Opinion 2024 Fantasy - Player X vs Y vs Z

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Good shout. Scored well. Didn't watch game so need to watch a replay of it to do so. That was a ton of kick outs

He changed his role last year. Check his end to the season!

I think he's a solid unit for the price

 

[DukeX]

If you had to pick 2 of: MCrouch, Wines, Newc, Amon- who are you taking?

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

If you had to pick 2 of: MCrouch, Wines, Newc, Amon- who are you taking?

Newc and Amon. I am biased

 

[bettingonbetts]

If you had to pick 2 of: MCrouch, Wines, Newc, Amon- who are you taking?

Newc and crouch

 

[Chris99]

My first pick in a keeper redraft is in the third round, I’ll be hunting a forward and pushing for a flag, hoping one of these are available

Billings, ANB, Harmes, Miers, Rayner

Who you taking?

 

[JDWCE]

My first pick in a keeper redraft is in the third round, I’ll be hunting a forward and pushing for a flag, hoping one of these are available

Billings, ANB, Harmes, Miers, Rayner

Who you taking?

I’d wager Harmes is almost certainly available due to his age. He went undrafted in my keeper - I considered him at my last pick but went young instead.

If you’re going for future then I’d be grabbing Miers. He’s only 24 and probably stays a forward permanently. Billings would be handy but he’s older and injury prone

If you’re going for the win this year then I think Harmes probably has the best scoring capacity as he will get mid minutes

 

[WaynesWorld19]

If you had to pick 2 of: MCrouch, Wines, Newc, Amon- who are you taking?

Wines (fixture and byes) and Newcombe

 

[Tex Danger]

Butters, Steele, LDU

talk me out of any of these and/or into any alternatives (aside from Martin, crouch who I also have)

These 3 been in my squad all preseason

 

[Shaunn]

Generally finding it hard to figure out which 2 to pick from these 4.

Fyfe, Billings, Cam Mackenzie and Tsatas..

 

[Barrybran]

Butters, Steele, LDU

talk me out of any of these and/or into any alternatives (aside from Martin, crouch who I also have)

These 3 been in my squad all preseason

Potential ankle for Butters. Didn't play beyond Q1 as a precaution. The other two should be fine.

 

[Barrybran]

Generally finding it hard to figure out which 2 to pick from these 4.

Fyfe, Billings, Cam Mackenzie and Tsatas..

Billings and Fyfe for mine. I would love Fyfe to score more than he likely will but his role is concrete and he'll go up in value. I think there is still speculation over Mackenzie and Tsatas on that front. Billings will play more forward but Melbourne have an excellent midfield. He'll get opportunities.

 

[Tex Danger]

Potential ankle for Butters. Didn't play beyond Q1 as a precaution. The other two should be fine.

Thats part of what has me ? This mix

Unlikely to change it but butters obviously could be a spanner in works. Worst is if he’s named but with any ? On that in the lead up yiu have to pass on him

Newcombe and Amon prob the main ones I’d consider outside them

 

[Barrybran]

Thats part of what has me ? This mix

Unlikely to change it but butters obviously could be a spanner in works. Worst is if he’s named but with any ? On that in the lead up yiu have to pass on him

Newcombe and Amon prob the main ones I’d consider outside them

I've had Butters, Steele, LDU and Newcombe for much of the preseason. I've just swapped Butters for Martin. I don't feel great about it and Butters will certainly line up in round 1 but it will be interesting to see the news out of Port over the next few days.

 

[DukeX]

Butters, Steele, LDU

talk me out of any of these and/or into any alternatives (aside from Martin, crouch who I also have)

These 3 been in my squad all preseason

I'm in the exact same situation.
Thinking LDU or Steele to Newc, and Butters up to Gulden, but wondering if I'm just being a bit too reactionary

 

[Shaunn]

I'm in the exact same situation.
Thinking LDU or Steele to Newc, and Butters up to Gulden, but wondering if I'm just being a bit too reactionary

Why are you removing Steele? role is there and tackled well, did exactly what he needed to do.

 

[Lonhro21]

Hey all, thoughts on Mclugg v Wines?

 

[Milo Cyrus]

Hey all, thoughts on Mclugg v Wines?

McLugg has a bye R2, Wines for me.

 

[Milo Cyrus]

Fisher & Bowes Vs Mackenzie & Salem?

 

[tigs2010]

Fisher & Bowes Vs Mackenzie & Salem?

1 if Bowes is in the side.

 

[Milo Cyrus]

1 if Bowes is in the side.

Yep, that's where I'm at.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Fisher & Bowes Vs Mackenzie & Salem?

This is who i have

 

[Phar Ace]

Newc and Amon. I am biased

With good reason

 

[Phar Ace]

This is who i have

Good legal representation or just footballers

 

[happy_eagle]

Sheezel + Fyfe/Mackenzie
or
Z.Williams + Butters

(the latter obviously depending on fitness)

 

[Barrybran]

Sheezel + Fyfe/Mackenzie
or
Z.Williams + Butters

(the latter obviously depending on fitness)

First option pending round zero