List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread (Cont’d)

[HFF]

Their pick next year could be well in the teens the swans

Also it shows how they don’t rate Hayward or Florent for the deals they still have and want them off the books

 

[Jen2310]

 

[Rorzza]

Trade week is firing up now!

 

[Scodog10]

WOW, if that isn’t ridiculous overs I’m not sure what is.

Curnow is good but he’s no Buddy Franklin.

It’s about right, IMO. Hayward is the only piece in that deal that is particularly appealing. Sydney are moving on from Florent, 11 in a weak draft is a bit meh and the same goes for the 2026 1st which likely falls post 15 (and likely goes towards matching a Walker bid). I think Carlton will eke a little bit more out by the time it gets finalised.

 

[Peters_Nuts]

Fire the thread up TradeDraft !!

 

[satty]

Disappointed we are losing the dees pick, but was right about us targeting the lions late picks .

 

[lones37]

That blows Geelong out of the water, and surely Carlton will not give that up. In reality, Sydney F1 2026 might not be a top 10 pick, in fact mid teens most likely. But it still a huge offer and Carlton would be crazy not to take that.

 

[Mollythedolly]

So true.
I’m basically a god on this forum.

That’s not the inference when posters write OMG in reply to your posts…

 

[Masked Magician]

That’s a horrible deal, demons future 3rd could be pick 36-42 in 2026, a stronger draft and could come in even more when picks with points absorbed.

 

[GETSOMENUTS]

The prelim final was JDG Go time
and he went missing
They spent the whole year getting him right to ensure he could perform at that moment
I think Fly and co must be pretty ruthless and unforgiving if you let them down when it counts
Mistakes are fine, but going missing maybe not

Nah if that were the case Lipinski would have been on the scrap heap yonks ago.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

 

[PiesHateU2]

It’s about right, IMO. Hayward is the only piece in that deal that is particularly appealing. Sydney are moving on from Florent, 11 in a weak draft is a bit meh and the same goes for the 2026 1st which likely falls post 15. I think Carlton will eke a little bit more out by the time it gets finalised.

I would have put Hayward’s trade price in isolation as an early to mid round pick. I believe Carlton would have offered at least that plus more last year when they chased him.

Add to that pick 11 and a future first rounder and that’s three pretty high end FR draft picks.

Plus a player in Florent who might have fallen from previous heights but is still pretty handy and started in 16 games out of 24 for the Swans this year.

Yeah, it’s overs for mine.

 

[JLC]

That's a fairly competitive offer.

If I was Carlton I would request one of their tall forwards. Rock the boat a bit.

 

[Pistol Night]

Suck shit to all involved. Hope he gets stuck at Essendon

 

[PiesHateU2]

Nice one Jen. Finally some movement from our Pies

 

[nickyds35]

Tbh florent is a salary dump.

All 3 of Ainsworth, Hayward and Florent were free agents last year and would be in between $600k and $750k, if your Carlton you take florent off that deal.

Then again, Voss is coaching for his life, might want as many senior players as possible.

 

[Pistol Night]

WOW, if that isn’t ridiculous overs I’m not sure what is.

Curnow is good but he’s no Buddy Franklin.

Not for a 29yo with questionable knees and Septemberitis

 

[PonsfordMagpie]

Our current 2025 draft hand in light of those pick swaps.

39, 45, 56, 61, 77, 95, 113

 

[Scodog10]

I would have put Hayward’s trade price in isolation as an early to mid round pick. I believe Carlton would have offered at least that plus more last year when they chased him.

Add to that pick 11 and a future first rounder and that’s three pretty high end FR draft picks.

Plus a player in Florent who might have fallen from previous heights but is still pretty handy and started in 16 games out of 24 for the Swans this year.

Yeah, it’s overs for mine.

We’ll see. Word is Sydney want 22 back so this deal is dead in the water because Carlton won’t do that.

 

[FatherTime]

De goey made massive progress during the year, I did think he was cooked. Pre finals the club stated he was further progressed than they expected. With a preseason, without hindrance, he would deliver much more. A finals match winner is gold.

So how do you explain the fall away in his form from the first final to the prelim? Sure the hit he took obviously knocked the stuffing out of him, but he hadn't contributed much prior to that hit and certainly had never looked the matchwinner we needed him to be. Only the club would know the true nature of any chronic conditions he may be carrying e.g. groin.

 

[PonsfordMagpie]

Buckley joining Geelong as an assistant coach.

 

[satty]

Our current 2025 draft hand in light of those pick swaps.

39, 45, 56, 61, 77, 95, 113

Not trading 39 or 45 in any buller deal.

 

[Jen2310]

Not trading 39 or 45 in any buller deal.

56 would be reasonable.

 

[satty]

Buckley joining Geelong as an assistant coach.

Can see him using it as a way of blowing out the cobwebs before he takes the tassie job.

 

[jimmy35]

Enjoy the harbour bridge Charlie.