Prediction 2022 B&F poll
- Thread starter P_Crippy
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Tough one but I think you've picked the right 5. I would go.
1. Walsh
2. Docherty
3. Cripps
4. Saad
5. Curnow
That's not necessarily the order I would rate their seasons but more more based on how I know we award votes.
1. Walsh
2. Docherty
3. Cripps
4. Saad
5. Curnow
That's not necessarily the order I would rate their seasons but more more based on how I know we award votes.
It's impossible to tell. Throw a blanket over all of them. I also wouldn't be surprised in the least if JSOS is right up there too.
Does anyone know how our BnF is scored?
This will be a close one.
1. Walsh
2. Docherty
3. Saad
4. Cripps
5. Curnow
1. Walsh
2. Docherty
3. Saad
4. Cripps
5. Curnow
Think Hewett will be top 5
I think Doc, Charlie and Saad are my top three this year.
zeggie
You can't kick goals when you're unconscious.
Saad.
Add JSOS, TDK & Hewitt into the mix
- Jul 24, 2018
- 1,815
- 7,312
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Saad
Been the most consistent and is the most damaging I believe. Good combination to have
Been the most consistent and is the most damaging I believe. Good combination to have
ferrisb
Brownlow Medallist
JNM voting system explained
Get across the voting system used to determine the winner of the 2017 John Nicholls Medal.
Four coaches (senior coach and three line coaches) have the opportunity to vote for as many players as they feel warrant a vote for each game on the following scale:
4 votes – outstanding performance
3 votes – excellent performance
2 votes – above expectation performance
1 vote – expected performance (trademark game)
A player therefore can receive a maximum of four votes from four coaches giving a maximum of 16 possible votes each round.
ferrisb
Brownlow Medallist
A bit harsh on Walsh...
His outstanding performances would only get 1 vote....
His outstanding performances would only get 1 vote....
Agree re the top 3, Crippa will be top 5 though. I have a feeling Fish might finish high also (top 10), that's my smokey.
- Banned
- #15
Curnow is a funny one. He will likely win the Coleman which is quite a feat seeing what he has been through. But he had the type of year where he might not even finish top 5 in the BnF. As good as he has been I still think he has more improvement to go which is amazing to think considering he will finish the year with 70+ goals.
Key forwards rarely win b&f's as the voting system usually rewards consistency which is harder as a key forward. Buddy has only got 1, Hawkins none, Josh Kennedy none, Jack reiwoldt 1 or none.
Wickzki
Definitely Sam MacLure.
- Oct 1, 2010
- 24,118
- 56,406
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Ophidians Old Boys, Blazers, MCFC
Walsh or Cripps will win it.
I suspect Adam Saad, Jack Silvagni, George Hewett, and Matt Kennedy to poll super well as well.
Docherty, Curnow, and a few others to be recognized as having had fantastic seasons but not necessarily polling outstandingly.
I'll suggest that Lewis Young is the one who surprises and finishes top ten.
I suspect Adam Saad, Jack Silvagni, George Hewett, and Matt Kennedy to poll super well as well.
Docherty, Curnow, and a few others to be recognized as having had fantastic seasons but not necessarily polling outstandingly.
I'll suggest that Lewis Young is the one who surprises and finishes top ten.
JNM voting system explained
Get across the voting system used to determine the winner of the 2017 John Nicholls Medal.www.carltonfc.com.au
Four coaches (senior coach and three line coaches) have the opportunity to vote for as many players as they feel warrant a vote for each game on the following scale:
4 votes – outstanding performance
3 votes – excellent performance
2 votes – above expectation performance
1 vote – expected performance (trademark game)
A player therefore can receive a maximum of four votes from four coaches giving a maximum of 16 possible votes each round.
Had a crack at it using that with the players who are expected to poll well. My top 6 at this stage ended up being.
1. Walsh - 46 Votes
2. Docherty - 42 Votes
3. Curnow - 42 Votes
4. Cripps - 39 Votes
5. Saad - 34 Votes
6. Hewett - 31 Votes
Was about what you would expect. Walsh and Docherty both super consistent and polling nearly every game but Walsh with more standout performances. Cripps strong early and heaps of outstanding games but also a fair few games where he doesn't poll at all. Saad consistent but not as many standout games as others. Hewett strong early and also consistent but drops off after the bye. Curnow surprisingly consistent for a key forward. Polled more then I would have thought.
Similar threads
