Position 2017 Rookies

[rocker_oz33]

I like the SC threads for that reason above. Champagners will call their own players not suited for SC or just call their own players .

Own team = team they support.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hayward Woodward and hello Newman looks decent.

 

[SC fish]

McCarthy better score this week otherwise I'm swapping for WHE

Yep he needs to fire this week or he's out. Was hoping for a slow burn.

 

[Kadog]

Hayward Woodward and hello Newman looks decent.

Tippett injured should finally make way for Cameron. Sydney producing the goods as always.

 

[go you pups]

Hayward Woodward and hello Newman looks decent.

Hayward was arguably in Sydneys best 6-7 tonight

Thought only Reid, Buddy, Lloyd and Smith were better.

Very impressed with him watching him live at the ground.

 

[big_bazza]

Lets hope Cameron is fit this week as he should get a game, the only issue may be if dopy dick Sinclair is in better knick fitness wise than Cameron Horse might play him and give Cameron a week in the neafl but lets hope not. Sinclair is shit up forward where as from what ive seen of Cameron hes a decent mark and kick at goal and moves well for a big fella, which is perfectly suited to playing 70% forward 30% ruck ala Tippet.

 

[kreglze]

Newman looked good as a potential pick up for the backline, looked good, 73 is great for a rookie pick up.

 

[big_bazza]

Newman looked good as a potential pick up for the backline, looked good, 73 is great for a rookie pick up.

He did mate, id like to think if he goes well enough in Rampes absence that he might keep his spot and we might drop Laidler.

 

[Super Hans]

Newman and Hayward looked good at the game, might pass on Hannan for them.

 

[The Lemon]

Newman and Hayward looked good at the game, might pass on Hannan for them.

Yep going early on Hannan looks like it might be a mistake now.

Oh well.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Newman and Hayward looked good at the game, might pass on Hannan for them.

But Hannan scored more than Newman & Hayward in his first game .....short memory, and playing Carlton today

 

[Super Hans]

But Hannan scored more than Newman & Hayward in his first game .....short memory, and playing Carlton today

Hannan also played the saints, Hayward and Newman played the dogs..

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Yep going early on Hannan looks like it might be a mistake now.

Oh well.

Why .....don't see it as a mistake at all

Can't make holistic judgements on the back of one game ? ......like i have with Hannan

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Hannan also played the saints, Hayward and Newman played the dogs..

And Hannan is playing Carlton this week? .....sure to have a good rise in price .....was an easy replacement for the dropped Eddy

Still time to access Hayward and Newman on the back of another game

 

[Didstar]

And Hannan is playing Carlton this week? .....sure to have a good rise in price .....was an easy replacement for the dropped Eddy

Still time to access Hayward and Newman on the back of another game

This. Plenty of other dud rookies that need to be corrected anyway, so the sydney boys provide that opportunity. Hannan looks to have good JS, and should hit 200k+ very quickly, even more if he has a good one against carlton.

 

[vast]

The sydney boys could easily lose their spots when heeney and mcveigh are back but hopefully they return before their price rise so we have a better idea on their job security.

Looking like good options to replace someone like pickett if he is still scoring poorly in weeks though

 

[rocker_oz33]

At least theres a few rookie choices not many but some choices.

 

[Flandersss]

Newman/Hayward interest me.

 

[Daniel McL]

Parfitt today to get 20 touches & kick 3 goals.

 

[Flandersss]

Parfitt today to get 20 touches & kick 3 goals.

Dat goal Nakia kicked last week

 

[Daniel McL]

Dat goal Nakia kicked last week

Beautiful stuff from Nokia!
Wish he was as durable as a Nokia though

 

[CROWS84]

What are people thinking of holding onto Eddy and Hibberd? Already need to make corrective trades elewhere and am thinking these guys may return at some stage, especially Eddy.

 

[DaveyBoy123]

What are people thinking of holding onto Eddy and Hibberd? Already need to make corrective trades elewhere and am thinking these guys may return at some stage, especially Eddy.

Nice prediction. Came true quicker than even you could have thought!

As a kangas fan, I don't see Hibberd coming back any time soon. I do think he will play again this season, but it won't be pre-bye imo.

 

[DaveyBoy123]

So gents, which rookie are we liking moving forward out of: Butler, Hannan or Houston?

 

[The Lemon]

So gents, which rookie are we liking moving forward out of: Butler, Hannan or Houston?

Houston and Butler. Hannan is a potato