Chip Scab1
Norm Smith Medallist
- Joined
- Sep 2, 2024
- Posts
- 5,016
- Reaction score
- 7,330
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Agreed Ken Farmer should be in but no idea why you've called Dunstall out?
Dunstall kicked 1254 goals himself, with most of those coming in the AFL era. He was on track to beat the all time V/AFL record ahead of Lockett before succumbing to injury following multiple knees, broken collarbone, smashed cheekbones, etc.
Aside from kicking goals, he was famed as the ultimate team player, giving off many more goals than any of his contempories (Lockett, Ablett, etc) and pioneering forwards who would pressure and chase defenders.
He was also THE best player in what many consider to be the greatest team of all time, with him playing in 4 flags and winning back to back best and fairests in flag years when they were at their zenith ('88/'89).
He also won the league MVP and finished top 3 in the Brownlow 4 times (runner up twice as a full forward!). In 1992, he won the MVP, was favourite for the Brownlow (but finished runner up by 1 vote after some very unusual voting), won the Coleman and kicked a lazy 145 goals in the National comp (which remains the record). (He also holds the record for most goals in a game in the National comp (17))
He also captained his side (unusual for full forwards), was never suspended and was a big game player - having kicked the 2nd most goals in finals ever (and the most in the last 90 years).
You mention State games and there weren't as many in Dunstall's time but he still won the EJ Whitten and the Simpson medals for BOG performances in State matches.
Most published lists has Dunstall in the top 10 players of all time.
Off the field, Dunstall (who was captain at the time) was instrumental in saving Hawthorn from merging with Melbourne. He also voluntarily stepped onto the Hawthorn board at one of their lowest ebbs in 2004, cleared out the fighting factions, got the club back on track and then overruled the Board to appoint Alistair Clarkson (instead of Gary Ayers) as coach, who delivered another 4 flags.
I see no reason he shouldn't be a legend (and suspect Farmer will also be in time).
Wayne Carey also modelled his game on Dunstall, calls him the GOAT.
Enough for me; when the GOAT calls you his GOAT, you win.







