Analysis 2015 Draft - Your Top 25

[Defacto]

The draft is only 2-3 days away... out of interest what is everyones ranking of the top 25... not where you think they will go, but what your preferences are...

here is mine:

1. Schache
2. Weitering
3. Mills
4. Hopper
5. McKay H
6. Kennedy
7. Oliver
8. Milera
9. Parish
10. Hipwood
11. Curnow
12. Francis
13. Burton
14. Keays
15. Gresham
16. Ah Chee
17. Weideman
18. Schoenfield
19. Fiorini
20. Hibberd
21. Balic
22. Matheison
23. McKay B
24. Tucker
25. Dunkley

 

[Kildonan]

Can you not enter the draft competition thread stickied above?

 

[Defacto]

Can you not enter the draft competition thread stickied above?

i thought it was a bit different, given isnt that what people think will happen

i was more interested to see what peoples ranking is for this draft, taking out the noise of what they think will happen

that way we can get a bit of a feel for sliders and bolters on draft night

feel free to merge it though if you like...

 

[Kildonan]

Fair enough

I hope posters do both...

 

[Armoooo]

1. Mills

2. Weitering

3. Hopper

4. Schache

5. Francis

6. Parish

7. Curnow

8. Burton

9. Collins

10. Kennedy

11. Oliver

12. Ha McKay

13. Ah Chee

14. Milera

15. Hipwood

16. Mathison

17. Keays

18. Hipwood

19. Partington

20. Weideman

21. Tucker

22. B McKay

23. Gresham

24. Hibberd

25. Clarke

 

[Kildonan]

This is how I think the first round selections will fall...

National Draft First Round

1 Weitering - Carlton
2 Schache - Brisbane
3 Hopper (Acad) - GWS
4 Mills (Acad) - Sydney
5 Parish - Melbourne
6 Kennedy (Acad) - GWS
7 Francis - Essendon
8 Keays (Acad) - Brisbane
9 Hipwood (Acad) - Brisbane
10 Weideman - Essendon
11 Milera - Gold Coast
12 Curnow - Melbourne
13 Oliver - Carlton
14 Burton - Adelaide
15 Mathieson - Carlton
16 Balic - Richmond
17 Collins - Adelaide
18 Gresham - St Kilda
19 Hibberd - Hawthorn
20 Ah Chee - GC
21 Lovell - North Melbourne
22 Clarke - Hawthorn
23 H McKay - Carlton

But how do I rank them? I preface this by explaining that I have no real basis for my preferences other than other people's opinions, and my own assessments of the championship matches and the widely available highlights packages - so essentially armchair expert

1 Hopper
2 Weitering
3 Mills
4 Schache
5 Kennedy
6 Francis
7 Hipwood
8 Parish
9 Keays
10 Milera
11 Oliver
12 Weideman
13 Curnow
14 Mathieson
15 Burton
16 Hibberd
17 Balic
18 Gresham
19 Collins
20 Clarke
21 Partington
22 H McKay
23 Lovell
24 Bonner
25 Ah Chee

 

[Curunir]

1 Weitering
2 Francis
3 Hopper
4 Mills
5 Parish
6 Hipwood
7 Mathieson
8 Kennedy
9 Keays
10 Schache
11 Oliver
12 Gresham
13 Clarke
14 Bonner
15 Burton
16 Balic
17 Hibberd
18 H.Mckay
19 Collins
20 Ah Chee
21 Partington
22 Tucker
23 B.Mckay
24 Curnow
25 Hunter

 

[borderbarry]

1. Weitering.
2. Hopper
3, Mills
4. Francis
5. Schache
6. Oliver
7. Parish
8. Kennedy
9. Hipwood
10. Keays
11. Burton.
12. H.McKay
13. Milera
14. Weiderman
15. Mathieson
16. Balic
17. Gresham
18. Hibberd
19. Partington
20. Bonner
21. Ah Chee
22. Collins
23. Tucker.
24. B.McKay
25. Curnow. (should drop at least this far)