Traded #22: Jake Carlisle - Pt.1 - Traded with some other stuff for pick 5, 24 and a Bird (cont in Part 2)

[Marley10]

Not to be a dickhead, but where has Carlisle confirmed this? To my knowledge only Dodoro has said it

So what? This is the word.

He still prefers St Kilda, but if a deal cannot be done, then off to Hawthorn he goes. They've maintained from the start that he will not go to the PSD

 

[toxic]

3. Going to Hawthorn if St Kilda can't put in a reasonable offer. That's what Carlisle confirmed

Link to carlisle confirmation?

 

[Kingofthehill]

Not to be a dickhead, but where has Carlisle confirmed this? To my knowledge only Dodoro has said it

Same can be said for everything we just read

 

[TheGreatBarryB]

Not to be a dickhead, but where has Carlisle confirmed this? To my knowledge only Dodoro has said it

Where have either Jake or manager said Hawks are not an option?

 

[Donakebab]

Who the hell is this Brian Speaking flog and why do St Kilda fans take everything he says as gospel. Last year he was claiming Jeremy Cameron was a certainty to go to the Saints. The guy doesn't know shit.

 

[rumply]

Not to be a dickhead,

too late

 

[toxic]

Clarko Said it after they spoke?

Clarko did NOT...I REPEAT DID NOT say he has spoken with Jake

Ffs

 

[rumply]

Cant see Hawks waiting forever don't be surprised if the Hawks withdraw their offer.

why?, they are probably still up to their neck in this.

 

[habib1984]

Clarko Said it after they spoke?

Clarko two short to reach phone must of email

 

[Kingofthehill]

Link to carlisle confirmation?

Likewise all we just read about what Carlisle wants .

 

[Foxx]

You do realise that Essendon have no academy of F/S picks so it's entirely irrelevant?

If the Hawks can't get Carlisle I'm sure they'd be kind enough to.give you 15 and 18 for 4.

You'd obviously be pumped to take that right?

No, but considering we already have 4 I would rather take picks 15 and 18 than 5

 

[toxic]

Ok, put yourself in Carlisle's shoes. Last day of trading...no deal....Hawks in your ear...Jake we'll look after you. Hodgey calls...Jake we want you mate.

do you think he's going to say...nah boys i'll take my chances in the PSD.? Doubt it.

For 700k ..4 years worth of extra cash reportedly would that influence his decision

 

[saintsrfreak]

Where have either Jake or manager said Hawks are not an option?

I'm not sure proving a negative is how these things work

 

[TheGreatBarryB]

Clarko did NOT...I REPEAT DID NOT say he has spoken with Jake

Ffs

Well it would be very very easy for Carlisle team to simply say..."Jake does not wish to play at Hawthorn".

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

why?, they are probably still up to their neck in this.

Hope so.

 

[rumply]

Clarko did NOT...I REPEAT DID NOT say he has spoken with Jake

Ffs

it was reported everywhere that he did...ffs

 

[TheGreatBarryB]

I'm not sure proving a negative is how these things work

It's not a negative. Ryder made it clear that only interested in Port and said no Bris no GWS. It's easy to do.

 

[yodellinhank]

If, as reported, Jake has confirmed his intent to be a saint what options are there?
1) trade with bombers
2) psd

Is there another option?

3) Doesn't want the uncertainty of PSD and ending up at Carlton - relents to opening his options up.

If it were as simple as players choice there'd be no trade period and everyone would go DFA.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

Saints fans can hold onto the PSD for however long they want, it won't be going to that.

I'm glad we're dictating the terms. I would not be happy if we were getting pushed around by saints of all clubs

 

[toxic]

it was reported everywhere that he did...ffs

Clarko himself said.

I will not go into any details

Neither confirm nor deny

He said nothing

Which to you means they spoke at length over multiple martinis
Which means to saints they haven't spoken

Zero confirmation clarkson spoke to jake

 

[caboose]

Ahem.

Where's the headline of "Saints struggling to let go" on the AFL website?!

 

[Charliebrow 16]

I think until such time as Carlisle or his manager come out and states publicly that he has no desire to play for Hawthorn, that option is still in play. And considering we've verbally all but agreed to an offer from Hawthorn that we deem to be adequate, St Kilda still need to come to the table and trump it. Simple.

 

[doug85]

The saints have made an offer but won't reveal it out of respect for Essendon.

 

[MarkG]

Just interested to know what Carlisle would've been on per year at Essendon ?
Is there no chance Worsfold could talk him around to re sign ?

I hope so. He was a critical part of our spine. With the WADA stuff over and a new ex premiership coach with the reigns, I believe we would have seen the real Carlisle. Gutted when he said that he wanted to leave.

 

[CBombers17]

The saints have made an offer but won't reveal it out of respect for Essendon.

hahahahahahahahaha