30 ronin phantom

[Yojimbo]

Great work. Can't see North using picks 16 & 25 on KPP. Our 1st I expext will be a mid and possibly 2nd pick will take KPP.

I agree with you, i had to find a home for Peter Wright based on needs
which was difficult i did the Petrie/Wright like for like which was easy
rather than necessary.

 

[Jell]

Great work. Can't see North using picks 16 & 25 on KPP. Our 1st I expext will be a mid and possibly 2nd pick will take KPP.

Depends on the quality of the tall. Wright at 16 would be a steal and would replace Petrie in the coming years. North are still too reliant on an ageing forward structure with no rock solid young forwards coming through (but potential in the likes of Black, Wood and Brown). Likewise defence isn't a strength, some good honest contributors, but an up and coming young KPD would be handy. On the flip side your midfield is brimming with young talent, and you're a better chance of turning speculative late round mids into something than a late round KPP. I think you can stretch your mids further than your KPP stocks at the moment, so if someone like Wright fell in your lap, you'd be crazy not to take him.

 

[Yojimbo]

Update 14/11/2014 without bios
#1- Christian Petracca #2- Angus Brayshaw #3- Patrick McCartin
#4- Jarrod Pickett #5- Jayden Laverde #6-Jake Lever
#7- Hugh Goddard #8- Kyle Langford #9- Darcy Moore
#10- Liam Duggan

#11- Nakia Cockatoo #12- Jordan De Goey #13- Paul Ahern
#14- Sam Durdin #15- Caleb Marchbank #16- Peter Wright
#17- Connor Blakely #18-Isaac Heeney #19- Lachie Weller
#20- Jarrod Garlett

#21- Tom Lamb #22- Reece McKenzie #23- Tyler Kietel
#24- Jack Steele #25- Connor Menadue #26- Brayden Maynard
#27- Dean Gore #28- Corey Ellis #29- Ed Vickers-Willis
#30- Damien Cavka

Ten days on version two after contemplation mainly based
around Freo not needing another KPD at pick 13.

 

[Cringle]

Update 14/11/2014 without bios
#1- Christian Petracca #2- Angus Brayshaw #3- Patrick McCartin
#4- Jarrod Pickett #5- Jayden Laverde #6-Jake Lever
#7- Hugh Goddard #8- Kyle Langford #9- Darcy Moore
#10- Liam Duggan

#11- Nakia Cockatoo #12- Jordan De Goey #13- Paul Ahern
#14- Sam Durdin #15- Caleb Marchbank #16- Peter Wright
#17- Connor Blakely #18-Isaac Heeney #19- Lachie Weller
#20- Jarrod Garlett

#21- Tom Lamb #22- Reece McKenzie #23- Tyler Kietel
#24- Jack Steele #25- Connor Menadue #26- Brayden Maynard
#27- Dean Gore #28- Corey Ellis #29- Ed Vickers-Willis
#30- Damien Cavka

Ten days on version two after contemplation mainly based
around Freo not needing another KPD at pick 13.

Carlton #19 - Lachlan Weller
Carlton #28 - Corey Ellis

Yes please!

 

[Yojimbo]

Carlton #19 - Lachlan Weller
Carlton #28 - Corey Ellis

Yes please!

In the second version i tried to identify needs but those small mids
are hard to place, fingers crossed it works out well for Carlton.

 

[Shadow Man]

Doubt Freo will pass on Durdin if available.

 

[Yojimbo]

Doubt Freo will pass on Durdin if available.

Durdin is my personal favorite among the KPD's in the draft the only reason
i went for a mid instead was the Freo list does have good depth in the KPD
area. McPharlin, Dawson, Silvagni, Pearce, Johnson, and Smith and
Vandeleur as rookies i felt was plenty of coverage. You are right though
Durdin is a promising talent, what do you think of the idea of taking KPF
Reece McKenzie?

 

[Shadow Man]

Durdin is my personal favorite among the KPD's in the draft the only reason
i went for a mid instead was the Freo list does have good depth in the KPD
area. McPharlin, Dawson, Silvagni, Pearce, Johnson, and Smith and
Vandeleur as rookies i felt was plenty of coverage. You are right though
Durdin is a promising talent, what do you think of the idea of taking KPF
Reece McKenzie?

I don't really know enough about McKenzie to comment, I would have thought either Durdin, Lever or Goddard if available would be on the money. However wouldn't be entirely surprised to see them reach for Garlett who has a sublime bag of tricks and the potential to be a game breaker. I think he may go earlier than most are predicting.

 

[Yojimbo]

I don't really know enough about McKenzie to comment, I would have thought either Durdin, Lever or Goddard if available would be on the money. However wouldn't be entirely surprised to see them reach for Garlett who has a sublime bag of tricks and the potential to be a game breaker. I think he may go earlier than most are predicting.

Reece McKenzie 196 cm 100 kg power forward
His best TAC game this year he kicked 10 goals 4 off 19 disposals and took
13 marks most of which were contested.There is a fair gap between his
best and worst performances, but the chance to learn under Pavlich
would be a bonus. Jarrod Garlett has a lot of positives his size could be
the only thing that sees him at the end of the first round.