Opinion 2024 Fantasy - Player X vs Y vs Z

[DukeX]

MID: Running LDU, Steele and Touk- Seen LDU and Steele in plenty of teams, but not hearing/seeing much of Touk- am I missing something in particular? Is it his early bye, or is there better value in getting MCrouch, Guthrie or N Martin instead?

DEF: Coffield on field with Curtin and Gibcus on the bench vs Curtin on field with Gibcus and Pink on bench (100k freed up- potentially to use to take Touk to AndyBray)

Please hit me with your logic!

 

[Shaunn]

MID: Running LDU, Steele and Touk- Seen LDU and Steele in plenty of teams, but not hearing/seeing much of Touk- am I missing something in particular? Is it his early bye, or is there better value in getting MCrouch, Guthrie or N Martin instead?

DEF: Coffield on field with Curtin and Gibcus on the bench vs Curtin on field with Gibcus and Pink on bench (100k freed up- potentially to use to take Touk to AndyBray)

Please hit me with your logic!

The bye is the only reason. Curitin on bench, will get games but score might not be to great.

 

[tigs2010]

MID: Running LDU, Steele and Touk- Seen LDU and Steele in plenty of teams, but not hearing/seeing much of Touk- am I missing something in particular? Is it his early bye, or is there better value in getting MCrouch, Guthrie or N Martin instead?

DEF: Coffield on field with Curtin and Gibcus on the bench vs Curtin on field with Gibcus and Pink on bench (100k freed up- potentially to use to take Touk to AndyBray)

Please hit me with your logic!

I think the early bye and not knowing how Dimma will play. Want to see it R0. Flanders is different given the shitty forward options.

 

[happy_eagle]

NWM + Billings +100k
or
Coleman + Macrae

 

[WaynesWorld19]

NWM + Billings +100k
or
Coleman + Macrae

NWM + Billings +100K ......easy choice

 

[bettingonbetts]

NWM vs Sheez vs Stewart

 

[bettingonbetts]

MID: Running LDU, Steele and Touk- Seen LDU and Steele in plenty of teams, but not hearing/seeing much of Touk- am I missing something in particular? Is it his early bye, or is there better value in getting MCrouch, Guthrie or N Martin instead?

DEF: Coffield on field with Curtin and Gibcus on the bench vs Curtin on field with Gibcus and Pink on bench (100k freed up- potentially to use to take Touk to AndyBray)

Please hit me with your logic!

It’s just because of the early bye I assume.
I don’t love having curtin on field but when you put it that way and able to upgrade to bray! Looks like a no brainer

 

[Barrybran]

NWM vs Sheez vs Stewart

I've got Stewart. The other two arguably have more upside but Geelong's early run is better. Also gives you an opportunity to see NWM v Sinclair and Sheezel's role when Fisher returns.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

NWM vs Sheez vs Stewart

As Barrybran said ....Stewart

I'd be worried with Sheezel, a 2nd year player, priced at his max ave IMO

 

[Shaunn]

Gawn (105-108) and Windhager (80-85) = 185-193 points

or

Xerri (85-90) and NWM (97-103) = 182-193 points



Early bye only for Gawn out of the 4, Probably make more cash gen off the bottom trade but im close to the top rucks with Gawn, honestly not sure.

 

[Zevon]

Gawn (105-108) and Windhager (80-85) = 185-193 points

or

Xerri (85-90) and NWM (97-103) = 182-193 points



Early bye only for Gawn out of the 4, Probably make more cash gen off the bottom trade but im close to the top rucks with Gawn, honestly not sure.

I’ve had NWM in my plans all pre season, but I’m softening on him (albeit only slightly) given it sounds like Sinclair’s days playing a bit of midfield are done and he’s back to being a pure running defender. Maybe I’m jumping at shadows but I do think that eats into NWM’s points even if only a little.

Gawn on the other hand could legitimately be back to 110+ scoring which is a steal at his price, and he has literally nobody taking his points/role from him. So would lean towards option A on that alone.

 

[tigs2010]

I’ve had NWM in my plans all pre season, but I’m softening on him (albeit only slightly) given it sounds like Sinclair’s days playing a bit of midfield are done and he’s back to being a pure running defender. Maybe I’m jumping at shadows but I do think that eats into NWM’s points even if only a little.

Gawn on the other hand could legitimately be back to 110+ scoring which is a steal at his price, and he has literally nobody taking his points/role from him. So would lean towards option A on that alone.

They start with Geelong on the skinny ground too which won't help him (inb4 goes 130)

 

[Zevon]

They start with Geelong on the skinny ground too which won't help him (inb4 goes 130)

Yes I too believe he’s likely to score poorly in that one.

Everybody should take advantage of our kiss of death and start him for his incoming 150

 

[fargothegreat]

Pick two for the bench (draft):
T.Powell, McKercher, Fisher and M.Crouch.

This is my team currently:

B: Young Lloyd W.Powell
M: Green Walsh Steele LDU
F: Macrae Adams Zorko
R: English
B: Soldo Coleman Rachele M.Crouch McKercher

Got plenty of mid cover considering my whole starting forward line are all MID/F, so thinking of dropping Crouch and punting on Powell after today's performance before someone else has the same idea, given how risky my current forward line is. Would then have 3 North players, but we're not playing byes so I don't think this will matter too much.

 

[tigs2010]

Pick two for the bench (draft):
T.Powell, McKercher, Fisher and M.Crouch.

This is my team currently:

B: Young Lloyd W.Powell
M: Green Walsh Steele LDU
F: Macrae Adams Zorko
R: English
B: Soldo Coleman Rachele M.Crouch McKercher

Got plenty of mid cover considering my whole starting forward line are all MID/F, so thinking of dropping Crouch and punting on Powell after today's performance before someone else has the same idea, given how risky my current forward line is. Would then have 3 North players, but we're not playing byes so I don't think this will matter too much.

Keeper league?

 

[tigs2010]

Butters or Steele?

 

[fargothegreat]

Keeper league?

Nope

 

[tigs2010]

Nope

I'd probably go Crouch and Powell. Punt McKercher.

 

[Zevon]

Butters or Steele?

Currently rocking both and very happy not to have to choose, but if I had to split them then Butters for that gun early draw that Port have, plus natural improvement as a 23 year old? Looks a slightly safer bet than Steele who I do still expect to have a bounce-back year.

 

[tigs2010]

Currently rocking both and very happy not to have to choose, but if I had to split them then Butters for that gun early draw that Port have, plus natural improvement as a 23 year old? Looks a slightly safer bet than Steele who I do still expect to have a bounce-back year.

Yeah would like to have Laird, Rozee, Butters, Steele as M1-4 but hard without sacrificing bench.

 

[Zevon]

Yeah would like to have Laird, Rozee, Butters, Steele as M1-4 but hard without sacrificing bench.

Similar situation for me in that I’d love to have Rozee but have gone down to a cheaper 700-850k option to allow for a deeper bench too.

 

[tigs2010]

Similar situation for me in that I’d love to have Rozee but have gone down to a cheaper 700-850k option to allow for a deeper bench too.

I've just culled Martin to make it happen. Someone will become him if need to fix bench. I'm done*




*till 1/4 time first game tomorrow.

 

[DukeX]

If you could pick any two premos at M1 & M2, who would you take?:
Bont, Green, Laird & AndyBray

To sit with Butters, Steele, LDU, and the 3 vanilla mid rookies. Or are there some out of scope ones worth going with instead (ie Daws and Errol)?

 

[LilDosDos]

Budarick and James Jordon
vs
Billings and Williams ?

Leaning Budarick and Jordon as that gives me the option to go Budarick down to Williams at round 3 if he doesn't do what I'm hoping?

 

[Shaunn]

Stewart (98-103) and Fyfe (75-80)
vs
NWM (97-102) and Fisher (87-92) (This is a hard one to average)

Am i putting to many points on the bottom trade?
Seems likes its safer and more points.