Dogs > Brisbane > GWS/GC
Click to expand...

Lol you have no idea. The biggest clubs in terms of drawing power and supporters are

1. West Coast
2. Adelaide
3. Collingwood
4. Essendon
5. Richmond
5. Carlton
7. Sydney
8. Hawthorn
9. Geelong
10. Fremantle
11. Port Adelaide
12. Brisbane
13. Melbourne
14. St.kilda
15. Western bulldogs
16. North Melbourne
17. GWS
18. Gold Coast

Richmond are not even close on a national scale to Collingwood and Essendon.

The only people who actually think that Richmond are the biggest Victorian club are Richmond supporters. All other supporters all agree that Collingwood is the biggest. We have always been the biggest apart from a small period from 1996-2001 when Essendon were biggest but even that was debatable because Collingwood were down the bottom.

Collingwood are 7 million more in attendance’s then Carlton and Essendon and 9.2 million more then Richmond.

Collingwood is also the biggest club on social media in the afl even more then west Coast and Adelaide. This proves that Collingwood have the biggest latent supporter base in the country.

These stats clearly proves that Collingwood is the biggest Victorian club in Australia. Richmond fans have no stats to prove their claim.
 
Richmond are miracle workers.

The club and its supporters are such campaigners that they've made Collingwood and its supporter base look good.

I might even *like* Collingwood because of it.

Someone get George Pell down here to get the Sainthood process starte....oh :(
 
frggr said:
Richmond are miracle workers.

The club and its supporters are such campaigners that they've made Collingwood and its supporter base look good.

I might even *like* Collingwood because of it.

Someone get George Pell down here to get the Sainthood process starte....oh :(
Click to expand...

Richmond may have overtaken Collingwood on the Geelong hate scale but no doubt Hawthorn would still have Richmond covered.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Tandy
    • Like
  • Poll Poll
Think Tank Essendon, Carlton and Richmond. Who has the worst list in the AFL?
2
Replies
25
Views
374
James Colorado
James Colorado
Elmer_Hauser
    • Wow
    • Like
People less bigoted, intolerant and toxic than the average Collingwood supporter
2
Replies
45
Views
2K
Magland
Magland
Footy Is Good
    • Like
    • Haha
The DKH Medal - and the "winner" is...
2 3 4 5
Replies
100
Views
1K
Footy Is Good
Footy Is Good
Footy Is Good
I'm a Collingwood supporter, ask me anything.
2 3
Replies
71
Views
2K
Footy Is Good
Footy Is Good
Elmer_Hauser
    • Haha
Things that grow/breed/infest themselves in the average Collingwood supporter bush/nether regions and or rear end
Replies
14
Views
304
Footy Is Good
Footy Is Good
BigVic
    • Haha
    • Wow
**** off Jose Who plays Hawthorn in the Grand Final this year?
2
Replies
33
Views
636
Chronz
Chronz
FISTO
    • Sad
    • Like
    • Haha
Think Tank The introduction of wild card has killed off Richmond’s Identity.
2 3 4
Replies
95
Views
3K
catscratchfever
catscratchfever

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom