Autopsy AFL 2023 Round 7 - Dogs v Hawks Sat April 29th 4:35pm AEST (Marvel)

Who will win and by how much?

  • Dogs by a goal or less

    Votes: 1 2.3%
  • Hawks by a goal or less

    Votes: 1 2.3%
  • Dogs by 7 - 20

    Votes: 10 23.3%
  • Hawks by 7 - 20

    Votes: 5 11.6%
  • Dogs by a lot

    Votes: 24 55.8%
  • Hawks by a lot

    Votes: 2 4.7%
  • Draw

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    43
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Hawks just don’t have enough players to rotate through the midfield at this stage. Probably the reason opposition midfields get on top in the second half.
Worpel, Newcombe, ward, day, nash, McKenzie, Moore, mcdonald is more than enough midfielders, the problem is inexperience. Give these guys 3 seasons together and they’ll be able to stand up all game.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

You should know better than me... but think you lost McEvoy, Gunston, Sheils, Mitchell & O'Meara.

Gained Amon.

Big net loss of experience.
Mcevoy retired
Gunston asked to be traded - wanted to keep him
Shiels retired then came back for clarko (not setting the world on fire either)
Mitchell has turned his form around
Omaera has been useless for freo
 
Mcevoy retired
Gunston asked to be traded - wanted to keep him
Shiels retired then came back for clarko (not setting the world on fire either)
Mitchell has turned his form around
Omaera has been useless for freo
Sure... my point was you lost plenty of experience!

My point stands as a fact.
 
Hawks fans hate marvel. There will be plenty of room.

Low to mid 30's.


Fun enough experience but...

College Accuse GIF
 
Interesting that English named in the best on the AFL site despite losing to Reeves in both possessions (15 to 11) and Hitouts by a long way (43 to 30). Reeves not mentioned at all in the write up at all.

Wonder if Damo did that one?
 
Interesting that English named in the best on the AFL site despite losing to Reeves in both possessions (15 to 11) and Hitouts by a long way (43 to 30). Reeves not mentioned at all in the write up at all.

Wonder if Damo did that one?
Thought Reeves got the better of him which was nice to see
 
Interesting that English named in the best on the AFL site despite losing to Reeves in both possessions (15 to 11) and Hitouts by a long way (43 to 30). Reeves not mentioned at all in the write up at all.

Wonder if Damo did that one?
They write the articles in advance then autofill the names
 
Not bad from the hawks today. We couldn't win a centre clearance until half way through the 2nd. Had they taken their chances a bit more and not made some dumb kicks down the wing in the 2nd half, it would have been a close game. They're a lot better with lewis up forward.
 
Hawks have a future. Just need to start making the most of their clearances.

Didn't notice the umpiring too much while watching the game. 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Hawks have a future. Just need to start making the most of their clearances.

Didn't notice the umpiring too much while watching the game. 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️

You'd probably notice it if the Hawks got 18 and Dogs got 10.

We will improve when our forward line get more time together. Lewis will improve things a lot in a few games when he is fit and skills are up to par. Ramsden will also find his place.
 
You'd probably notice it if the Hawks got 18 and Dogs got 10.

We will improve when our forward line get more time together. Lewis will improve things a lot in a few games when he is fit and skills are up to par. Ramsden will also find his place.

To be honest mate I only really notice umpiring when dudes are on here having a sook because then it becomes a focus
 
To be honest mate I only really notice umpiring when dudes are on here having a sook because then it becomes a focus

Because your team routinely is looked after.

Do you notice how Patrick Cripps always throws instead of handballs?

That is literally your entire midfield. Bont also never gets pinged HTB. No matter how much prior he has and no matter how badly he disposes or doesnt even bother.
 
We had a stinker first half. Luckily came up against a pretty ordinary team. If Hawks nuffs think anyone needs a good ride with umpires to beat their side they’re delusional.
 
Because your team routinely is looked after.

Do you notice how Patrick Cripps always throws instead of handballs?

That is literally your entire midfield. Bont also never gets pinged HTB. No matter how much prior he has and no matter how badly he disposes or doesnt even bother.

“Melt melt melt melt melt”
 
Because your team routinely is looked after.

Do you notice how Patrick Cripps always throws instead of handballs?

That is literally your entire midfield. Bont also never gets pinged HTB. No matter how much prior he has and no matter how badly he disposes or doesnt even bother.
Bont has had holding the ball freekicks against him this year.

Dogs also sit second last on the freekick ladder.

This theory is stupid and just an excuse at this point
 
Sure... my point was you lost plenty of experience!

My point stands as a fact.
You said we traded out all of our experienced players though, which we didn’t.

McEvoy and Shiels retired, Gunston walked to another team. We traded Mitchell (going well) & O’Meara (going poorly).

Not sure you have a grasp on the meaning of the word ‘fact’.
 
You said we traded out all of our experienced players though, which we didn’t.

McEvoy and Shiels retired, Gunston walked to another team. We traded Mitchell (going well) & O’Meara (going poorly).

Not sure you have a grasp on the meaning of the word ‘fact’.
You traded out more experience than you traded in... even accounting for retirements.

Really not hard to follow that you have replaced us with the youngest & most inexperienced list.
 
2 goals up half way through the 4th quarter and we are a bunch of mummy's boys...

Doesnt say much about the Dogs does it.
Obviously a dogs fan who has forgotten their last 40 minutes of the 2021 GF.
Melbourne turned up the heat and the dogs utterly turned it up big time on the biggest day of the year.
 
Back
Top