2017 trade hypothetical thread

[Suma Magic]

Guessing in between Treloar and Mitchell.

A top 10 pick?

I wouldn't give up a top 10 pick for him.

 

[Topkent]

A top 10 pick?

I wouldn't give up a top 10 pick for him.

You guys don't need a player like him. We do though

 

[Suma Magic]

You guys don't need a player like him. We do though

We may need a big clearance mid the most, but we still need any/all decent young midfielders.

 

[adammania9]

Aaron Hall is a squib

 

[Dez!]

I know this won't please Bigfooty recruiters but Adelaide would probably knock this back unless they have some midfielder lined up and need picks to bring him in. Neal-Bullen is a good foot soldier and I wanted to draft him but doesn't really fit in with the Crows list profile, he's not good enough to be a point of difference in the first 22.

I can see them going for a first rounder and some like Tyson who is old enough to be best 22 and add to their midfielder but young enough that he still has some youf left in him.

Plus the benefit would be that they can then use Melbourne's pick to get another established mid if they so please.

Disagree.

ANB worked his way into a very strong midfield and has been improving at a very good rate this year.

Also top 3 in pressure for forwards when he's down there, I'd think he could very well make a significant impact at Adelaide.

 

[Suma Magic]

Not sure Aaron Hall would fit the bill for young midfielders though. Old mate would be 27 when he lines up next year and I'd say anything from pick 10-20 would be fair for him.

I think if you offer pick 10 there would need to be some mayo as well but I digress.

Didn't realise he was that old.

If we traded pick 10 for him then we are crazy.

 

[schmuttt]

You guys don't need a player like him. We do though

As much as I'd like Hall he isn't worth a top 10 pick.

 

[Mitchell54]

Hall is worth an early 2nd imo

 

[Topkent]

As much as I'd like Hall he isn't worth a top 10 pick.

Our first with one of GCs picks coming back would be around it I'd think

 

[JG22]

Late teens would be best the GC would get for Hall imo.

Could be worth a gamble.

You look at the Mitchell trade last year but also consider that was a complete reaming.

 

[Scotty_222]

Aaron Hall trade value?

Contracted until 2018.

You can have him..

 

[M Malice]

I'd imagine there will be a culling of the Gold Coast playing list when the new AFL approved coaching regime comes in and any OOC players will come under the greatest scrutiny.

OOC 2017- Grant, Harbrow, Lonergan, Hallahan, McKenzie, Leslie, Shaw, Matera, Willis, Rischitelli, Schoenfeld.

Can't see much there worth taking.

 

[Topkent]

Matera and Mckenzie would be worth a punt IMI

 

[Scotty_222]

We have to clean out the rot..

 

[adammania9]

I'd imagine there will be a culling of the Gold Coast playing list when the new AFL approved coaching regime comes in and any OOC players will come under the greatest scrutiny.

OOC 2017- Grant, Harbrow, Lonergan, Hallahan, McKenzie, Leslie, Shaw, Matera, Willis, Rischitelli, Schoenfeld.

Can't see much there worth taking.

Harbrow and Rischitelli stay for experience
Leslie is a good young full-back. Worth keeping/
Matera is a good small forward, if he wants to stay, keep him.
Schoenfeld hasn't shown lots but is worth giving a one-year deal to.

Others should be released I think.

 

[anotherletdown]

I'd imagine there will be a culling of the Gold Coast playing list when the new AFL approved coaching regime comes in and any OOC players will come under the greatest scrutiny.

OOC 2017- Grant, Harbrow, Lonergan, Hallahan, McKenzie, Leslie, Shaw, Matera, Willis, Rischitelli, Schoenfeld.

Can't see much there worth taking.

We have to clean out the rot..

Is that the list above, or it much deeper? I'm not really up to date with the comings and goings of your club but it feels that there shouldn't be a rot. I think last years draft was good and the spine looks great. The draft picks leave you in a pretty strong position this year. What's gotta give... obviously your coach has but is it mostly off field or on field?

 

[M Malice]

We have to clean out the rot..

Do you know who is in that category S222?

 

[Topkent]

We have to clean out the rot..

Suns still have a pretty good list IMO. Gotta rebuild the midfield with young leaders but May Wright Lynch Day Leslie Witts is a very good core of talls

 

[Scotty_222]

Is that the list above, or it much deeper? I'm not really up to date with the comings and goings of your club but it feels that there shouldn't be a rot. I think last years draft was good and the spine looks great. The draft picks leave you in a pretty strong position this year. What's gotta give... obviously your coach has but is it mostly off field or on field?

Grant
Nicholls
Lemmens
Shaw
Brookesby

They need to go

Sexton
Mackenzie
Hallahan
Thompson
Lonergan

Would be treading a fine line.

 

[blueiris]

To think most people had the Suns miles ahead of the Lions last season the Suns looks like it needs another rebuild again already

 

[Topkent]

To think most people had the Suns miles ahead of the Lions last season the Suns looks like it needs another rebuild again already

There KPP stocks are still far more developed than yours. They don't need a full rebuild just concentrate on finding young disciplined midfielders

 

[Scotty_222]

To think most people had the Suns miles ahead of the Lions last season the Suns looks like it needs another rebuild again already

Wouldnt say rebuild, Just need a good mix. We needed to play more of the kids early on like you did, we thought we could have made finals therefore playing more senior players. Thats where the coach comes in, plus again we have been decimated by injury..

 

[WWSD]

What would Billy Stretch cost?

 

[Topkent]

What would Billy Stretch cost?

Probably get him for cheap considering he is playing 2s at the moment. Melbourne wouldn't want to get rid of him but if he did the ole request a trade your second for him and our 3rd or something in that region.

 

[Dez!]

Probably get him for cheap considering he is playing 2s at the moment. Melbourne wouldn't want to get rid of him but if he did the ole request a trade your second for him and our 3rd or something in that region.

He just recently signed an extension.