Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. WCErevival

    The Farce that is the free kick differential number

    Richmond were done htb about 5 times in the 3rd quarter. That's half of your differential right there.
  2. WCErevival

    Nic Nats Report: Tribunal - Still pathetic/soft/inconsistent

    He's not lifted off the ground. He falls over and is in between steps so there is a split second there is nothing touching the ground.
  3. WCErevival

    Umpire Hits Back - article: Why experts are wrong to bash umpires

    Anyone whinging about the Saints game, what free kicks didn't you agree with?
  4. WCErevival

    Blaming Umpires For A Loss

    The crowd isn't going to influence the umpire into calling a free when nothing has happened. If there is a 50/50 call then they may help but then you can't really argue as it was a 50/50 call to start with.
  5. WCErevival

    15m or not 15m?

    I think it comes down to where the kick is. Often if its in the defensive 50 they call play on to get the game moving. Even the commentators were joking in our game about a couple of decisions where it was clearly at least 20 metres but called to play on.
  6. WCErevival

    Sandilands can accept 1 match ban -- NAB Challenge

    If you attempt a bump and hit the head its a ban. Surely everyone knows this by now. It was clumsy by Sandilands he should have just gone the ball he most likely would have got the hit out even with the 3rd man up.
  7. WCErevival

    Suckling and Franklin play on when they kick long set shots

    I dont care if a player moves a metre or two when kicking for goal. It would make very little difference. As long as its kicked from behind the mark then who cares.
  8. WCErevival

    Stevic - Seriously ?

    I dont understand why people are pissed off about the Ballantyne one in the first quarter. If Ballantyne didn't act like such a ******* all the time and niggle every 2 seconds they wouldnt have their eyes on him ready to call a free. Suban is the same. Just play the game
  9. WCErevival

    Fyfe

    That's what I thought. The ball wasn't in the North players reach so you cant really say Fyfe was going the ball. He tried to knock him away from it.
  10. WCErevival

    Chris Masten biting allegation

    He was hungry for some potato
  11. WCErevival

    What's worse than 'diving' to get a free kick?

    I'm more surprised Priddis just accepted it and said nothing.
  12. WCErevival

    Johnson - enough is enough

    I dont like the guy but not much in that. Definitely not as bad as people are making out.
  13. WCErevival

    Lewis hit on Goldstein

    Didnt think there was much in this one. Just a poor late attempt at a spoil
  14. WCErevival

    Yarran gone for weeks

    It didnt look that bad even though the amount of blood. Chapman looked like he dropped just so it got noticed
  15. WCErevival

    Two weeks for this?

    TBH I thought it just looked a lot worse live than it was. When I watched the footage again he was watching the ball going for the spoil and never hit Wingards head. If Wingard never went to hospital for a check up it wouldn't even be a big deal.
  16. WCErevival

    Two weeks for this?

    He actually had his eyes on the ball for most of its flight until the last second then it was too late.
  17. WCErevival

    St Kilda Fans booing Umpires!!!!!

    Amazing people seem to forget and just concentrate on the last few minutes. Darling's clear mark that was taken off him which cost us a certain goal. Jumping on Mackenzies back in the defensive 50 that got called holding the ball and gave a shot on goal to Saints. Darling was fairly obviously...
  18. WCErevival

    Collapsing, charging with your head - the AFL are to blame for this crisis

    The one I'm hating at the moment is the free for in the back on the bottom of a pack. Sometimes there is barely any contact at all for a free to be given. If they're trying to contest the ball just let them go at it. Its not like its dangerous or anything.
  19. WCErevival

    Worst umpiring decisions

    The phantom goal in the 2009 GF
  20. WCErevival

    The whole ball must be over the whole line.

    18 second mark. Even one of the commentators says miles over.
  21. WCErevival

    The whole ball must be over the whole line.

    I thought it was the other angle (the one directly in line with the goal line with the post in front of the ball) that confirmed it was over. You could see the majority of the ball on the other side and clearly figure out where the line and ball would of been. For the ball to have not of crossed...
  22. WCErevival

    Jack Darling - Playing for frees

    Why is there a 23 page thread on a guy that has thrown his head back twice? Once when he belted himself in the face and the other from high contact.
  23. WCErevival

    Glass - How many weeks?

    1 week my guess. Will definitely get something..
  24. WCErevival

    WCE v Carlton umpiring - a small bit of perspective

    WCE got 3 goals from frees. Carlton got 2 goals from frees. Hardly worth talking about really. Not sure why Carlton supporters are so pissed off.
  25. WCErevival

    The Chris Judd 50 metre penalty was 100% correct

    No softer than when someone gets a 50 metre penalty for language.
  26. WCErevival

    Ducking the head for free kicks is a soft act, and not in the spirit of the game!

    Why wont people realise that players aren't ducking their head, they are lowering their body so they are making it harder for them to tackle. For example you see Shuey sometimes running on a 45 degree angle to protect his body. Its a smart tactic not cheating. They can still be tackled without...
  27. WCErevival

    Tonights Umpires

    No luck at all hey. Just conveniently forget all the frees you got in the first quarter, Hurn being called to play on only after a couple of seconds in the last quarter which resulted in a goal, lucky bounces near goals etc.
  28. WCErevival

    Tonights Umpires

    All the Carlton supporters saying the umps won it for us need to give it a rest. The Blues got a load of freebies at the start and there were no free kicks in the latter part of the game to either team. It was there to win in the end and you didnt do it. They were over officiating in the...
  29. WCErevival

    Daisy in trouble ?

    My moneys on 1 week.
  30. WCErevival

    We've just witnessed the worst umpring decision in history

    There was definitely some sort of hold there and as soon as the whistle went off I knew it was for that but still I thought it was quite minor and considering where it was and the point of the game, probably should of been left alone.
Back
Top