WanderingDude
Club Legend
- Joined
- Sep 9, 2025
- Posts
- 1,573
- Reaction score
- 2,133
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I had a horrendous thought. Do a Sheedy, move backs forward and forwards back. Then I realised we have no backs and our forwards would just be minced. 

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
BigFooty Tipping Notice Img
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Opening Round
The Golden Ticket - Official AFL on-seller of MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.

Their target audience is schoolboys.Even his colleague Maher fell for it live on air. Saying he hopes Fly is ok…
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Love this Jen.Buller is.. wow
Very impressive. He’s not fighting for a third tall. Hes locked to play a KPP
I think you right the club recruited him to be 1st or 2nd KPF from day 1 and with the way McStay is either injured or awaiting his next injury ( sorry but that how it seems for him) it cannot come soon enough.Buller is.. wow
Very impressive. He’s not fighting for a third tall. Hes locked to play a KPP
Just asking for a friend. Could Collingwood have won the Curnow trade ???Buller is.. wow
Very impressive. He’s not fighting for a third tall. Hes locked to play a KPP

This is clearly my fault, I was thinking yesterday with all the good reports coming out about Cocka, he will be next person to step up and get injured!Swoop saying Cochran straight into the rooms and gone to get scans.
Valid point. Jen reminded us that players we have recruited were done so on the basis they’d be first 23.I think you right the club recruited him to be 1st or 2nd KPF from day 1 and with the way McStay is either injured or awaiting his next injury ( sorry but that how it seems for him) it cannot come soon enough.
We do need Membrey to stay healthy he is almost the most important player we have upfront.
Maynard Houston Quaynor and Howe all in full match sim today. The band is reformingThis is clearly my fault, I was thinking yesterday with all the good reports coming out about Cocka, he will be next person to step up and get injured!
Frampton is good again, right? I assume they’re still holding Reef back from match sim?Houston. IQ. Maynard and Howe in full training. Match sim and all
This pleases me.Houston. IQ. Maynard and Howe in full training. Match sim and all
Anything happen with Schultz?Houston. IQ. Maynard and Howe in full training. Match sim and all
JT? TJ?Just caught training. Two quarters of match sim at the end. 1sts vs 2nds, as is often the case.
West played both quarters for the 1sts, which I found interesting. Seems like he has first dibs if / whilst McStay builds fitness.
Harrison and Hayes the other two that earned 1sts guerneys, but only for a quarter each. Beau on sidelines for 2nds, and crisp okayed the full game for the 2nds.
Will repeat that defence of the new style (lions influenced) is a key focus in all of the training sessions - which may be missed at first glance. As they obviously know that defending their type of run and carry system is just as important, if not more, than learning to implement it in offence.
Looked good in patches, but also came unstuck at times, down to some growing pains mixed with some good / intense defending.
Few player notes….
Prindable - played well again. Wing. Tough going against the first team, so any wins for the 2nds should be lauded imo. I had him going at 100% DE, so can see him featuring sooner rather than later. Caught Cameron for a HTB and delivered long to an open target. Then collected a JDG miss, and set up a goal. Also set up another goal, whilst good hands in close generated a couple of clearances that caught the eye. All v impressive. Like… a lot
Swadling - showing confidence again. Was v busy in the short practice drills and also off half back in the sim. Got caught trying to do too much at one stage, but didn’t go into his shell. Loves to get th ball and run. Keeper
Saxena - showing signs again. V similar to Bobby in stature and style. 2nd most immature body out there though, so will need time. Showed lovely disposal by foot today, kicking to teammates under pressure. Also got rag dolled a little bit, so will be given time imo. Hayes and Harrison ahead of him still, but showing great signs with his run and nous.
West - mostly played as the foil for Membrey and Buller for the 1’s. Didn’t see much action as a result. Still learning his place in the first team structure.
Buller - good. Ran well, active, up t egg ground and in the pockets. Slotted a couple, missed another. Kicking not as good as his predecessor, but v mobile and switched on.
Hayes - kicked a nice goals on the run and is linking up well. Won’t look too out of place when he gets a call up.
Nick - everywhere.
Josh - played off half back and midfield again. Showed great reading of the play down back - and aerial game well above his size. Has his brother covered here. Had a few interceptions that propelled the first team into attack.
Pendles - looked good. Busy and involved. Decision making so good.
Houston - got involved and kicked beautifully to targets. More in his familiar position, so hoping that stays and he keeps progressing.
Ryan - better. Read okay well at times, kicked well - though still short, and almost took a v nice pack mark. Hopefully gains a bit more confidence from that.
Allan - don’t impact much in the middle, but is being given th chance to prove himself. Had one nice run and carry, but would like to see more.
Elliott - played v well. In th best. Kicked at least 3 goals, including one from an interception. Busy and looking primed.
Steele - roan. In th 1’s, and getting involved. Obv provides great run and could hold down a v important position to allow more seasoned players time to run through the midfield.
JT - looks recovered from ankle and taking kick outs. Busy, but slow disposal / looping ball drop still bothers me. Still fringe at this stage.
Howe - did well, often tasked with defending Cameron on a lead. Bit bulkier this year. Tiny bit.
And as always apologies for any typos as doing this all on mobile phone in between work
You'd reckon if Dan's not fit, West, Membrey, Buller are the tall forwards.Reckon we are getting closer to working out our preferred 23 for opening round
Moore and McStay the main 2 queries.