Opinion 2025 Player X v Y v Z

[Thuggee_Cult]

I need to turf out Roberts or Houston to bring in ButtersSexy.

Which underperformer do I dump?

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

I need to turf out Roberts or Houston to bring in ButtersSexy.

Which underperformer do I dump?

I turfed Roberts. SO there is at least 130 incoming.

Flip a coin

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

I turfed Roberts. SO there is at least 130 incoming.

Flip a coin

Oh I hear you, don’t you worry, whoever I turf will kill it for the rest of the year. Nothing surer.

I’ve had both since round 1 and they have been frustrating owns.

Am leaning towards Roberts going, Blakey and Bice are stealing his chips, Houston looks like he will explode

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Oh I hear you, don’t you worry, whoever I turf will kill it for the rest of the year. Nothing surer.

I’ve had both since round 1 and they have been frustrating owns.

Am leaning towards Roberts going, Blakey and Bice are stealing his chips, Houston looks like he will explode

Mills back to also take some luster away

 

[SC fish]

Houston looks like he will explode

...and get four weeks for it?

 

[JuddgementDay]

I've got a few options to trade this week, but the net results after two weeks are:

Warner + McKercher
VS
Roberts + JHF

So which pair are better?

 

[King Max]

S Butler or J Martin?

Team is complete, this is for the long haul….

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

S Butler or J Martin?

Team is complete, this is for the long haul….

Hawks seem bullish on Butler...

Martin is made of tissue paper.

 

[Test Tickle]

S Butler or J Martin?

Team is complete, this is for the long haul….

Yeah thinking the same

Edit: I think if Martin is playing and not Sub i think I'll grab him, then maybe Butler next week as I need to make some cash somehow, with only 9 trades left.

 

[No eye deer]

Who to kick to the kerb?
Rankine vs Trac.
Playing for league.

 

[Scythe]

Who to kick to the kerb?
Rankine vs Trac.
Playing for league.

Rankine is better to watch, but Trac has better role security and a higher floor (except for the mare last week).

Depends on what the extra cash does for you

 

[No eye deer]

Rankine is better to watch, but Trac has better role security and a higher floor (except for the mare last week).

Depends on what the extra cash does for you

The cash will help, but I’m getting JHF and Darcy in the next two weeks either way.
Just means I have to get Darcy this week if I trade Rankine, as I can’t afford JHF.

I’ve decided to go Rankine to Darcy. Darcy has the Tigers this week and 5 weeks without a ton for Rankine just doesn’t cut it.
I’ll forgive Tracs score last week with the tag.

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Who to kick to the kerb?
Rankine vs Trac.
Playing for league.

Have the same conundrum, I'm ditching Trac.

 

[No eye deer]

Have the same conundrum, I'm ditching Trac.

Well, one of us will make the right decision.
Or both of us
Or none of us!

 

[BustrGonad]

Who would you rather as bench cover for the rest of the season: Z. Johnson or A. Clarke?

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

JHF vs MacRae for the last forward spot?

 

[King Max]

JHF vs MacRae for the last forward spot?

Check Macrae first 3 SC final games. Nth, Tigers, Ess. Lock him in.

 

[Dundalis]

Who's the better rookie to keep likely rest of the year, Matt Carroll or Angus Clarke? Need to trade one to facilitate fully upgraded team.

 

[JuddgementDay]

I’m willing to burn one final trade, so which combo?

Out: Bolton vs Rankine
In: Darcy vs JHF

 

[SC fish]

Who's the better rookie to keep likely rest of the year, Matt Carroll or Angus Clarke? Need to trade one to facilitate fully upgraded team.

No idea really but trading Carroll OUT will provide more funds if you can wait a week or two

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

I’m willing to burn one final trade, so which combo?

Out: Bolton vs Rankine
In: Darcy vs JHF

Out: Bolton (FLOG)
In: Darcy

 

[MacStradbroke]

I’m willing to burn one final trade, so which combo?

Out: Bolton vs Rankine
In: Darcy vs JHF

Bolton > Darcy for me too.

 

[St Steady]

serong or brayshaw for final mid premo

 

[SC fish]

serong or brayshaw for final mid premo

Tough choice! A few weeks back it was Brayshaw but Serong has outscored him recently. Dunno who gets the tag or scores better from here. Toss a coin?

 

[Test Tickle]

Will Boxshall get a run this week?