- Joined
- Jan 24, 2026
- Posts
- 2,078
- Reaction score
- 1,962
- AFL Club
- Tasmania
Maybe he's not a keeperYou will only lose money on NAS if you trade him out, it doesn't matter what you paid for him as a season long keeper, that deal is done.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

LIVE: Collingwood v Fremantle - Rd 5 - 7:10PM Fri
Squiggle tips Freo at 62% chance -- What's your tip? -- Injury Lists » -- All Rd 5 Games
BigFooty Tipping Notice Img
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 5
The Golden Ticket - Corporate tickets, functions, Open Air Boxes at the Adelaide Oval, ENGIE, Gabba, MCG, Marvel, Optus & People First Stadiums. Corporate Suites at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Soccer Notice Image
FA Cup Semi-Finals ⚽ 2026 FIFA Series A - Socceroos friendlies ⚽ Europa - Rd of 16 ⚽ The Matildas x 2026 Womens Asia Cup ⚽ Conference League - KNOCKOUTS! ⚽ Conference League - Rd of 16 ⚽ Socceroos Internat'l Friendlies ⚽ Champs League - League Phase ⚽
Fantasy Footy Notice Image Round 5
SuperCoach Rd 5 SC Talk - Trade Talk - Capt/VC ,//, AFL Fantasy Rd 5 AFF Talk - AF Trades - Capt/VC
Maybe he's not a keeperYou will only lose money on NAS if you trade him out, it doesn't matter what you paid for him as a season long keeper, that deal is done.
Jhf last year comes to mind and Dawson a couple of years ago burnt me after I traded him outIt's not crazy, his price only matters if you trade him (or he gets injured).
He'll find form soon enough. This happens every year, a premo starts slow and everyone jumps off, only to have to get him back in a month later when he comes good.
Use your trades improving your team, sideways trading premo's isn't the answer.
Not reallyThat strategy is going to lead you to the no trades club in record time.
If a person picked NAS at the start you have to ride out the price drop. He will come good.
Trading him out and then trading him back in is the definition of madness.
That would be a crazy move IMO
Trade NAS to Sinclair before Nas goes down in value around $100k if another bad week and Sinclair jumps up in price
You can always trade NAS back in when he bottoms out but it could be a $200k difference between the 2
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Not being a smartarse here, but have you played SC before? Genuine question.Not really
We have 40 trades and need to use 30 to improve our side as quickly as possible
We trade in a rookie thats on the bubble to make cash so we can upgrade and thats basically the strategy of the game
Make money fast , Improve the team as soon as possible.
Nas has a BE of 201 and price $622,300
Sinclair BE of 77 and averages 133 and along with Trac is the highest rated thats played 2 games at a price of $606,600
So logically Sinclair is a must have premium. So Prem to Prem and pocket $200k
Hoarding trades is also madness
Exactly, happens every year. Most will cop at least one underperforming premo.Jhf last year comes to mind and Dawson a couple of years ago burnt me after I traded him out
Ok i take your numbers as you seem to know the formulaLol.
Nas is averaging 75 which is terrible by his standards.
If he has another stinker and scores that again before starting to turn it around gradually he'll lose 60k max.
As for sinclair- if he maintains his hot form (massive "if"- he's av is 133) he'll make circa 40k tops.
So thats 100k turnaround, circa half your 200k by my calcs.
Yeah i have not that great at it but lets see how we goNot being a smartarse here, but have you played SC before? Genuine question.
If NAS scores B 2 B 100's he'll lose $60k, it's not the end of the world. Sinclair is scoring at 133, that is unsustainable and he'll revert.Not really
We have 40 trades and need to use 30 to improve our side as quickly as possible
We trade in a rookie thats on the bubble to make cash so we can upgrade and thats basically the strategy of the game
Make money fast , Improve the team as soon as possible.
Nas has a BE of 201 and price $622,300
Sinclair BE of 77 and averages 133 and along with Trac is the highest rated thats played 2 games at a price of $606,600
So logically Sinclair is a must have premium. So Prem to Prem and pocket $100k
Hoarding trades is also madness
BOMBERBLITZ may have something to say about hoarding tradesNot really
We have 40 trades and need to use 30 to improve our side as quickly as possible
We trade in a rookie thats on the bubble to make cash so we can upgrade and thats basically the strategy of the game
Make money fast , Improve the team as soon as possible.
Nas has a BE of 201 and price $622,300
Sinclair BE of 77 and averages 133 and along with Trac is the highest rated thats played 2 games at a price of $606,600
So logically Sinclair is a must have premium. So Prem to Prem and pocket $100k
Hoarding trades is also madness
Brayshaw for me so farExactly, happens every year. Most will cop at least one underperforming premo.
All good. But like Nelso said sideways trading premo's in round 1 is a recipe for running out of trades with an incomplete team.Yeah i have not that great at it but lets see how we go
I will get Nas when he gets to $550k and holding Sinclair
Chasing the fast starters can often be a negative move too.If NAS scores B 2 B 100's he'll lose $60k, it's not the end of the world. Sinclair is scoring at 133, that is unsustainable and he'll revert.
There's a big chance that NAS reverts to his comfort space behind the ball and reignites his scoring whilst at the same time quelling Sinclair's scoring.
The sort of strategy you're considering can work in AF but this format doesn't lend itself to it.
Ok i take your numbers as you seem to know the formula
But $100k is still great cash when you have 40 trades.
Lets also keep in mind where Lyon is traying to play him and also other teams paying him more attention
Sinclair has been doing it for years and is more a sure thing ATM
Nice team. Probably better to wait until after St Kilda's bye to get NWM. And possibly wait until his form turns.View attachment 2555064View attachment 2555065
2300 round 1 with Jagga on the pine
39 trades left and $738k in the bank , Will get Houston and Nas next week possibly
BOMBERBLITZ may have something to say about hoarding trades
They finished 7th overall last year and came home like a train as they had trades in the bank.
either or...go with your gutI'm thinking Gulden to either Jackson or Xerri - who would everyone go with there? Jackson seems more reliable but Xerri's fixture is very tempting.