Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Happy to pay that for TDK if it pushes Carlton to band 1.
Say they come 9th, so it would be 9 and 10 pushed out to about 17 and 18 after the corrupt FS and NGA's are taken.
We get one of their few good young players, they get a couple of solid citizens and fall off the cliff for another decade.

All sounds good to me.

Sent from my SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
They actually don't have a first round pick so they might have even more reason to take a band one compo especially if they finish quite far down the ladder.

Hawthorn have their first and would be feeling pretty good about it.
 
What’s the confidence level on NWM re-signing ? I’m not confident at all and the reason is I think it’s inevitable he will go home at some stage in his career

And I think he will be getting 6 year massive money offers from the SA clubs . If he was going to re sign with us it’d be for 2 years max like he did his last one , but I feel given the fact he will have 6 years on the table , he’s not going to sign 6 years for us unfortunately
 
What’s the confidence level on NWM re-signing ? I’m not confident at all and the reason is I think it’s inevitable he will go home at some stage in his career

And I think he will be getting 6 year massive money offers from the SA clubs . If he was going to re sign with us it’d be for 2 years max like he did his last one , but I feel given the fact he will have 6 years on the table , he’s not going to sign 6 years for us unfortunately
Maybe 4 max to take him to free agency
 
They actually don't have a first round pick so they might have even more reason to take a band one compo especially if they finish quite far down the ladder.

Hawthorn have their first and would be feeling pretty good about it.
Oh even better. So their band 1 would be after the first round? About pick 27 [emoji1787][emoji1787][emoji1787][emoji1787][emoji1787]

Sent from my SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Oh even better. So their band 1 would be after the first round? About pick 27 [emoji1787][emoji1787][emoji1787][emoji1787][emoji1787]

Sent from my SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
Haha nah it still goes after what their first round pick would have been, but if they end up coming say 14th and have a pick like 6 but give it to Hawthorn, they will be quite desperate to get their hands on pick 7 which would be available through the TDK compo.
 
What’s the confidence level on NWM re-signing ? I’m not confident at all and the reason is I think it’s inevitable he will go home at some stage in his career

And I think he will be getting 6 year massive money offers from the SA clubs . If he was going to re sign with us it’d be for 2 years max like he did his last one , but I feel given the fact he will have 6 years on the table , he’s not going to sign 6 years for us unfortunately
I think there's almost no chance he leaves before free agency. Port aren't looking a good prospect for the next few years and Crom aren't any better placed than us TBD. His manager will be telling him to sign for another 2 years and the club will be offering to set him up for life. In 2 years time the landscape will look different and he can make a more educated choice as to where his premiership chances sit with each club.
 

Callaghan, from Melbourne’s bayside suburbs, never received a written offer from St Kilda nor did he ever meet Ross Lyon, but $18 million over 10 years was the number and a million-dollar home loan on favourable terms was on the table.

Although nothing was formalised, the proposed home loan would most likely have fallen into the additional services agreement category.
And he still said no 😂. Either the Giants have the greatest culture of all time or we are utterly repellent to players.
 
And he still said no 😂. Either the Giants have the greatest culture of all time or we are utterly repellent to players.
"Callaghan, from Melbourne’s bayside suburbs, never received a written offer from St Kilda nor did he ever meet Ross Lyon, but $18 million over 10 years was the number and a million-dollar home loan on favourable terms was on the table. Although nothing was formalised, the proposed home loan would most likely have fallen into the additional services agreement category."

Well that's an offer isn't it...

never received, not formalised, didn't meet the coach, "likely"...Classic Caro use of words

Good on us for having a crack though and trying to dig ourselves out of this decade long hole. Keep going Pres and team!
 

Remove this Banner Ad

And he still said no [emoji23]. Either the Giants have the greatest culture of all time or we are utterly repellent to players.
Apparently he was worried about expectation given how much money he'd be on

Which would be a fair concern for younger players
 

Callaghan, from Melbourne’s bayside suburbs, never received a written offer from St Kilda nor did he ever meet Ross Lyon, but $18 million over 10 years was the number and a million-dollar home loan on favourable terms was on the table.

Although nothing was formalised, the proposed home loan would most likely have fallen into the additional services agreement category.
A million dollar home loan?
Bloke was going to buy a flat in Brighton when he got back?
 
Hadn’t had a touch before a 7 minute purple patch. Will be very good, but it’s ******ed making calls like this so early
Uncontested possession cos the cats weren't marking him coz he'd done SFA for the rest of the game. Good on him for some good kicking but it wasn't note worthy by any stretch.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Been there, done this…

The top mids were gone by our pick.
Travaglia mooted as a future mid.
Did you forget what Boxshall is looking like bringing to the table?
Garcia stepping up.
Of course…Macrae.

We have to try get elite players if / when they are available and we can afford it. Besides, Ro is not going to be around forever.
Murphy Reid
 
Uncontested possession cos the cats weren't marking him coz he'd done SFA for the rest of the game. Good on him for some good kicking but it wasn't note worthy by any stretch.
A first gamer, kicking 4 goals in 7 mins? Credit where credit is due.

We get excited when Garcia comes on as sub and gets 9 touches.



On CPH2145 using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom