Andrew Gaff vs Steele Sidebottom

[Gaben]

Gaff by a fair bit, even though I don't mind Sidey. Sidebottom lacks weapons though, his kicking doesn't have penetration and he is slow as a wet week. Smart player though and reads the play exceptionally well. He is an upgraded version of Brent Stanton at the end of the day without the tendency to go completely missing when the heat turns up.

 

[Collingwoodity]

Gaff by a fair bit, even though I don't mind Sidey. Sidebottom lacks weapons though, his kicking doesn't have penetration and he is slow as a wet week. Smart player though and reads the play exceptionally well. He is an upgraded version of Brent Stanton at the end of the day without the tendency to go completely missing when the heat turns up.

Gaff will be better and probably is now... but sidebottom went missing in grand finals 2011 and pf 2012. he was outstanding in both gfs in 2010.

 

[Off Tap]

Gaff will be better and probably is now... but sidebottom went missing in grand finals 2011 and pf 2012. he was outstanding in both gfs in 2010.

Really surprised with the amount of Gaff love here considering he has only 2 years behind him.

Obviously wouldn't swap Gaff however Sidey is all class.