2nd Preliminary Final discussion

[SriLankanCat]

Cant wait gonna be awesome!

In: SJ, Rooke, Mumford?

Out: Hogan? Blake? Byrnes maybe?

 

[bulletproof]

Re: Preliminary Final

Hogan and Stokes. Great game from Wojcinski today. Delighted with him.

 

[SriLankanCat]

Re: Preliminary Final

Stokes was ok today.

Byrnes' poace was important today but who else do we drop

WOjsinski was terrific.

Also liked Varcoes chase

Hawkin was a bit dissapointing, did a fewgood things but that was it

 

[TassieCat]

Re: Preliminary Final

Byrnes out...HELL NO! For me the one to miss should be Stokes if (and its a big big if) Stevie J gets up!

 

[magic_johnson!]

Re: Preliminary Final

Hunt said Stevie J was running well at training this week and should be back for the prelim.

 

[hamG]

Re: Preliminary Final

I doubt Stokes will be dropped, he did his role of staying close to goal and running with Harbrow and was good at both.

 

[ant0s]

Re: Preliminary Final

IN - SJ, Rooke
OUT - Hogan, Stokes

Surely Wojak has secured his finals seat with a great game today?

 

[alfy!]

Re: Preliminary Final

Stokes was great today, so can't really see him being dropped. But Hogan was also superb. Very tough decision.

Blake is the one they need to get out of the team though.

 

[Poetic Justice]

Re: Preliminary Final

Hogan superb? what game were you watching??

 

[alfy!]

Re: Preliminary Final

For a player with his role, he played a great game today, and did everything that is asked of him.

 

[Scuderia]

Re: Preliminary Final

For a player with his role, he played a great game today, and did everything that is asked of him.

Was he tagging? I barely noticed him myself.

 

[alfy!]

Re: Preliminary Final

Interesting that others have a different opinion of him today. I thought his first half was great and he contributed in the second half too. I have never been a big fan of him either.

 

[Magnum]

Re: Preliminary Final

God I wish Hawkins could live up to his potential in the big games.

Glad to have a week off. Glad Chappy made it through.

Hogan I like but was pretty sloppy today. Rooke in for him.

Not sure who gets dropped for Jonno (assuming he's right)... Stokes?

Also Blake out, Mumford in....

Thank Christ we have Scarlett...

 

[SriLankanCat]

Re: Preliminary Final

I feel for Blake but i want Mumford back in

 

[Tomozaurus]

Re: Preliminary Final

Personally, I think:

In: SJ, Rooke, Mumford
Out: Hogan, Byrnes, Blake

Hawkins needs to stand up big.

 

[Gaz_Brownlow]

Re: Preliminary Final

Surely Mumford.... Is he playing in the VFL? What are peoples thoughts of Blake and Ottens game today?

No given with Max or SJ, but you would assume they would be ok. Unfortunately you have to drop Hogan. NO way can we drop Wojack....two fantastic games in a row, and he really gives us a new dynamic + he is quite hard at the contest. Between Varcoe, Byrnes, Stokes really.....probably Stokes at this stage.

What did people make of the Selwood incident? Possible suspension?

 

[mac_cat]

Re: Preliminary Final

Surely Mumford.... Is he playing in the VFL? What are peoples thoughts of Blake and Ottens game today?

What did people make of the Selwood incident? Possible suspension?

Blake - his one strength is his tap ruck-work and didn't even do well at that today. A liability around the ground, he's on thin ground to save his spot.

Nothing in the Selwood incident(s), he got shoulder as well as the head, no malice intended.

 

[Pollywaffle]

Re: Preliminary Final

What did people make of the Selwood incident? Possible suspension?

Will be looked at I'm sure
He seemed a little off his game as well

 

[Gaz_Brownlow]

Re: Preliminary Final

Nice...on Selwood i mean.

All reports good at this stage on SJ, and you would think Rooke was close today. HOwever as i said, no gurantees.

Hopefully Mumford plays in the 2's and dominates and makes it an easy selection - against Collingwood, St Kilda or Adelaide - we need an additional physical presence from our ruckman, we could get away with it against the Dogs, but the Mummy is on the cards for the others.

Any thoughts on Otto's game?

 

[AidanNelson2009]

Re: Preliminary Final

In: S. Johnson, M. Rooke
Out: S. Hogan, S. Burns

Great game today by the cats altough we only played 2 great quarters which were the 1st and 3rd. Our 2nd and 4th quarters were absolutly terrible, don't know what was going on but the win was the important thing and now we get a weeks break which is good.
I think that we will be playing Collingwood in the Preliminary final, the saints will beat them tomorrow and the Pies will beat the crows, it's going to be great finals series, there are potentially 4 sides that can win the flag, if not 5, with the way the crows are going at the moment.

 

[watermelonslice]

Re: Preliminary Final

I'm extremely worried about Selwood's two coat hangers. Bateman got a week for doing something pretty similar to Lloyd.

 

[AFaiL]

Re: Preliminary Final

I cant find he thread to bump, but lol @ the bulldogs 'wanting' to play geelong.

i said n that thread 'be careful what you wish you'

they learnt

well done today guys, showed the media morons not to change their minds with the wind

i hope we follow suit tomorrow

 

[AFaiL]

Re: Preliminary Final

I'm extremely worried about Selwood's two coat hangers. Bateman got a week for doing something pretty similar to Lloyd.

Nah he will be fine, just sloppy tackles

Batement went the charge

 

[Geelongfor2008]

Re: Preliminary Final

Hogan superb? what game were you watching??

He was good did a good intercept early on to set up a goal

 

[goodoldcats]

Re: Preliminary Final

Blake - his one strength is his tap ruck-work and didn't even do well at that today. A liability around the ground, he's on thin ground to save his spot.

Nothing in the Selwood incident(s), he got shoulder as well as the head, no malice intended.

blake had the chance to be the third man up in the backline a couple of times but just stood there 5m away