Garcia isn’t in the same class though. I would hope someone better comes along for life after Bont and Libba. Not to say Garcia hasn’t got a role going forward and the things you suggested would help with this.
VFL 2024 VFL Thread
- Thread starter VitalDread
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I’m not having a go at Scott. Good, honest player. I was merely commenting about our depth where last couple years, he was firmly entrenched as best 22. This year (so far), he is behind another 3-4 players just to get a sniff at a spot.
Mofra
Moderator
- Dec 6, 2005
- 67,574
- 199,606
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Footscray, Coney Island Warriors
- Moderator
- #403
I do remember him talking about wanting to 'hit some bodies' in his debut speech. He certainly has a bit of grit to his play. If we are really all-in on this 'selection integrity' mantra, he might be playing ahead of Harmes.
BulldogMuscle
Honk For The Dogs
Give it a few hours full game will be uploaded
Thanks brah!
dogwatch
Premium Platinum
Western Bulldogs - Ed Richards Player Sponsor 2024
Western Bulldogs - Bailey Dale Player Sponsor 2024
Veteran
Western Bulldogs - Ed Richards Player Sponsor 2023
Western Bulldogs - Bailey Dale Player Sponsor 2023
10k Posts
Western Bulldogs - Bailey Dale Player Sponsor 2022
Western Bulldogs - Ed Richards Player Sponsor 2022
How did Scott go today? A typical solid Scott game? or a bit quiet?
out of finals
Senior List
Hope Chatfield's injury isn't as bad as it looked
Bedendo’s numbers very low. For those at the game or who watched was he lining up on the wing or the HFF dead zone? Really hoped he’d have a big year after performing in the last practice match and coming back really fit.
PocketRocket08
Team Captain
- Apr 26, 2022
- 313
- 383
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
JOD and Croft very athletic they will b
Played a combination of both. Mainly wing though. Obviously we want players getting their hands on the ball. However the way they compete and run defensively is very important also.
Dom was ok competed well and was strong in the air.
I see a lot of people knocking Jed. Please show a little patience first of all he was sick last week and remember this is his first pre season. Same with Clarke.
Jed fought back brilliantly in the second half and impacted in helping the team secure the win.
Best players today
Lobb
Harmes
Garcia
Craig-Peters
Clarke.
Also mention to freijah, Keath & Scott.
- Oct 12, 2012
- 7,051
- 10,991
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Freijah broke the game open many times with dangerous kicks switching play. Exactly what we need more of.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
- Apr 23, 2013
- 6,859
- 10,013
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Cleveland Indians
This ability makes modern day AFL players invaluable.
Will be watching this kid with great interest , sounds exactly what we need.
- Aug 15, 2014
- 10,704
- 22,131
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bulls
I will be absolutely shocked if he doesn't make it as an AFL player. He seems to have everything you need in the modern game. I'm not too sure on his inside or contested work but at this stage projects as a strong winger or half back type.
Garcia's form as a midfielder is hard to ignore.
My annoyance is that he will have a purple patch as a midfielder in the VFL then come in to the senior side as a small forward.
Dogs_R_Us
Space Traveller
Who would you like him to replace?
Exactly... I have no idea.
Last few years it was easier to make a case since our midfield was moving like puffing billy.
I still haven’t forgotten Garcia attempting to single-handedly match fix the Lions game against us last year lol
But his VFL form to end last year and start this year has been excellent. Sadly for him he’s seemingly fallen behind Gallagher and the newly acquired Harmes for any midfield time. If he gets given another shot at a small forward spot before Clarke I’d understand.
But his VFL form to end last year and start this year has been excellent. Sadly for him he’s seemingly fallen behind Gallagher and the newly acquired Harmes for any midfield time. If he gets given another shot at a small forward spot before Clarke I’d understand.
VFL player summary: Round 2 v Casey
Development and Player Leadership Coach, Jarryn Geary, reviews the 15 AFL-listed players who featured in Footscray’s round two win.
Jedd Busslinger
21 disposals, seven marks
“Jedd had a pretty strong day. He got a fair bit of the ball offensively, which was nice for a big unit to be running off half-back and continuing to develop his back craft against the bigger key position players. It's a pretty positive performance from Jedd.”
Rory Lobb
15 disposals, seven marks, four tackles, 20 hit-outs, five goals
“For the second week in a row Rory’s had another big impact on the game. He had seven shots at goal and kicked three from the ruck which was a positive for him. He was pretty influential on the day in getting the result for us, and continuing to dominate in the air at VFL level.”
Charlie Clarke
12 disposals, four tackles, two goals
“Chook had a really strong game. He kicked a couple goals, put a lot of pressure on as a small forward and ran really strongly throughout the day. He performed really well - that's a couple of weeks in a row now he’s started to string some pretty positive performances together.”
Jordan Croft
10 disposals, two marks
“It was Crofty’s first game for Footscray, so it was nice to see him out there and in colours that he's grown up barracking for his whole life. He had a really long pre-season obviously - being injured in the back end of the pre-season - but he was really good. He played sort of limited minutes which will look to increase over the next few weeks, but he was solid in his first game for the club.”
James O’Donnell
15 disposals, seven marks, two clearances
“JOD was good – it felt like he got better throughout the game the longer it went on. He performed really strongly in the back end, and obviously coming off some interrupted weeks, will look to continue to get some continuity in his football as he pushes for AFL selection.”
James Harmes
33 disposals, eight marks, five tackles, six clearances, one goal
“James is probably looking forward to playing some other opposition now - having played both of his former sides in his first two games for the football club – but he was really strong and responded really well. It’s obviously disappointing for him on the back of a suspension, but he was critical in us getting the result. He had a lot of the ball and brought his teammates into the game too.”
Dom Bedendo
Eight disposals, two marks, one goal
“Dom played majority wing this week, after spending a bit more time forward in the previous sort of 3-4 weeks. He played the wing role really well - didn't have a heap of the ball, but his impact on the game was quite strong. He managed to kick a goal too, which is nice for a wingman.”
Joel Freijah
23 disposals, seven marks, one clearance
“Joel’s spent the last 3-4 weeks at half back and is building his game nicely from there. He got a number of possessions off half-back and has been able to do that the last few weeks. He's continuing to work on his defensive craft – but for someone who hasn’t spent a lot of time down there, is developing nicely as a defender.”
Anthony Scott
20 disposals, five marks, four clearances
“Scotty was pretty solid. He’s also had a bit of an interrupted period, having one game on and one game off, so he's looking for some continuity in his game. He was solid on the wing though and hopefully can string a couple of games together now.”
Lachie McNeil
15 disposals, four marks, two clearances
“Lachie played mostly forward and ran really well throughout the game. He didn’t play last week as the carry-over emergency, so it was good for him to get a game back into his legs. He’ll take some confidence in the fact that he was able to play a full game and have a solid impact too.”
Arthur Jones
Seven disposals, four marks, two goals
“Arty was quite lively with two goals. His pressure was good, and he had a couple of nice chase-down tackles. We’re just looking for him to probably get in the game a bit more throughout the four quarters moving forward.”
Luke Cleary
18 disposals, six marks, two tackles
“Luke played a really strong game in the back-line. He was quite good defensively – he won the ball back from the opposition a lot and used it really well. His sort of run and bounce out of the back-line was really positive for us this week. He’s been good the last couple of weeks.”
Riley Garcia
31 disposals, seven marks, six tackles, seven clearances, one goal
“Sunny’s put together a good 3-4 weeks now really. He’s been consistent and again had a lot of ball playing through the midfield. His clearance work and contest work was really strong and he finished off the game really well – his last quarter especially helped us get over the line.”
Lachie Smith
Eight disposals, two marks, four tackles, two clearances, 23 hit-outs
“Lachie shared ruck duties with Lobby – to come up against some young Melbourne ruckmen who were really competitive meant he had a good battle on his hands. Like some of our other younger players who have had full pre-seasons and played a lot of footy already, I think Lachie will benefit having this next week off and will be looking forward to a rest. He’ll be pretty fresh for the next game.”
Alex Keath
19 disposals, four marks
“Keathy was solid – he’s been building over the last few weeks and has been on managed minutes but is building quite nicely. He's been leading the young group quite well down there. He had another strong game and defended really well. He’ll keep looking to build on his last month as he pushes for AFL selection.”
