Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2015 Trade, Draft, Rookie Draft and FA Megathread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
We aren't going to get him in the PSD especially if the Hawks are now showing interest. We will deal. There is a week left. I will be worried in 6 days and 23 hours.

This is wrong.
The Hawks would have no chance at getting him in the pre-season draft with the contract he would be asking for.
 
"From 2016 onwards I will be at the St Kilda footy club.

I'm obviously very excited about the decision and it's been a lengthy process since we finished the season. I couldn't be happier.

Richo was there in my first year at Essendon, Rohan Welsh, who is the defensive coach at St Kilda was my Vic Metro coach in 2009.

But also just how young they are the exciting football they've played this year.

I've just turned 24 so hopefully I can finish my career there and show the young kids how to develop as well"

If he went back on those words, I can't see why any club would want him.
Bloody good point. The bolded opening is about as strongly-worded as is possible.

Be a politician-esque backflip if he did.
 
I'd rather this doesn't change our approach to Carlisle; if we lose him, then look to split 5 into two first rounders with the intention of snaring Mathieson and a KPD like Collins (or maybe bid on Hipwood)
Agree with this if Carlisle goes to Hawks.
Happier with that outcome than to give a drug infested cult club pick 5.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Bloody good point. The bolded opening is about as strongly-worded as is possible.

Be a politician-esque backflip if he did.

He did reportedly run off field yelling profanities about the club he still played for.

I'd expect anything to be honest.
 
Might be in strife... I'm abit shocked to be honest. Lots to play out but wow
It's enough to turn someone to smoking, drinking and gambling :cry: #atleastwecanstillbelikejake
 
Bloody good point. The bolded opening is about as strongly-worded as is possible.

Be a politician-esque backflip if he did.

Maybe this is confirmation that Hawthorn are moving to the Junction Oval?! :eek::p
 
This is wrong.
The Hawks would have no chance at getting him in the pre-season draft with the contract he would be asking for.


I agree but them being interested means the Bombers wont let it get to the PSD. The only way it could possibly happen is if Carlisle completely rejects them and I doubt that will happen but even if it does the Saints and Bombers will trade.
 
Rumoured trade is;

Essendon lose Carlisle and gain Hawthorns first and Norths first.
Hawthorn lose Anderson and their first for Carlisle.
North give up their first for Anderson.

I must be missing something with Jed Anderson. He's a good VFL footballer with potential but are you serious North would give up their first pick. They are idiots.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

"From 2016 onwards I will be at the St Kilda footy club.

I'm obviously very excited about the decision and it's been a lengthy process since we finished the season. I couldn't be happier.

Richo was there in my first year at Essendon, Rohan Welsh, who is the defensive coach at St Kilda was my Vic Metro coach in 2009.

But also just how young they are the exciting football they've played this year.

I've just turned 24 so hopefully I can finish my career there and show the young kids how to develop as well"

If he went back on those words, I can't see why any club would want him.

This x 10000, a young man with some questions over his character, doubles back after a statement like this, don't want or need him showing our kids how to develop.

If he goes to the Hawks, we get lucky not having him.
 
I'd still rather pick 5 than Carlisle!

In the end, Jake is the only person that matters. Hawthorn could offer Dildoro free wristies for the rest of his life but unless Jake agrees, it doesn't matter.

Surely we can give him an extra $100k year 1 if push came to shove
 
If he changes his mind because the Hawks came a callin', well IMO he wasn't right for us in the first place.

Conversely, if the rumour is true and he stares Clarkson down, then that will be a massive endorsement of his character and of his desire to join our mighty club.

Therefore IMO we can't lose :cool:
I agree with this, we could end up the huge winners out of this if Carlisle sticks fat
 
Let's not jump all over jake's character until AFTER he accepts an offer from the Hawks, because as it stand right now he is still coming to us.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom