Analysis AFC SANFL 2019 Thread

[Stiffy_18]

No idea why they are continuing to play fog back in defence.. hes getting towelled up.. and if he gets towelled up there in the SANFL then he’ll get slaughtered in the AFL..

So the experiment is a failure.. put him back in the forward line..

After a single game? **** me the sky must be falling!

Do people recall Nathan Bock’s SANFL I think it was a PF when he got toweled up, destroyed, chewed up and spat out. Had an absolutely nightmare. Turned into a pretty good player before injuries got the better of him.

 

[Bicks]

Was that the first time you've watched the reserves?

Somethings never, ever, ever change!

 

[Bicks]

After a single game? **** me the sky must be falling!

Do people recall Nathan Bock’s SANFL I think it was a PF when he got toweled up, destroyed, chewed up and spat out. Had an absolutely nightmare. Turned into a pretty good player before injuries got the better of him.

Nah, not for mine. Fog is a forward.

 

[Bearded Clam]

After a single game? **** me the sky must be falling!

Do people recall Nathan Bock’s SANFL I think it was a PF when he got toweled up, destroyed, chewed up and spat out. Had an absolutely nightmare. Turned into a pretty good player before injuries got the better of him.

That’s two games in a row I’ve watched that he’s been towelled up down back.. and he looks completely disinterested in it too so it’s not gonna happen.

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

And Fogarty had a shocker.

Hardly his fault.

 

[hey shorty]

After a single game? **** me the sky must be falling!

Do people recall Nathan Bock’s SANFL I think it was a PF when he got toweled up, destroyed, chewed up and spat out. Had an absolutely nightmare. Turned into a pretty good player before injuries got the better of him.

He's a forward, a special one at that.

So play him there.

 

[Elite Crow]

Well that was a waste of $10. Sholl excellent, Poholke ok.

About it unfortunately

Given how well he played, would he be any chance of coming in given Seeds out?

 

[Eagleboy2011]

frees at 35-14. we must be the most clumsy and undisciplined ever.

Disgracefully uneven.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Hardly his fault.

I just feel like our coaches can’t get the simple / obvious things right. They’re trying to be too clever by half when they should just keep it simple where they can. Fog at CHF is too ****ing obvious for them.

 

[hey shorty]

Given how well he played, would he be any chance of coming in given Seeds out?

In some teams yes, in ours no.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Given how well he played, would he be any chance of coming in given Seeds out?

That’s two good games in a row for poholke. Another 12 or 13 of those and he might get his name put forward at selection.

 

[WetCrow1991]

**** this club for playing Fog in defence in the SANFL. Seriously, **** them. Honestly he should have played round 1.

 

[Stiffy_18]

Nah, not for mine. Fog is a forward.

He's a forward, a special one at that.

So play him there.

So was Matthew Pavlich but he only became a great forward at AFL level after spending a year or two in defense.

 

[WetCrow1991]

After a single game? **** me the sky must be falling!

Do people recall Nathan Bock’s SANFL I think it was a PF when he got toweled up, destroyed, chewed up and spat out. Had an absolutely nightmare. Turned into a pretty good player before injuries got the better of him.

Or we could play him forward. You know. First rounder, elite forward prospect.

 

[hey shorty]

That’s two good games in a row for poholke. Another 12 or 13 of those and he might get his name put forward at selection.

4 if you included the trials.

Play him in front of Gibbs.

 

[WetCrow1991]

So was Matthew Pavlich but he only became a great forward at AFL level after spending a year or two in defense.

Or that was irrelevant and he would have been a great forward regardless.

 

[hey shorty]

So was Matthew Pavlich but he only became a great forward at AFL level after spending a year or two in defense.

Not everyone is Matthew Pavlich.

The experiment isn't working and we are in dire need of a forward.... And you want to keep him in defence.

Utter madness.

 

[Bicks]

So was Matthew Pavlich but he only became a great forward at AFL level after spending a year or two in defense.

yeah well I'm not seeing any of that adaptability in Fogarty....

 

[CroCop]

I just checked out this McBean on YouTube and he is a tall big guy . I’m gathering Fog played a key defensive post and that he is not . He is not that tall Fog a 189cm that should be intercepting and jumping in front of the tall key forwards plus creating play . He should not be the main pillar in defense .

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

I just saw this McBean on YouTube and he is a tall big guy . I’m gathering Fog played a key defensive post and that he is not . He is not that tall Fog a 189cm that should be intercepting and jumping in front of the tall key forwards plus creating play . He should not be the main pillar in defense .

Fog is 193cm

 

[hey shorty]

Fog is 193cm

A great deal shorter than his opponent

 

[Bicks]

I just saw this McBean on YouTube and he is a tall big guy . I’m gathering Fog played a key defensive post and that he is not . He is not that tall Fog a 189cm that should be intercepting and jumping in front of the tall key forwards plus creating play . He should not be the main pillar in defense .

Same height as Tex Walker actually 193cm

 

[Stiffy_18]

Fogarty’s has two major deficiencies that need development, aerobic fitness base and he does not find the footy enough. Playing him in the backline will allow him to develop those aspects of his game more than if he was played as a forward with a defender constantly on his back.

For the record, I think he is a great forward prospect but he needs to get MUCH fitter and he needs to develop his ball getting ability. In the long run, playing games this early in his career in defense will help his development. It’s not about here and now but the long terms with these kids.

 

[WetCrow1991]

Fogarty’s has two major deficiencies that need development, aerobic fitness base and he does not find the footy enough. Playing him in the backline will allow him to develop those aspects of his game more than if he was played as a forward with a defender constantly on his back.

For the record, I think he is a great forward prospect but he needs to get MUCH fitter and he needs to develop his ball getting ability. In the long run, playing games this early in his career in defense will help his development. It’s not about here and now but the long terms with these kids.

Somersaults

 

[Elite Crow]

So how tall is this McBean fella?