2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

[gh172]

Dal Santo, elite disposal and gets 30 touches a game, hardly misses a game and averages 110+ every year

Koby Stevens or james mcdonald, last mid spot

James McDonald.

I can't decide between Golby and Lake, Scotland and Shaw.

 

[Daniels]

I can't decide between Golby and Lake, Scotland and Shaw.

Lake and Shaw.

Cox vs Mumford

Gut feel says Cox will still crush from get go. Little voice says Nic Nac could create an issue with rotations.

Mumford will dominate you would think, but still could be a slight semi yo-yo.

I feel which ever way I go I will be kicking myself. THIS IS DOING MY HEAD IN!

 

[Clutch]

i would go Mummy he is set for 120 ave ave i tihnk and i tihnk cox will play more forward this year which could drop his average a touch.

my last decision
Porplyzia and (Hargrave, Lake or dempsey) v Malceski and kennedy (GWS)

 

[tenderwarrior]

James McDonald.

I can't decide between Golby and Lake, Scotland and Shaw.

I have gone Shaw and Lake. For some reason I feel that Scotland is over priced. Lake is a proven player, and while he may disappoint, at least you know what he might give you. Golby, though impressive thus far, is quite a risk.

I have a good one!

S Fisher and any rookie midfielder OR forward under $125,000 (So far in my team: Dickson, Saad, McDonald, Shiel & Magner)

OR

C Rioli and a rookie defender under $125,000 (So far in my team: Mohr & Bugg)

 

[len_jet]

[SIZE=-1]Which combo...

Pendelbury / Mumford / Porplyzia

OR

S. Mitchell / McIntosh / Fyfe


[/SIZE]

 

[Daniels]

i would go Mummy he is set for 120 ave ave i tihnk and i tihnk cox will play more forward this year which could drop his average a touch.

my last decision
Porplyzia and (Hargrave, Lake or dempsey) v Malceski and kennedy (GWS)

That's what I'm worried about. Wonder how much of a pinch hitter Nic Nat will be...? Head doing!

Porpz and Lake a tie with Malceski and Kennedy. Flip a coin!

 

[V23]

[SIZE=-1]Which combo...

Pendelbury / Mumford / Porplyzia

OR

S. Mitchell / McIntosh / Fyfe


[/SIZE]

Option 1, Pendlebury may be a bit expensive though

---

Pfeiffer + Pavlich vs Ledger + Goodes?

 

[pies21]

hey lads having a bit of a tough one,

buddy+martin vs goodes+rioli???

 

[IDIG]

hey lads having a bit of a tough one,

buddy+martin vs goodes+rioli???

Must be Buddy and Martin by a fair bit I would've thought?

 

[bludrew79]

Suckling or broughton d3

 

[DEAN0]

Broughton, good numbers this preseason, looks the goods in the midfield rotations.

Dangerfield or Zaharakis?

 

[Watsclarkosmob]

hey lads having a bit of a tough one,

buddy+martin vs goodes+rioli???

Buddy and Martin, Rioli is incredibly frustrating with his inconsistency...though Goodes is looking great this year.



Selwood vs Thompson ???

 

[Turly]

Buddy and Martin, Rioli is incredibly frustrating with his inconsistency...though Goodes is looking great this year.



Selwood vs Thompson ???

I'd Go Selwood mate.

This is an incredibly difficult one and I don't expect many to have any idea... But even if someone with a bit of inside info could give us a bit of a hand

I need to pick 2 of these

Neale VS Ledger VS Pfeiffer

The one that misses out I will replace with Josh Caddy as I have some spare cash.

 

[beev]

I'd Go Selwood mate.

This is an incredibly difficult one and I don't expect many to have any idea... But even if someone with a bit of inside info could give us a bit of a hand

I need to pick 2 of these

Neale VS Ledger VS Pfeiffer

The one that misses out I will replace with Josh Caddy as I have some spare cash.

Tough. I doubt Neale will play round 1 but I doubt he'll come in mid-season so I take him and Ledger.

I've been struggling with this for a few weeks.

I currently have Swan, J.Selwood and Watson. All have the bye in round 12 so I need to drop one.

I haven't been impressed with Swan's NAB form but he doesn't care about it and I know he will pump out the big scores when the H&A season starts.

I think Selwood will take his game to another level being skipper.

I've seen Jobe Watson in both his NAB games and he's dominated. He's in for a similar start as last year when he was averaging 120+.

Who should I drop?

And who should I pick up?

Thanks.

 

[Turly]

Tough. I doubt Neale will play round 1 but I doubt he'll come in mid-season so I take him and Ledger.

I've been struggling with this for a few weeks.

I currently have Swan, J.Selwood and Watson. All have the bye in round 12 so I need to drop one.

I haven't been impressed with Swan's NAB form but he doesn't care about it and I know he will pump out the big scores when the H&A season starts.

I think Selwood will take his game to another level being skipper.

I've seen Jobe Watson in both his NAB games and he's dominated. He's in for a similar start as last year when he was averaging 120+.

Who should I drop?

And who should I pick up?

Thanks.

Sorry mate I think it was a typo... which 2 were you saying lol?

 

[Watsclarkosmob]

I'd Go Selwood mate.

This is an incredibly difficult one and I don't expect many to have any idea... But even if someone with a bit of inside info could give us a bit of a hand

I need to pick 2 of these

Neale VS Ledger VS Pfeiffer

The one that misses out I will replace with Josh Caddy as I have some spare cash.

Cheers mate midfield does look better with Selwood in there....

How about you move Pfeiffer to the forward line and then you can have all three.

 

[beev]

Sorry mate I think it was a typo... which 2 were you saying lol?

Yep, badly worded. What I meant was that I think Neale will come in early in the season. I don't think he'll debut round 11,12 etc which is when you'd be looking for downgrade targets. So if you want Neale take him now. Hope you can understand that.

Any thoughts on my issue?

 

[RWnBluey]

Miles v McDonald?

Ive currently go Mcdonald and I know that Miles hasn't been named this week but I'm starting to think when Power and Scully come back McDonald will struggle to get game time/red vest candidate.

 

[Turly]

Yep, badly worded. What I meant was that I think Neale will come in early in the season. I don't think he'll debut round 11,12 etc which is when you'd be looking for downgrade targets. So if you want Neale take him now. Hope you can understand that.

Any thoughts on my issue?

I'd drop Swan and pick up Boys or Murphy

 

[Johanpetro]

H.Scotland and N. Riewoldt

VS

Broughton and someone like Petrie/Hurley or even N.Riewoldt with 90k left still....

So essentially Scotland Vs Broughton haha

 

[oneredfrog]

Waters or Malceski?

Having last minute doubts on Malceski.

 

[RWnBluey]

Waters or Malceski?

Having last minute doubts on Malceski.

I went with Malceski, a risk? yes, but if you want to do well you need to make some risky calls

 

[Unknown Caller]

Pfeiffer or Wingard?

Pfeiffer has dual position eligibility and is cheaper, but I suspect Wingard has better job security.

 

[oneredfrog]

Thanks Woofy. Just after I posted I thought I'd stick with malceski. Last minute changes can only lead to disappointment.

Unknown - Went with Pfeiffer over Wingard because of price, used the extra dosh elsewhere and keep hearing that Wingard wont play for a while yet whereas pfeifer looks like getting a game straight up.

 

[Antz]

Pfeiffer or Wingard?

Pfeiffer has dual position eligibility and is cheaper, but I suspect Wingard has better job security.

If you have the money I would go Wingard due to job security.

Shiel or Mcdonald guys. I am really struggling with this one.

Cheers