Position 2024 Defenders

Are You Starting Nick Daicos in R1

  • Yes - I'll be picking Daicos in R1 - Irrespective of his R0 score

    Votes: 40 44.0%
  • Yes - I'll be picking Daicos in R1 - If he scores 100 or more in R0

    Votes: 16 17.6%
  • No - I won't be picking Daicos in R1 - Irrespective of his R0 score

    Votes: 35 38.5%

  • Total voters
    91
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Nov 6, 2003
121,080
166,674
Melbourne
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
🇦🇺 🇦🇺 🇦🇺 West Adelaide
Defenders
PlayerClubPositionGames 2023PlayerClubPositionGames 2023
Nick DaicosCOLLDEF/MID20Alex KeathWBDEF18
James SicilyHAWDEF19Mark KeaneADELDEF5
Jack SinclairSTKDEF23Aliir AliirPADEF22
Luke RyanFREMDEF23Billy FramptonCOLLDEF15
Nic NewmanCARLDEF21Taylor DuryeaWBDEF20
Harry SheezelNMDEF23Sam FrostHAWDEF18
Tom StewartGEELDEF22Jack HenryGEELDEF11
Liam DugganWCEDEF22Brandon StarcevichBLDEF23
Lachie WhitfieldGWSDEF21Jake KolodjashnijGEELDEF19
Dan HoustonPADEF23Oleg MarkovCOLLDEF20
Jayden ShortRICHDEF16Mac AndrewGCSDEF17
Mitch DuncanGEELDEF16Jordan BoydCARLDEF8
Nasiah Wanganeen-MileraSTKDEF23Alex CincottaCARLDEF16
Jake LloydSYDDEF22Sam De KoningGEELDEF19
Hayden YoungFREMDEF22Jai SerongHAWDEF2
Callum WilkieSTKDEF23Daniel TurnerMELBDEF2
Mason RedmanESSDEF23Jack PayneBLDEF22
Angus BrayshawMELBDEF/MID23Josh RothamWCEDEF13
Bailey DaleWBDEF23Judd McVeeMELBDEF23
Lachie AshGWSDEF23Tom McCartinSYDDEF14
Lachie WellerGCSDEF9Miller BergmanNMDEF12
Wil PowellGCSDEF18Lachie JonesPADEF13
Andrew McGrathESSDEF23Aaron FrancisSYDDEF14
Dyson HeppellESSDEF22Nathan MurphyCOLLDEF21
Brodie SmithADELDEF22Nik CoxESSDEF/MID6
Nick VlastuinRICHDEF21Alex PearceFREMDEF23
John NobleCOLLDEF23Lloyd JohnstonGCSDEF2
Blake HardwickHAWDEF23Ben LongGCSDEF15
Jordan RidleyESSDEF17Joel HamlingSYDDEF4
Jarman ImpeyHAWDEF22Patrick ParnellADELDEF5
Daniel RioliRICHDEF23Jaxon PriorBLDEF5
Ed RichardsWBDEF19Liam JonesWBDEF18
Alex WitherdenWCEDEF22Trent McKenziePADEF17
Christian SalemMELBDEF14Sean LemmensGCSDEF11
James TreziseRICHDEF1Kaine BaldwinESSDEF4
Jayden HuntWCEDEF23Massimo D'AmbrosioHAWDEF8
Jordan ClarkFREMDEF23Lewis MelicanSYDDEF7
Trent RiversMELBDEF23Lachlan CowanCARLDEF7
Darcy MacphersonGCSDEF23Esava RatugoleaPADEF16
Mitchell HingeADELDEF22Jed BewsGEELDEF15
Luke McDonaldNMDEF22Nick MurrayADELDEF17
Rory AtkinsGCSDEF17Darcy GardinerBLDEF2
Brayden MaynardCOLLDEF22Zaine CordySTKDEF/FWD13
Adam SaadCARLDEF22James BorlaseADELDEF4
Connor BudarickGCSDEF2Hugo RalphsmithRICHDEF13
Jason JohannisenWBDEF11Ryan GardnerWBDEF10
Corey WagnerFREMDEF9Brandon WalkerFREMDEF14
Harry HimmelbergGWSDEF22Karl WornerFREMDEF4
Wayne MileraADELDEF22Dylan GrimesRICHDEF22
Nick BlakeySYDDEF23Jy FarrarGCSDEF9
Oliver FlorentSYDDEF23Tylar YoungRICHDEF19
Mitch McGovernCARLDEF19Darragh JoyceBLDEF5
Harry PerrymanGWSDEF19Jase BurgoynePADEF5
Liam StockerSTKDEF22Kallan DawsonNMDEF1
Jacob WeiteringCARLDEF23Harry EdwardsWCEDEF2
Jeremy McGovernWCEDEF9Jordon ButtsADELDEF17
Brodie KempCARLDEF15James O'DonnellWBDEF12
Zach GuthrieGEELDEF23Jackson ArcherNMDEF5
Elliot YeoWCEDEF/MID10Luke ClearyWBDEF1
Brennan CoxFREMDEF20Oisin MullinGEELDEF6
Liam BakerRICHDEF/FWD23Bodhi UwlandGCSDEF3
Keidean ColemanBLDEF20Rhett BazzoWCEDEF11
Steven MayMELBDEF21Adam KennedyGWSDEF/FWD5
Nick HindESSDEF16Denver Grainger-BarrasHAWDEF/FWD7
Harris AndrewsBLDEF23James BlanckHAWDEF15
Isaac QuaynorCOLLDEF23Jakob RyanCOLLDEF1
Isaac CummingGWSDEF/MID17James MaddenBLDEF2
Jayden LaverdeESSDEF19Tom ClureyPADEF1
Chayce JonesADELDEF/MID18Hugh BondADELDEF
Connor IdunGWSDEF23Will HamillADELDEF
Nathan BroadRICHDEF19Carter MichaelBLDEF
Jamaine JonesWCEDEF13Domanic AkueiCARLDEF
Nick HaynesGWSDEF19Sam DurdinCARLDEF
Jack ScrimshawHAWDEF16Zac WilliamsCARLDEF
Tom ColeWCEDEF12Charlie DeanCOLLDEF
Braeden CampbellSYDDEF/MID22Lewis HayesESSDEF
Conor McKennaBLDEF23Zach ReidESSDEF
Noah BaltaRICHDEF23Hugh DaviesFREMDEF
Josh WeddleHAWDEF17Joshua DraperFREMDEF
Kane FarrellPADEF20Oscar MurdochGEELDEF
Ryan BurtonPADEF20Emerson JekaGEELDEF
Darcy MooreCOLLDEF21Caleb GrahamGCSDEF
Marcus WindhagerSTKDEF/MID18Sandy BrockGCSDEF
Ryan LesterBLDEF16Leek AleerGWSDEF
Jimmy WebsterSTKDEF16Blake HowesMELBDEF
Jeremy HoweCOLLDEF11Jed AdamsMELBDEF
Seamus MitchellHAWDEF14Kyle MarshallPADEF
Jake BoweyMELBDEF21Tom McCallumPADEF
Tom BrownRICHDEF1Josh GibcusRICHDEF
Josh BattleSTKDEF22Kaleb SmithRICHDEF
Mark O'ConnorGEELDEF/MID22Angus McLennanSTKDEF
Luke NankervisADELDEF4James Van EsSTKDEF
Brady HoughWCEDEF15Caleb MitchellSYDDEF/MID
Darcy WilmotBLDEF23Cooper VickerySYDDEF
Jack BowesGEELDEF17Harrison ArnoldSYDDEF
Heath ChapmanFREMDEF3Jaiden MagorSYDDEF
Dylan WilliamsPADEF20William EdwardsSYDDEF
Miles BergmanPADEF22Coby BurgielWCEDEF
Dane RampeSYDDEF14Jordyn BakerWCEDEF
Josh WorrellADELDEF12Jedd BusslingerWBDEF
Jake KellyESSDEF17Nick CoffieldWBDEF
Aidan CorrNMDEF19Oscar RyanADELDEF
Charlie BallardGCSDEF23Daniel CurtinADELDEF/MID
Jack BuckleyGWSDEF23Charlie EdwardsADELDEF/MID
Lewis YoungCARLDEF15Zane ZakostelskyBLDEF/RUCK
Changkuoth JiathHAWDEF8Billy WilsonCARLDEF/MID
Caleb MarchbankCARLDEF5Matthew CarrollCARLDEF
Sam TaylorGWSDEF15Tew JiathCOLLDEF
Tom DoedeeBLDEF11Luamon LualESSDEF
Robbie FoxSYDDEF19Archie RobertsESSDEF
Harry CunninghamSYDDEF23Oscar McDonaldFREMDEF
Jake LeverMELBDEF22Ollie MurphyFREMDEF
Ethan HughesFREMDEF20Connor O'SullivanGEELDEF
Adam TomlinsonMELBDEF8Lawson HumphriesGEELDEF/MID
Josh GoaterNMDEF10Will GrahamGCSDEF/MID
Sam CollinsGCSDEF23Sam ClohesyGCSDEF
Ben PatonSTKDEF12James LeakeGWSDEF
Tom BarrassWCEDEF14Joe FontiGWSDEF
Laitham VandermeerWBDEF11William McCabeHAWDEF
Dougal HowardSTKDEF18Bodie RyanHAWDEF
Ben McKayESSDEF19Toby PinkNMDEF
Bailey MacdonaldHAWDEF2Riley HardemanNMDEF
Max MichalanneyADELDEF22Wil DawsonNMDEF/FWD
Brandon Zerk-ThatcherPADEF22Liam O'ConnellSTKDEF
Griffin LogueNMDEF15Angus HastieSTKDEF
Harrison PettyMELBDEF/FWD14Arie SchoenmakerSTKDEF
Sam BanksRICHDEF6Patrick SnellSYDDEF/FWD
Joel JeffreyGCSDEF/FWD7
 
Defenders
PlayerClubPositionGames 2023PlayerClubPositionGames 2023
Nick DaicosCOLLDEF/MID20Alex KeathWBDEF18
James SicilyHAWDEF19Mark KeaneADELDEF5
Jack SinclairSTKDEF23Aliir AliirPADEF22
Luke RyanFREMDEF23Billy FramptonCOLLDEF15
Nic NewmanCARLDEF21Taylor DuryeaWBDEF20
Harry SheezelNMDEF23Sam FrostHAWDEF18
Tom StewartGEELDEF22Jack HenryGEELDEF11
Liam DugganWCEDEF22Brandon StarcevichBLDEF23
Lachie WhitfieldGWSDEF21Jake KolodjashnijGEELDEF19
Dan HoustonPADEF23Oleg MarkovCOLLDEF20
Jayden ShortRICHDEF16Mac AndrewGCSDEF17
Mitch DuncanGEELDEF16Jordan BoydCARLDEF8
Nasiah Wanganeen-MileraSTKDEF23Alex CincottaCARLDEF16
Jake LloydSYDDEF22Sam De KoningGEELDEF19
Hayden YoungFREMDEF22Jai SerongHAWDEF2
Callum WilkieSTKDEF23Daniel TurnerMELBDEF2
Mason RedmanESSDEF23Jack PayneBLDEF22
Angus BrayshawMELBDEF/MID23Josh RothamWCEDEF13
Bailey DaleWBDEF23Judd McVeeMELBDEF23
Lachie AshGWSDEF23Tom McCartinSYDDEF14
Lachie WellerGCSDEF9Miller BergmanNMDEF12
Wil PowellGCSDEF18Lachie JonesPADEF13
Andrew McGrathESSDEF23Aaron FrancisSYDDEF14
Dyson HeppellESSDEF22Nathan MurphyCOLLDEF21
Brodie SmithADELDEF22Nik CoxESSDEF/MID6
Nick VlastuinRICHDEF21Alex PearceFREMDEF23
John NobleCOLLDEF23Lloyd JohnstonGCSDEF2
Blake HardwickHAWDEF23Ben LongGCSDEF15
Jordan RidleyESSDEF17Joel HamlingSYDDEF4
Jarman ImpeyHAWDEF22Patrick ParnellADELDEF5
Daniel RioliRICHDEF23Jaxon PriorBLDEF5
Ed RichardsWBDEF19Liam JonesWBDEF18
Alex WitherdenWCEDEF22Trent McKenziePADEF17
Christian SalemMELBDEF14Sean LemmensGCSDEF11
James TreziseRICHDEF1Kaine BaldwinESSDEF4
Jayden HuntWCEDEF23Massimo D'AmbrosioHAWDEF8
Jordan ClarkFREMDEF23Lewis MelicanSYDDEF7
Trent RiversMELBDEF23Lachlan CowanCARLDEF7
Darcy MacphersonGCSDEF23Esava RatugoleaPADEF16
Mitchell HingeADELDEF22Jed BewsGEELDEF15
Luke McDonaldNMDEF22Nick MurrayADELDEF17
Rory AtkinsGCSDEF17Darcy GardinerBLDEF2
Brayden MaynardCOLLDEF22Zaine CordySTKDEF/FWD13
Adam SaadCARLDEF22James BorlaseADELDEF4
Connor BudarickGCSDEF2Hugo RalphsmithRICHDEF13
Jason JohannisenWBDEF11Ryan GardnerWBDEF10
Corey WagnerFREMDEF9Brandon WalkerFREMDEF14
Harry HimmelbergGWSDEF22Karl WornerFREMDEF4
Wayne MileraADELDEF22Dylan GrimesRICHDEF22
Nick BlakeySYDDEF23Jy FarrarGCSDEF9
Oliver FlorentSYDDEF23Tylar YoungRICHDEF19
Mitch McGovernCARLDEF19Darragh JoyceBLDEF5
Harry PerrymanGWSDEF19Jase BurgoynePADEF5
Liam StockerSTKDEF22Kallan DawsonNMDEF1
Jacob WeiteringCARLDEF23Harry EdwardsWCEDEF2
Jeremy McGovernWCEDEF9Jordon ButtsADELDEF17
Brodie KempCARLDEF15James O'DonnellWBDEF12
Zach GuthrieGEELDEF23Jackson ArcherNMDEF5
Elliot YeoWCEDEF/MID10Luke ClearyWBDEF1
Brennan CoxFREMDEF20Oisin MullinGEELDEF6
Liam BakerRICHDEF/FWD23Bodhi UwlandGCSDEF3
Keidean ColemanBLDEF20Rhett BazzoWCEDEF11
Steven MayMELBDEF21Adam KennedyGWSDEF/FWD5
Nick HindESSDEF16Denver Grainger-BarrasHAWDEF/FWD7
Harris AndrewsBLDEF23James BlanckHAWDEF15
Isaac QuaynorCOLLDEF23Jakob RyanCOLLDEF1
Isaac CummingGWSDEF/MID17James MaddenBLDEF2
Jayden LaverdeESSDEF19Tom ClureyPADEF1
Chayce JonesADELDEF/MID18Hugh BondADELDEF
Connor IdunGWSDEF23Will HamillADELDEF
Nathan BroadRICHDEF19Carter MichaelBLDEF
Jamaine JonesWCEDEF13Domanic AkueiCARLDEF
Nick HaynesGWSDEF19Sam DurdinCARLDEF
Jack ScrimshawHAWDEF16Zac WilliamsCARLDEF
Tom ColeWCEDEF12Charlie DeanCOLLDEF
Braeden CampbellSYDDEF/MID22Lewis HayesESSDEF
Conor McKennaBLDEF23Zach ReidESSDEF
Noah BaltaRICHDEF23Hugh DaviesFREMDEF
Josh WeddleHAWDEF17Joshua DraperFREMDEF
Kane FarrellPADEF20Oscar MurdochGEELDEF
Ryan BurtonPADEF20Emerson JekaGEELDEF
Darcy MooreCOLLDEF21Caleb GrahamGCSDEF
Marcus WindhagerSTKDEF/MID18Sandy BrockGCSDEF
Ryan LesterBLDEF16Leek AleerGWSDEF
Jimmy WebsterSTKDEF16Blake HowesMELBDEF
Jeremy HoweCOLLDEF11Jed AdamsMELBDEF
Seamus MitchellHAWDEF14Kyle MarshallPADEF
Jake BoweyMELBDEF21Tom McCallumPADEF
Tom BrownRICHDEF1Josh GibcusRICHDEF
Josh BattleSTKDEF22Kaleb SmithRICHDEF
Mark O'ConnorGEELDEF/MID22Angus McLennanSTKDEF
Luke NankervisADELDEF4James Van EsSTKDEF
Brady HoughWCEDEF15Caleb MitchellSYDDEF/MID
Darcy WilmotBLDEF23Cooper VickerySYDDEF
Jack BowesGEELDEF17Harrison ArnoldSYDDEF
Heath ChapmanFREMDEF3Jaiden MagorSYDDEF
Dylan WilliamsPADEF20William EdwardsSYDDEF
Miles BergmanPADEF22Coby BurgielWCEDEF
Dane RampeSYDDEF14Jordyn BakerWCEDEF
Josh WorrellADELDEF12Jedd BusslingerWBDEF
Jake KellyESSDEF17Nick CoffieldWBDEF
Aidan CorrNMDEF19Oscar RyanADELDEF
Charlie BallardGCSDEF23Daniel CurtinADELDEF/MID
Jack BuckleyGWSDEF23Charlie EdwardsADELDEF/MID
Lewis YoungCARLDEF15Zane ZakostelskyBLDEF/RUCK
Changkuoth JiathHAWDEF8Billy WilsonCARLDEF/MID
Caleb MarchbankCARLDEF5Matthew CarrollCARLDEF
Sam TaylorGWSDEF15Tew JiathCOLLDEF
Tom DoedeeBLDEF11Luamon LualESSDEF
Robbie FoxSYDDEF19Archie RobertsESSDEF
Harry CunninghamSYDDEF23Oscar McDonaldFREMDEF
Jake LeverMELBDEF22Ollie MurphyFREMDEF
Ethan HughesFREMDEF20Connor O'SullivanGEELDEF
Adam TomlinsonMELBDEF8Lawson HumphriesGEELDEF/MID
Josh GoaterNMDEF10Will GrahamGCSDEF/MID
Sam CollinsGCSDEF23Sam ClohesyGCSDEF
Ben PatonSTKDEF12James LeakeGWSDEF
Tom BarrassWCEDEF14Joe FontiGWSDEF
Laitham VandermeerWBDEF11William McCabeHAWDEF
Dougal HowardSTKDEF18Bodie RyanHAWDEF
Ben McKayESSDEF19Toby PinkNMDEF
Bailey MacdonaldHAWDEF2Riley HardemanNMDEF
Max MichalanneyADELDEF22Wil DawsonNMDEF/FWD
Brandon Zerk-ThatcherPADEF22Liam O'ConnellSTKDEF
Griffin LogueNMDEF15Angus HastieSTKDEF
Harrison PettyMELBDEF/FWD14Arie SchoenmakerSTKDEF
Sam BanksRICHDEF6Patrick SnellSYDDEF/FWD
Joel JeffreyGCSDEF/FWD7
What do we think Ridley is priced at? Season of 2 halves last year. His finish may have pushed his average/price to the point where the risk is too big.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Moderator
  • #3
What do we think Ridley is priced at? Season of 2 halves last year. His finish may have pushed his average/price to the point where the risk is too big.
Or ...does the recruitment of Ben Mckay, help free up Ridley ?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Ridley's a kent, scores well when you don't have him, then stinks it up when you trade him in.

He cost me 4 trades last season he is on the never again list.
Copped all his poor scores at the start and traded him out then he came good traded him back in again only to shaft me again.:moustache:
 

Attachments

  • tenor (7).gif
    tenor (7).gif
    365.5 KB · Views: 44
Daicos and Sicily are the two expensive options I’ll take. Only problem with these two is they get attention, but along with Stewart should be top 3.

Young playing midfield is good value so will take him, and don’t mind Sheezel. Think at HB he can do 110+ but at HF might only manage 85-90

Rookies look ok - Coffield and Hore should do 70+ if they play, and Curtain should play r1. Toby Pink is 102k, Roos are bare at KPD.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Daicos and Sicily are the two expensive options I’ll take. Only problem with these two is they get attention, but along with Stewart should be top 3.

Young playing midfield is good value so will take him, and don’t mind Sheezel. Think at HB he can do 110+ but at HF might only manage 85-90

Rookies look ok - Coffield and Hore should do 70+ if they play, and Curtain should play r1. Toby Pink is 102k, Roos are bare at KPD.
Yeah defence looks pretty easy. Big price to pay for a second year player in Sheezus but worked for Daicos.
 
Coleman too, definitely unders, just needs to stay on the park.
i dont really like the coleman pick

averaged 87 in 2022, but this was with rich, and without mckenna and wilmot. looks like there is upside on 2023 average of 71 with some scope for natural progression too at a glance.

when rich left the side in 2023 after round 13, coleman averaged 84.5~ for the rest of the year, excluding finals. some of his biggest games came in finals which is why i think people like the pick as his best games were the ones freshest in peoples minds. it seems like mckenna took most of brisbane's kick ins when rich left the side as well, with coleman and wilmot getting a lesser share, so he does not have an easy avenue to 25+ points a week like some defender options do. those two aforementioned players being rebound options brisbane go through a lot also hurts colemans oppurtunities to seagull easy possessions.

as you hint at in your post he is also quite injury prone. too much risk in coleman for me to pick him
 
Last edited:
Back
Top