Remove this Banner Ad

Andrew Mackie

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

E

edward_woodward

Debutant
Joined
Sep 27, 2006
Posts
82
Reaction score
0
Location
hobart
AFL Club
GWS
fair dinkum im watching the catsvdogs game, andrew mackie would have to be one of the most overrated footballers in the afl, he is a shocker, everytime ive seen him within 10 metres of the ball he loses his footing and when he has the ball his handballing is bordering on pathetic ive never seen a bloke miss as many targets as him
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Enright, Chappy, Selwood and the two Abletts deserve to be paid, the rest should donate their pay packets to the Good Friday appeal.

If we play like this for the rest of the season, it'll be a looooooong year.
 
I disagree about Mackie being overrated. Surely no-one in the right mind has ever rated him to begin with.
 
i have never rated mackie but most of the media do, i dont think brad ottens has ever held a contested mark in his life
 
Mackie has to be one of the softest players in the AFL. Too many times Mackie chooses to go for the chest mark rather than attack the ball with his hands outstretched. Then there's the constant fumbling at the most crucial moments. I can't believe we used a first round pick to sign this gutless kid.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

mackie gives half ass efforts.. no physical presence

though he did kick a nice goal Q4

djerrkura would have given his best
 
Its round one, god some of you on here seem to be throwing away your membership. I remember a lot of threads saying this kid is going to be a star last yr, now you calling for his head. Its a joke really. Next week when he plays well, u all will be saying how much of a gun he is. This is me laughing at you all HA HA.
 
Big Nasty said:
Different side this year my a$$.
Ling and Gardiner are blooty duds.
Click to expand...

Again i can only listen on the radio, and i havent seen the game, but these to did alright today, I know they both missed tgts ocasionally, but they where not on there Pat Malone there. They should both play next week
 
Mackie is clearly talented - but he shows it only sporadically. Another under-performer! I just do not know how you get 'fire in the belly' into a player like this - he's no longer a kid either!
 
Rustybugles said:
Mackie is clearly talented - but he shows it only sporadically. Another under-performer! I just do not know how you get 'fire in the belly' into a player like this - he's no longer a kid either!
Click to expand...
Start playing him on the wing, where he played his best footy last year. Not on the half back flank.
 
Presumably, from experience, I'm one of a few Mackie fans around here, but even yesterday's effort is hard to excuse.

His negatives (the fumbling hands, the hit-and-miss disposal, and yes, the softness) are gradually pushing the positives (the occasional moments of class, run, and "hit" kicks) right out of line.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom