Best Squad

[Tarkyn_24]

An AFL Draft and trading game has recently concluded, and we invite you to vote on which squad you would prefer to have control of as a coach.

Hopefully this causes some discussion, and a favourable outcome for me


Team A



B: Campbell Brown - Ben Rutten - Graham Johncock
HB: Jason Gram - Adam Hunter - Sam Fisher
C: Nick Dal Santo - Sam Mitchell - Nathan Foley
HF: Brett Ebert - Jonathan Brown - Daniel Motlop
F: Corey Jones - Cam Mooney - Nathan G.Brown

FOLL: Brad Ottens - Daniel Kerr - Gary Ablett Jnr

BENCH: Matthew Leuenberger - Matthew Priddis - Cameron Ling - Michael Firrito

OTHERS:
Adam McPhee
Marc Murphy
Jarryd Roughead
Joel Selwood
Scott Pendlebury
Josh Drummond
Luke Ball
Nathan Jones
Nathan Thompson
Daniel Wells
Heath Scotland


Team B

B: Darren Milburn (GEE) - Dustin Fletcher (ESS) - Leo Barry (SYD)
HB: Lindsay Gilbee (WBD) - Matt Egan (GEE) - Andrew McLeod (ADE)
C: Brett Deledio (RCH) - Chris Judd (CAR) - Adam Cooney (WBD)
HF: Steve Johnson (GEE) - Lance Franklin (HAW) - Brent Harvey (KAN)
F: Aaron Davey (MEL) - Matthew Lloyd (ESS) - Alwyn Davey (ESS)
FOLL: Dean Cox (WCE) - Adam Goodes (SYD) - Jimmy Bartel (GEE)
I/C: Jeff White (MLB) - Dale Thomas (COLL) - Corey Enright (GEE) - Danyle Pearce (PTA)

Others :-
Leigh Montagna (STK)
Nick Stevens (CAR)
Graham Polak (RCH)
Adam Simpson (KAN)
Ashley Hansen (WCE)
Darren Jolly (SYD)
Jordan Lewis (HAW)
Chris Knights (ADE)
David Neitz (MLB)

Team C

B: M Scarlett - D Glass - A Carazzo
HB: N Malceski - C Bolton - J Adcock
C: J Corey - S West - B Goddard
HF: A Didak - S Lucas - A Embley
F: T Cloke - B Johnson - R O"Keefe
R: J Charman - C Cornes - L Power
INT: J Koschitzke - M Richardson - B McLean - A Sandilands

EME:
B Stanton
T Croad
J Sherman
S Gumbleton
Q Lynch
T Kennelly
R Robertson
H O'Brien
D Cross
C Bruce

Team D
FB: Roger Hayden (Freo)/ Brian Harris (WBD) / Tarkyn Lockyer (CWood)
HB: Heath Shaw (CWood) / Joel Bowden (Rich) / Shaun Burgoyne (Port)
C: Lenny Hayes (Stk) / Simon Black (Bris) / Kane Cornes (Port)
HF: Nick Riewolt (Stk) / Matthew Pavlich (Freo) / Scott Thompson (Adel)
FF: Jeff Farmer (Freo)/ Brendon Fevola (Carl) / Barry Hall (Syd)
R: Hamish McIntosh (Roos) / Luke Hodge (Haw) / Dane Swan (CWood)
I/C: Brendon Lade (Port) / Michael Johnson (Freo) / Simon Goodwin (Adel) / Jarrad Waite (Carl)
EMG: Matthew Maguire (Stk) / Brett Kirk (Syd) / Paul Chapman (Geel)

Extras
Brad Sewell
Luke McPharlin
Robert Murphy
Jarrad Brennan
Grant Birchall
Jess Sinclair
Tyson Edwards

 

[Colin D'Cops]

Team B looks the goods, it has a midfield full of Brownlow medallists with Goodes, Judd & Bartel....It has an exciting CHF in Franklin, the best FF in the league in Lloyd, the best CHB in the league in Egan, the best ruckman in the league in big Cox & the All Australian half forwards in Steve Johnson & Brent Harvey.....They have the two Davey brothers with Alwyn & Aaron, and those little dynamos can run any defenders off their legs....All their backs six are All Australians, and they would be able to hold any forward line to minimal goals....Oh I didn't realise, that's my team....!

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Team B looks the goods, it has a midfield full of Brownlow medallists with Goodes, Judd & Bartel....It has an exciting CHF in Franklin, the best FF in the league in Lloyd, the best CHB in the league in Egan, the best ruckman in the league in big Cox & the All Australian half forwards in Steve Johnson & Brent Harvey.....They have the two Davey brothers with Alwyn & Aaron, and those little dynamos can run any defenders off their legs....All their backs six are All Australians, and they would be able to hold any forward line to minimal goals....Oh I didn't realise, that's my team....!

They all have different strengths, but I can't go past a defence which has Kosi, Scarlett, Glass, Bolton and C Cornes all rotating through with Adcock, Malceski and Carazzo rebounding.

 

[Sainters08]

geez i tell ya wot. if Team A doesnt win theres sometin wrong...!

Check out the Midfield with Dal Santo, Mitchell, Foley, Kerr and Ablett Jnr. And then off the bench is Priddis + Ling, its unstoppable!

awesome back-line + forward-line as well.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

OK, now can we have some impartial discussion from someone not involved?

 

[dtm06]

Team C. It'll be too hard for any other team to score against that defence. team a has an awesome midfield but C is good enough to get it over the line.

 

[DOCKER MAN]

In team D McPharlin should be well within the 22 at CHB

 

[Sainters08]

gee i wonder who DOCKERMAN voted for....?

* Cough * Team D * COUGH *

bias much?

 

[larkis]

I wonder who Sainters08 votes for .....?
I believe it would be Team D, why would it be any other team?

 

[Tarkyn_24]

I wonder who Sainters08 votes for .....?
I believe it would be Team D, why would it be any other team?

I like my defensive rotations.

Cough. <Glass, Scarlett, Koschitzke, Goddard, Adcock, C Bolton, Carazzo, Malceski, C Cornes> Cough.

 

[Sainters08]

Yea..Larkis btw, My Team isent Team D

I Like my Midfield Rotations .

COUGH < Dal Santo, Mitchell, Foley, Kerr, Ablett Jnr, Priddis, Ling, J.Selwood, M.Murphy, Pendlebury, L.Ball, N.Jones > COUGH

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Yea..Larkis btw, My Team isent Team D

I Like my Midfield Rotations .

COUGH < Dal Santo, Mitchell, Foley, Kerr, Ablett Jnr, Priddis, Ling, J.Selwood, M.Murphy, Pendlebury, L.Ball, N.Jones > COUGH

What's the point of a midfield if the ball won't get near the goals?

 

[Sainters08]

What's the point of a midfield if the ball won't get near the goals?

whats the point of your Forwards if your midfielders cant get the ball?>

 

[Tarkyn_24]

whats the point of your Forwards if your midfielders cant get the ball?>

So i guess we're looking at a nil all draw, ey?

My defenders don't rush behinds.

 

[Sainters08]

So i guess we're looking at a nil all draw, ey?

My defenders don't rush behinds.

guess so...

mine wont either. coz they'll neva get the ball

 

[bhorjus]

I like Team B.

Though all teams do look very good.

 

[Bender571]

For me it was between before B & D.

I went with B because its midfield just looks to powerful, and would probably score about 70% of its teams goals.

 

[WestCoaster87]

Team D's backline lets them down big time, awesome forward line though but the backline swayed my vote.

 

[krisholio14]

Team A for me. Has the most balanced squad of the lot.

 

[The Juddernaught]

i voted D but it was pretty hard between that and team A. D's forwards were the difference that swung my choice

 

[Inferno]

Team A just over team B. I like A's midfield and forward like more while B has the best defence.

Also team D has 4 tall forwards which is very bad, plus they have Hall in there who is no good. It was bad enough that Farmer was picked ahead of Chapman and Sewell didn't even make an emergency spot... and isn't Thompson more of a midfielder?