2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

[Lotch]

Basically my problem is with my mid and forward MPP rookies.

At the moment I have:

M: Wingard, Smith (Shiel & Magner)
F: Pfeiffer (Kennedy)

Should I drop Kennedy, move Smith to the forward line and bring in Colingo/Mcdonald.

Or drop Wingard and move Pfeiffer into the midfield for Smith and pick up one of the rookies mentioned.

 

[prenticem]

Swan and Selwood vs. Pendlebury and Hodge.

Someone help!!!.

Leaning towards option 2. Pendles won't come down much in price I'm predicting (unless injured)...so he'll be hard to get all season if I don't jump on. Hodge isn't going to be as consistent as Swan or Selwood but is a bit of unique choice I reckon...and underpriced.

 

[prenticem]

Basically my problem is with my mid and forward MPP rookies.

At the moment I have:

M: Wingard, Smith (Shiel & Magner)
F: Pfeiffer (Kennedy)

Should I drop Kennedy, move Smith to the forward line and bring in Colingo/Mcdonald.

Or drop Wingard and move Pfeiffer into the midfield for Smith and pick up one of the rookies mentioned.

Not sure if the rules here are you need to comment on someone elses post. I will anyhow.

Option a) all the way. Colingo rather than McDonald if you can afford it. Smith will be a gun.

 

[Ducky Tie]

Mumford and A Hall or McEvoy and Saad.
Option A looks the best but I don't know much about Hall so what are your thoughts about this?

 

[IDIG]

A definitely.

 

[Lotch]

Not sure if the rules here are you need to comment on someone elses post. I will anyhow.

Option a) all the way. Colingo rather than McDonald if you can afford it. Smith will be a gun.

My apologies if that is a rule in this thread.

Thanks for your feedback!

Mumford and A Hall or McEvoy and Saad.
Option A looks the best but I don't know much about Hall so what are your thoughts about this?

Mumford gets suspended more often and I think the way he plays also makes him a bigger risk of injury. That being said he has massive scoring potential.

But Hall has only had one (IIRC - maybe two) notable pre-season games. Saads job security seems better. At this stage I have both rookies in my squad.

If Hall is named go with (the riskier) option A.

 

[Marucho]

Petrie v Josh Kennedy?

 

[Bristol]

Zaharakis vs. Sidebottom

 

[Bristol]

Spurr vs. Morris

 

[Blueforce]

marucho:
petrie - kennedy hasnt played all PS...some injury concerns

sparx:
sidebottom - expect to play in more winning teams so likely greater points, also has had a good PS
morris - but only since spurr is still rookie listed... if spurr gets elevated lean to spurr


ok - need some help here
danger vs jroo??
+
m.clarke & danger/jroo vs boumann/morris & robinson/gray/lewis??

cheers

 

[RBW_007]

Morris and Sidebottom.

Zaharakis vs. Sidebottom

Spurr vs. Morris

Porps + Coniglio vs Parker + Cripps

 

[PP34]

Murphy vs Judd as my third premium midfielder.

I love Juddy and have had him in my team for the past four years. I've never had Murphy but I think this might be the year to change that. I feel as though he'll improve on last years scores. Thoughts?

 

[Jabbot]

Murphy vs Judd as my third premium midfielder.

I love Juddy and have had him in my team for the past four years. I've never had Murphy but I think this might be the year to change that. I feel as though he'll improve on last years scores. Thoughts?

I've had Murphy the last 3 years, and am doing the same this year. Will be in top 6 mids by year's end I'd say..

Swallow vs Dal Santo vs Priddis
and
Sidebottom vs Gray vs Dangerfield

 

[PP34]

Gaff vs Caddy.

Any news on whether Caddy will play this year?

 

[RevDog]

Ablett vs. Pendlebury

 

[PP34]

Ablett vs. Pendlebury

I picked Ablett but only because of the price. Pendlebury will be one of my upgrade targets. Both are huge scorers and you can rely on them each week. I just think you're better off waiting a few rounds for Pendles to drop in price.

 

[controlKLICK]

Leuneberger and Pfeiffer.

Or

Hodge and Stephenson.

I've convinced myself Hodge will outscore Leuneberger and Redden will outscore Pfeiffer/Saad. Fair call?

 

[footyfan08]

I've convinced myself Hodge will outscore Leuneberger and Redden will outscore Pfeiffer/Saad. Fair call?

Good call for sure.

Any ideas on J.Riewoldt v dangerfield v any other player in that range?

 

[IDIG]

Would have to be Danger on potential of change of role, new coach and a good preseason. JRoo could work out to be a decent POD though if you were willing to back him against all the Danger owners

 

[Ed_Gein]

everyone seems to be going with mumford who is prone to injury and suspension.

just wondering if i should take a punt on hale as my number 1 ruck instead.

hale + broughton
vs
mumford + golby

 

[galindez]

Goddard + Selwood

or

Birchall + Pendlebury

last decision on my starting team!

 

[galindez]

everyone seems to be going with mumford who is prone to injury and suspension.

just wondering if i should take a punt on hale as my number 1 ruck instead.

hale + broughton
vs
mumford + golby

while I share your concerns about Mumford, I can't see Hale being a high enough scorer to be considered number 1 ruck all year.

 

[Yoda_]

Caddy OR Parker?

Thinking Parker, full pre season, bigger body in a better team but is that little bit more expensive..

 

[crowsarethebest]

Swan/Selwood/Thompson/Priddis/Judd/Dal Santo/Mitchell/Swallow etc. Already got Ablett/Pendles/Murphy, one more premium. I guess I can't really go wrong with any of them but I was leaning towards Selwood or Thompson.

 

[Foxx]

Swan/Selwood/Thompson/Priddis/Judd/Dal Santo/Mitchell/Swallow etc. Already got Ablett/Pendles/Murphy, one more premium. I guess I can't really go wrong with any of them but I was leaning towards Selwood or Thompson.

Dal Santo, elite disposal and gets 30 touches a game, hardly misses a game and averages 110+ every year

Koby Stevens or james mcdonald, last mid spot