List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

[serial_thrilla]

 

[pK75]

The main restriction is not who he is competing with, it's his tiny size. He really is a midfielder more than a small forward, and you have to be crazy good to make it as an AFL midfielder at his size.

He has yet to really show any indications of being a good small forward at AFL or VFL level. That's not to say he couldn't be good, but he's not being groomed there in the VFL (1 goal in 7 games in 2025, all listed as starting wing/hb) and as such is an unknown quantity.

More likely he would be a smaller version of Switta than a gun goal kicker. Which might still be useful considering Switta's injury history and importance to the side.

But I doubt we can sell him on more opportunity, as I wouldn't have him in our best 23 at full strength. He'd be competing with Dudley to fill an injury vacancy.

Isn’t he Tasmanian as well? Or I am confused with someone else.

Edit, ignore me, who’s the tassie player im thinking of?

Edit 2: McKercher from the same draft went to Roos at pick 2

 

[Taylor]

Reidy has no follow up game, which wouldn't be a problem if he also didn't mostly tap it to his feet. Granted he could just be trying to block space to allow his midfielders to swoop in and clear it but he all to often watches his direct opponent go win the ball at AFL level.

 

[Stinky Lomax]

With Reidy, we just need to upgrade the tv that the kids play their PlayStation on & get what you can for the old unit.

 

[PrancingPony]

I'm starting to understand the people who wanted to keep Knobel over Reidy, maybe you guys were onto something.

 

[Spirit Level]

Is Max Knobel out of contract? Would he ever come back?

 

[malpaso]

LOL -> FOLLOW LIVE: Trade action heats up as Freo deal goes through

 

[go_the_dockers]

Is Max Knobel out of contract? Would he ever come back?

Had injury issues this year.

 

[guidodp15]

People on social media reacting as expected:

"Next Meek"

"We got screwed"

"Should have kept Reidy and traded Darcy"


I genuinely don't understand these people's thought process.

"The streets will for get prime Reidy"

 

[2big2strom]

With Reidy, we just need to upgrade the tv that the kids play their PlayStation on & get what you can for the old unit.

this reminds me of the time I sold the old family tv unit that had been relegated to the shed at cashies so I could afford a carton for leavers...

 

[go_the_dockers]

Walls believes a 2nd round pick is the correct price for Judd McVee



You can here the audio from 30 minute mark.


Sounds like a pick shuffle to upgrade our 2nd round pick is likely.

 

[Barnabus]

You know if you only watch his highlights he looks quite good.

 

[Sewell21]

well after the latest chatter about sebbas Instagram follows I went and had a look myself...and even more recent than Simpkin is a follow of one P Cripps

Did he unfollow Jai?

 

[Docker82]

People on social media reacting as expected:

"Next Meek"

"We got screwed"

"Should have kept Reidy and traded Darcy"


I genuinely don't understand these people's thought process.

Doubt these people actually know much about footy especially the players outside the team that plays each week.

Their process doesn't matter. Neither does mine for that matter but I've seen enough of Reidy at Peel to know he isn't the next Meek. At best he's the next Tom Campbell but in reality he's probably more like Scott Jones except was given a second opportunity. Reckon he's delisted end of yhe contract he's just signed.

 

[TheMcManusNose]

People on social media reacting as expected:

"Next Meek"

"We got screwed"

"Should have kept Reidy and traded Darcy"


I genuinely don't understand these people's thought process.

At this point I'm fairly convinced that, even on random afl pages, most actually aren't real people.

 

[mattis117]

Yep I'd give our first for Rogers. Get it don't Wallsy

 

[Cobbler]

Walls believes a 2nd round pick is the correct price for Judd McVee



You can here the audio from 30 minute mark.


Sounds like a pick shuffle to upgrade our 2nd round pick is likely.

Yet trying to tie Port’s pick 28 in the Brodie deal gets laughed at…

There’s easily a world where we do Brodie, 33 and 44 for 28 and say 66

It’s practically paying Port to take him off our hands.

Anyway, enough speculating from me.

 

[Piggy Smalls]

Mannagh really should’ve been the one when we lost Schultz. We need a pressure forward and you’re more likely to get that from a mature age

I'm pretty sure we thought Mannagh was our man. Geelong weren't expected to pick him so early, and he's since come out and said we were chasing him the hardest.
Imagine if we had him and Bruce on our half forward line!

 

[largebus]

Twomey saying clubs are enquiring about Daicos.
I could ring up Collingwood's membership dept and ask about him and they would report it as club enquiring.

 

[Lach72]

Fraicos confirmed

 

[serial_thrilla]

Twomey saying clubs are enquiring about Daicos.
I could ring up Collingwood's membership dept and ask about him and they would report it as club enquiring.

They're really struggling for content right now.

 

[Stinky Lomax]

this reminds me of the time I sold the old family tv unit that had been relegated to the shed at cashies so I could afford a carton for leavers...

Pretty sure that’s what we got.

 

[Spirit Level]

I'm pretty sure we thought Mannagh was our man. Geelong weren't expected to pick him so early, and he's since come out and said we were chasing him the hardest.
Imagine if we had him and Bruce on our half forward line!

Also imagine if we hadn't given away a future first for an out of contract Jackson

Could've had Curtin as well.

It's fun to imagine.

And now I'm sad

 

[mayne iac]

Yep I'd give our first for Rogers. Get it don't Wallsy

No Chance he's going anywhere

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

No Chance he's going anywhere

I wouldn't be THAT strong. GC will cycle through players more than most because of the academy feeding talent. Its possible they want all their academy picks this year and are coming up short on points.

Humphrey is too good to let go for that, Rogers isnt.

 

[Taylor]

No Chance he's going anywhere

AFL might not like first round GC academy players leaving after their first contract for opportunities.