List Mgmt. 2024 List Management Part 2 📃

[NewDarkNavyBlues]

What if those guys agreed to sign for much less than the league avaerage? Does it make sense then? What if we'd need to pay more to fill those spots?

I'm not saying that's the case, just that we don't have enough information to do anything but broadly speculate.

On SM-F926B using BigFooty.com mobile app

The fact we signed Corey Durdin to a multi year deal this year, yet we are considering letting Owies (our best small forward) explore opportunities, sums up how this football club is run.

 

[Arr0w]

The fact we signed Corey Durdin to a multi year deal this year, yet we are considering letting Owies (our best small forward) explore opportunities, sums up how this football club is run.

I think Durdin has "upside"

 

[Foucault1989]

Outstanding delistings today.

Trade Owies for pick 30 or so and trade that pick and our 2nd to move up in the draft.

3 or so picks inside the top 30 at the draft and some cheaper trades will be a very good outcome.

That's my view as well. Load up with draft picks in a reportedly strong draft.

All gun AFL players come from the draft. The best teams nail their draft picks. Draft picks are not underrated - they are the best way of developing a sustainable team. You've just got to hit the right targets and develop them.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

This is a very good point. The question is why?

Players don't lose their ability. Are they sore, injured, frustrated, confused or have opposition sides found us out?

One reason I am concerned about how we fell away this year is the our 2 best players (Cripps & Weitering) couldn't have done much more. I thought Cripps had his best year

Lack of training leads to a drop off in skills eventually. Id imagine the consistent injuries players had to deal with would have been the main reason for it.

Form is generally a bit contagious too so once a few started dropping away it's quite common for others to fall away just a couple of percent too.

Quite confident next year most will be back to their best if we get our list fit and healthy over pre season.

 

[DangerousD]

What if those guys agreed to sign for much less than the league avaerage? Does it make sense then? What if we'd need to pay more to fill those spots?

I'm not saying that's the case, just that we don't have enough information to do anything but broadly speculate.

On SM-F926B using BigFooty.com mobile app

I assume those guys signed for low $$$ I’m not suggesting they are taking much cap, but no idea what they’d actually be on.

On the information available, I would have preferred to get rid of Durdin and offered Owies a contract.

 

[Soapy V]

The fact we signed Corey Durdin to a multi year deal this year, yet we are considering letting Owies (our best small forward) explore opportunities, sums up how this football club is run.

Agree. Give them a one year deal until they are established. Corey is 23 at start of next season. He’s not a kid anymore

At some stage you need to go past talent and potential and judge on results

 

[JJBagger]

The fact we signed Corey Durdin to a multi year deal this year, yet we are considering letting Owies (our best small forward) explore opportunities, sums up how this football club is run.

How much he’s getting paid matters more than the two years he got. If he’s on 150-200k a year, for a borderline best 22 player, is pretty solid. If he ends up being the 35th player on the list, then it’s not much of an issue imo

 

[Soapy V]

Lack of training leads to a drop off in skills eventually. Id imagine the consistent injuries players had to deal with would have been the main reason for it.

Form is generally a bit contagious too so once a few started dropping away it's quite common for others to fall away just a couple of percent too.

Quite confident next year most will be back to their best if we get our list fit and healthy over pre season.

Fair points.

My concern is we will use injuries as pure reason for drop off and won’t address other issues

There is no way that injuries alone were the reason for our last 10 weeks

 

[JJBagger]

Agree. Give them a one year deal until they are established. Corey is 23 at start of next season. He’s not a kid anymore

At some stage you need to go past talent and potential and judge on results

How do we know he wasn’t getting multi year deals offered elsewhere, and we had to give him 2 years to keep him?

 

[Soapy V]

How do we know he wasn’t getting multi year deals offered elsewhere, and we had to give him 2 years to keep him?

I never said otherwise? If that was the case I would let him go and got the picks

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Fair points.

My concern is we will use injuries as pure reason for drop off and won’t address other issues

There is no way that injuries alone were the reason for our last 10 weeks

Which is part of the reason I'm glad we got embarrassed up in Brisbane and a few games before that. Highlighted just how dire our deficiencies are when compared to some of the other teams around the league.

We still have boat loads of talent on the list but a poor end to the year may be the catalyst for change we needed to make the tough calls we should have at the end of 23.

A good trade and draft period could take us from pretenders to contenders very quickly.

 

[Soapy V]

How much he’s getting paid matters more than the two years he got. If he’s on 150-200k a year, for a borderline best 22 player, is pretty solid. If he ends up being the 35th player on the list, then it’s not much of an issue imo

Disagree. It holds spots and costs money. It adds up.

We saw this year how vital list spots are. SC can get right easily and to say $300k or more is nothing is madness especially when we are talking about 3-4 players on a list of 38

Draftees are on $150-$200k these days. Not mature players

 

[Soapy V]

Which is part of the reason I'm glad we got embarrassed up in Brisbane and a few games before that. Highlighted just how dire our deficiencies are when compared to some of the other teams around the league.

We still have boat loads of talent on the list but a poor end to the year may be the catalyst for change we needed to make the tough calls we should have at the end of 23.

A good trade and draft period could take us from pretenders to contenders very quickly.

I agree. I like our list and think we will improve it

Issue for me is fitness and a game style that allows us to play to our potential

 

[JJBagger]

If that was the case I would let him go and got the picks

But we didn’t, thats not part of the discussion. It was about why he got 2 years

 

[Soapy V]

But we didn’t, thats not part of the discussion. It was about why he got 2 years

Exactly. And my response stands

PS he got 2 extra years on top of a nearly full season yet to run.

Anyway. Not a big deal. I just don’t see the reasoning

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I agree. I like our list and think we will improve it

Issue for me is fitness and a game style that allows us to play to our potential

Yep. I think if we add 3-4 good players in the trade and draft period and then get some natural progression out of some of Wilson, Moir, Elijah, Ollie, Boyd, Motlop and Durdin then we'll be right in the mix.

There's a lot of premiership quality talent on our list, there's also some that just aren't quite up to it ATM.

 

[Arr0w]

Durdin has upside right?

 

[Soapy V]

Yep. I think if we add 3-4 good players in the trade and draft period and then get some natural progression out of some of Wilson, Moir, Elijah, Ollie, Boyd, Motlop and Durdin then we'll be right in the mix.

There's a lot of premiership quality talent on our list, there's also some that just aren't quite up to it ATM.

100% agree

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Durdin has upside right?

I think a lot of that depends on his shoulder surgeon. He's a high pressure player, with 2 bung shoulders he's going to struggle doing what he's built his game on.

 

[DangerousD]

This is a very good point. The question is why?

Players don't lose their ability. Are they sore, injured, frustrated, confused or have opposition sides found us out?

One reason I am concerned about how we fell away this year is the our 2 best players (Cripps & Weitering) couldn't have done much more. I thought Cripps had his best year

Not just Cripps and Weitering either, Kennedy, Charlie, Harry all had very good years. TDK and Pitt probably both had their best seasons, stats wise Newmans output went up in last year as well, then Owies had his best season.

That’s a lot of good players having good seasons but still dropping off.

I still think our drop off has come from poor coaching in regards to set ups around stoppages and ball retention and not so much injuries which has been a convenient excuse for our club and coaches.

 

[Arr0w]

I think a lot of that depends on his shoulder surgeon. He's a high pressure player, with 2 bung shoulders he's going to struggle doing what he's built his game on.

I think we sweat the small stuff way too much.

But, always prefer your stoic stanch rather than the burger flippers

 

[Soapy V]

I think a lot of that depends on his shoulder surgeon. He's a high pressure player, with 2 bung shoulders he's going to struggle doing what he's built his game on.

And no one has said he doesn’t have ability or upside. If so, we would want him delisted. Nothing to do with conversation

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I think we sweat the small stuff way too much.

But, always prefer your stoic stanch rather than the burger flippers

I'll go to my grave saying our small forwards since Betts have all stunk, and I'm sticking to it!

Just hope that can be addressed in the off season so we're primed for 2025.

 

[Soapy V]

I'll go to my grave saying our small forwards since Betts have all stunk, and I'm sticking to it!

Just hope that can be addressed in the off season so we're primed for 2025.

Question.

Has the Durdin or Cottrell extensions possibly cost us Owies? We need spots and to keep improving our SC

Out of these three who would you prefer?

Personally, in regards to ALL our small forwards we are living in hope rather than results. That can be okay with 1 or 2 but when it’s 4 or 5 it’s a concern and a real issue for our list

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Question.

Has the Durdin or Cottrell extensions possibly cost us Owies? We need spots and to keep improving our SC

Out of these three who would you prefer?

Personally, in regards to ALL our small forwards we are living in hope rather than results. That can be okay with 1 or 2 but when it’s 4 or 5 it’s a concern and a real issue for our list

Don't think so. I think Owies has the most value out of the 3 of them but has the least scope for improvement too.

Imo it's a good move to move him on at peak value if it helps us acquire some other players that fit our list better.

The need for outside run and better users going inside 50 is something Owies unfortunately will never be able to provide us imo.