News 2025 Injuries, Suspensions, and Concussion Protocols

[gutsroy]

Assume draft / indirect C Hall, Gross, E Hewett relevance more than anything, but tbhh am just running up the scoreboard to keep SC fish on his toes

 

[Plugger35]

I might be tempted to trade Murphy Reid to Phillipou if he gets named against Freo, they are around the same price right now.

Sinclair would not be ideal, might wither on the vine if they really throw him forward, but if NAS plays in the middle, can't see how they can risk it.

I can't see Sinclair playing up forward when we are struggling to get the ball inside 50, would be wasting his chip scab gull talent.

 

[gutsroy]

Pou an interesting one. I was frothing him preseason.

Not so clear cut now, hard to trade into midpricers approaching the byes. He'd want to look very good in his first two games to be worth it.

Yeah, trickier, because there are fallen prremos that do cost a bit more but are good value and have much lower risk of needing to be traded out down the line
Depends how he scores, needs to show a bit more than he would have had to as a starting pick, agree

 

[gutsroy]

I might be tempted to trade Murphy Reid to Phillipou if he gets named against Freo, they are around the same price right now.



I can't see Sinclair playing up forward when we are struggling to get the ball inside 50, would be wasting his chip scab gull talent.

Yeah, think it is risky to move your two most reliable avenues out of defence into different lines at the same time in him and Nas. Bit surprising, but wait and see if anything actually comes of it.

 

[Chronz]

I can't see Sinclair playing up forward when we are struggling to get the ball inside 50, would be wasting his chip scab gull talent.

 

[kyri]

Assume draft / indirect C Hall, Gross, E Hewett relevance more than anything, but tbhh am just running up the scoreboard to keep SC fish on his toes

some quality reporting tonight scoops

 

[54Dogs]

Pou an interesting one. I was frothing him preseason.

Not so clear cut now, hard to trade into midpricers approaching the byes. He'd want to look very good in his first two games to be worth it.

Might take him a bit to get going but has zero competition in that midfield to be in the starting 3, still think 90s in the run home. Can prob hold down the flex for a bit after Flynn is moved on

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Might take him a bit to get going but has zero competition in that midfield to be in the starting 3, still think 90s in the run home. Can prob hold down the flex for a bit after Flynn is moved on

Possibly, but as trades get low speculative picks like him are harder to justify. He's PROBABLY two trades.

Could look at him as a cheap bench filler I guess. Will play if fit. Should score ok. McKercher may be another like that.

 

[54Dogs]

Possibly, but as trades get low speculative picks like him are harder to justify. He's PROBABLY two trades.

Could look at him as a cheap bench filler I guess. Will play if fit. Should score ok. McKercher may be another like that.

prob decent cheap bye cover

 

[Duckworthy]

Same thing every year with St Kilda it seems though. They'll throw Sinclair in the middle for a few games, realise he sucks there, then put him back to his usual role where he dominates again.

Don't know how many times they need to try it.

1 more time for about 14 rounds?

 

[54Dogs]

 

[kyri]

even when he is back, you would want to wait until he is on the bubble. not a player even i would jump the gun on.

 

[54Dogs]

even when he is back, you would want to wait until he is on the bubble. not a player even i would jump the gun on.

Even then it feels like one where he could be out at any time with a flare up. He's priced at 71 so hardly bargain basement

 

[kyri]

Even then it feels like one where he could be out at any time with a flare up. He's priced at 71 so hardly bargain basement

agreed. even if he tons in his first game back, I would want to see him back it up again. with his durability, the extra round insurance policy will be well worth it.

 

[SC fish]

When is the Cerra appeal being heard? Tomorrow?

 

[Duckworthy]

When is the Cerra appeal being heard? Tomorrow?

Tomorrow morning around 10am
edit: 10:30 to be precise

 

[rocker_oz33]

some quality reporting tonight scoops

Scoops is over it .
Like flies on a hot turd .
I mean that in a nice way...

 

[gutsroy]

Scoops is over it .
Like flies on a hot turd .
I mean that in a nice way...

SC fish laid down the gauntlet, put the acid on Scoops
Nek minnit

 

[Caztheconquerer]

 

[SloppyJoe]

I'm still dirty at Mills for getting injured before round 0.

I was looking forward to the leg up I would get when all you campaigners picked him.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

 

[rocker_oz33]

Kiddy due back this week .
Pretty sure.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Kiddy due back this week .
Pretty sure.

Playing VFL this week. Might need a few VFL games.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Playing VFL this week. Might need a few VFL games.

I was half right ...