List Mgmt. 2024 List Management Part 2 📃

[Soapy V]

Is he leaving

No but been in 2s. Scott doesn’t seem to be a fan

 

[Soapy V]

Very conditional player.

Used to be but has improved a lot. Same was said about Chol

 

[Michael Jezz]

You bag Austin in nearly every one of your posts and it gets rather boring. Anyhow you didn't answer the original question which Hawthorn pick from Round 2 onwards for National, rookie and mid season drafts from the last 6 years that you rate ?

Hawthorn have List Management. Carlton is a failure. LOOK AT FACTS

Jai Newcombe- midseason draft
Connor Nash- Cat B rookie
Lloyd Meek- pick 69
Dylan Moore- pick 67
Mitch Lewis- Pick 76
Worpel- Pick 45
Harry Morrison- Pick 64

 

[Soapy V]

I'll be interested to see how Motlop goes with a full season, he's got goal sense which is a good start. Hopefully his injury issues were a one off and not a sign of things to come. Durdin might need to be tried in the Caleb Daniel type role, he can't stay as a small forward without goal sense.

Yes! Finally someone who agrees

 

[Stamos]

Hawthorn have List Management. Carlton is a failure. LOOK AT FACTS

Jai Newcombe- midseason draft
Connor Nash- Cat B rookie
Lloyd Meek- pick 69
Dylan Moore- pick 67
Mitch Lewis- Pick 76
Worpel- Pick 45
Harry Morrison- Pick 64

Meek was part of the O’Meara trade, they didn’t draft him

 

[Opium]

Pittonet is the worst ruckman in the comp. Someone tell me what he offers the side??

 

[Doro]

Pittonet is the worst ruckman in the comp. Someone tell me what he offers the side??

When fit/firing his hitouts to advantage are amongst the best. Seems to lose his effectiveness very quickly after a couple of good games though.

 

[Sweet Seventeen]

Pittonet is the worst ruckman in the comp. Someone tell me what he offers the side??

****ing obvious that he is playing under duress. We all know that he is capable of much better.

He is a very decent second string ruckman. He will be much better next season, after he has had a good pre season.

 

[Doro]

Yes! Finally someone who agrees

Was that some of your original thought? Nice.

 

[Opium]

Very conditional player.

Turning 28. Offers little if he doesn't mark

 

[Opium]

F------ obvious that he is playing under duress. We all know that he is capable of much better.

He is a very decent second string ruckman. He will be much better next season, after he has had a good pre season.

What is he capable of? He doesn't mark, doesn't kick goals. Doesn't tackle. Please elaborate.

 

[Soapy V]

Was that some of your original thought? Nice.

I just think we have a number of players that are being made into certain players instead of playing their natural roles

Durdin is one of them

 

[Opium]

No but been in 2s. Scott doesn’t seem to be a fan

Once the ball hits the ground. He's a liability

 

[Soapy V]

Turning 30. Offers little if he doesn't mark

Wright? He’s 27 and won a B&F. He’s better than that

 

[Opium]

Wright? He’s 27 and won a B&F. He’s better than that

Yeah. I just corrected my post. He's only 27. Issue is he's very one dimensional in the modern game

 

[Prem17]

Just an opinion on a few suggestions made in the last few pages.
I've never been a huge fan of Austin but I'll give him full credit for Acres and E. Hollands. Absolutely fantastic recruiting there. Yet to do a lot in the draft though.
As for our off field team, I think Lloyd should be gone but who are the possible replacements?
Wright seems to be on the outer at the pies but he has been good at the role for a long time.

Like to hear any reasonable opinions from ITK Vic posters as I haven't been listening to Melbourne radio much this year.

 

[Soapy V]

Yeah. I just corrected my post. He's only 27. Issue is he's very one dimensional in the modern game

Don’t agree. He’s no star but can play a key role. Beautiful kick for goal

Playing FF releases Charlie and is a good relief for TDK. Could release Jack to KPD role we need filled

Late maturer who’s best footy could easily be ahead of him

 

[macky99]

****ing obvious that he is playing under duress. We all know that he is capable of much better.

He is a very decent second string ruckman. He will be much better next season, after he has had a good pre season.

l would not be surprised if we trade Pittonet and look at other options for a back up ruckman, he just offers very little and his mobility is a major deficiency.

 

[Soapy V]

Hawthorn have List Management. Carlton is a failure. LOOK AT FACTS

Jai Newcombe- midseason draft
Connor Nash- Cat B rookie
Lloyd Meek- pick 69
Dylan Moore- pick 67
Mitch Lewis- Pick 76
Worpel- Pick 45
Harry Morrison- Pick 64

Is that selection or coaching/development?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I'll be interested to see how Motlop goes with a full season, he's got goal sense which is a good start. Hopefully his injury issues were a one off and not a sign of things to come. Durdin might need to be tried in the Caleb Daniel type role, he can't stay as a small forward without goal sense.

Motlop is a slow off the mark small forward with average skills and subpar ball winning ability. He's a goal sneak, doubt he becomes anything more.

 

[Dramoth]

Hi Blues fans, Crows fan coming in peace. Serious question that's been brewing in my mind reading the consternation about your lack of an established second KPD: temperature check on Jordon Butts? He might be the least exciting player in the comp, but he's big, pretty young, reasonably athletic, cheap, and Victorian. We arguably have one too many big defenders as it is (pending what happens to Keane). I'm surprised there are never any reports linking him to a Vic club.

What is your opinion of Gollant? I saw his two big highlight videos (6 and 8 goals in the SANFL). Looks to be a good young medium forward.

As far as Butts, I think that he would be a better option than Young and Durdin, S. Has played 75 games? So he would be right in the slot if we wanted to pick up a young defender.

 

[Michael Jezz]

Is that selection or coaching/development?

Both but we have not brought talent in the door. Voss can coach but the football department from fitness, asst coaches to list management are failing him. A case in point is Liam Mcmahon should have been rookied mid season. It will bite us in backside like Lambert & Caminiti. Mcmahon & Caminiti are better than Lemmey and were under our noses

 

[Dramoth]

Thoughts on bringing in Adrian Dodoro to help improve our list?


















I’m kidding!


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Doro]

Motlop is a slow off the mark small forward with average skills and subpar ball winning ability. He's a goal sneak, doubt he becomes anything more.

Ouch. I felt he was developing nicely this time last year, 2024 has been a writer off though. Could use a bit more speed off the mark, I agree.

 

[Soapy V]

Both but we have not brought talent in the door. Voss can coach but the football department from fitness, asst coaches to list management are failing him

If that’s your opinion that’s fine. I struggle to find data that supports this