2019 Rookies

[Benno_900]

any of these blokes going to effect LDU's scoring?

Dumont predominantly plays wing.

I can't see all of Anderson, LDU, Tyson and Ahern in the same team. So one extra mid shouldn't affect him too much.

At the moment, Ahern is the lucky one out. But I'd prefer Tyson out.

 

[Feerits Elf]

So only field him if the weather is good?

Or if playing at Docklands ...

 

[Benno_900]

Hore to Rozee or Collins?

 

[LukasTheGreat]

Gotta get Parker.

 

[JT_the_Man]

Scrimshaw or Rozee?

 

[Unknown Caller]

Should I trade out Balta for Miers?

 

[JT_the_Man]

Should I trade out Balta for Miers?

Nah, Balta back in this week.

 

[SC fish]

Hore to Rozee or Collins?

Rozee with DPP for mine

 

[gutsroy]

Should I trade out Balta for Miers?

Would hold, give Balta a chance. Miers looked pretty good, but not sure he’s worth sidewaysing a playing rookie for.

 

[stevebbb]

Atkins just killed his moneymaking potential with that 30. Hopefully he sticks around and crawls to $250k

 

[Migzeh]

I pooped it up. So heres a terrible idea.

I Had kentstable on the bench as my E.

I also have scott and gibbons on the bench. (both playing)

How dumb would it be to trade gibbons to a non playing mid rookie to get that 99.

I also have ridley in my backline doing **** all except clogging up 200+k.

Also how dumb would it be to trade ridley to another playing rookie or a i can swing moore back to def and bring in a fwd rookie.

After typing it i think it sounds pretty dumb. side ways trades to chase ~40 points.

Im yet to make a trade so feeling a bit off ya know.

 

[SC fish]

I pooped it up. So heres a terrible idea.

I Had kentstable on the bench as my E.

I also have scott and gibbons on the bench. (both playing)

How dumb would it be to trade gibbons to a non playing mid rookie to get that 99.

I also have ridley in my backline doing **** all except clogging up 200+k.

Also how dumb would it be to trade ridley to another playing rookie or a i can swing moore back to def and bring in a fwd rookie.

After typing it i think it sounds pretty dumb. side ways trades to chase ~40 points.

Im yet to make a trade so feeling a bit off ya know.

Don't do the first one - hope for a late OUT so you pick up Constables' score.

The second one sounds OK though

 

[Juzzomac]

I pooped it up. So heres a terrible idea.

I Had kentstable on the bench as my E.

I also have scott and gibbons on the bench. (both playing)

How dumb would it be to trade gibbons to a non playing mid rookie to get that 99.

I also have ridley in my backline doing **** all except clogging up 200+k.

Also how dumb would it be to trade ridley to another playing rookie or a i can swing moore back to def and bring in a fwd rookie.

After typing it i think it sounds pretty dumb. side ways trades to chase ~40 points.

Im yet to make a trade so feeling a bit off ya know.

Don't do it. Midfield cash generation is far more important than 30-40 points.

 

[Sainterz12]

I pooped it up. So heres a terrible idea.

I Had kentstable on the bench as my E.

I also have scott and gibbons on the bench. (both playing)

How dumb would it be to trade gibbons to a non playing mid rookie to get that 99.

I also have ridley in my backline doing **** all except clogging up 200+k.

Also how dumb would it be to trade ridley to another playing rookie or a i can swing moore back to def and bring in a fwd rookie.

After typing it i think it sounds pretty dumb. side ways trades to chase ~40 points.

Im yet to make a trade so feeling a bit off ya know.

Do it, another one out of the way to 50k

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Atkins just killed his moneymaking potential with that 30. Hopefully he sticks around and crawls to $250k

Would've been better as a late out as was the goss.

Kent would've been LDU.

 

[pincrusher]

I pooped it up. So heres a terrible idea.

I Had kentstable on the bench as my E.

I also have scott and gibbons on the bench. (both playing)

How dumb would it be to trade gibbons to a non playing mid rookie to get that 99.

I also have ridley in my backline doing **** all except clogging up 200+k.

Also how dumb would it be to trade ridley to another playing rookie or a i can swing moore back to def and bring in a fwd rookie.

After typing it i think it sounds pretty dumb. side ways trades to chase ~40 points.

Im yet to make a trade so feeling a bit off ya know.

Ridley trade makes sense. As for Kenstable, take your medicine and give yourself an uppercut for not having him on the field in the first place.

 

[Red Syrah]

I have all the main rookies and happy with them so was not bothered by Hore not playing. But then was remembered last night about cash generation, so is it worth a trade to go Hore>Scrimshaw for cash gen bc he wont be onfield?
Also, how is his JS?
Or do I hold Hore hoping for return somewhere down the track?

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Or do I hold Hore hoping for return somewhere down the track?

Always have a hore on hold just in case you need a booty call.

 

[Winx]

Should I trade out Balta for Miers?

Reckon Balta can bounce back this week ,been given a second chance and preseason form was good.Holding for mine.

 

[Kadog]

My rookies cows going into the first price rise.

Clark Duursma Wilkie Hore
Walsh LDU KentStable Scott Atkins Valente
Setters Drew Parker Balta

 

[Mofra]

Reckon Balta can bounce back this week ,been given a second chance and preseason form was good.Holding for mine.

Ditto - not burning a trade on a rookie swap.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hore is more useful as a loophole doughnut than a cash cow early in the season, particularly for teams with 3 def rookies on field and a decent D7 rookie. Think of him as a slow burn who will eventually make you 140k+ when he strings a few games together. A lot of SC's probably don't see it that way, but those early season 20-30 scores on field can ruin a round and use of a loophole doughnut can minimise that risk.

Depends on your def bench.
I have dirt hore and baby john.

Thinking moving hore to rimshaw.
Balta to parker.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Unsure on the balta move but l can see him in and out of the Richmond team.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Unsure on the balta move but l can see him in and out of the Richmond team.

ill dump him next week when he spuds it.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Thoughts on Hore to Wilke or Joyce.
Is it worth the trade, may make about 80k out it.
Is it worth it?